Treatment FAQ

what is unfair about mr brocklehurst treatment of jane

by Mr. Ryan Gerhold Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago

His treatment of Jane is unfair for many reasons. He heard all of those things from Mrs. Reed who didn't really like Jane in the first place, he has never actually seen Jane act like that, and he hasn't been at the school watching her behavior.

Why is Jane worried when Mr Brocklehurst visits?

Jane is worried at his arrival, because she remembers Mrs. Reed's comments to him about Jane's deceitfulness and Mr. Brocklehurst's promise to warn the teachers at the school of Jane's unsavory character. During his visit, Jane accidentally drops her slate. Brocklehurst immediately brands her as careless.

What do you think about the treatment of the girls at Brocklehurst?

Brocklehurst's sadistic treatment of the girls serves only to destroy any self-worth in the children--not to mention in their health. I completely agree with accessteacher's post.

What does Jane note about Brocklehurst's daughters'hair?

As Brocklehurst lectures Miss Temple on the need to cut off the girls' long hair — it's a sign of vanity — his wife and daughters walk into the room, ornately dressed in velvet, silk, and furs. Jane notes that his daughters' hair is "elaborately curled" and that his wife wears fake French curls.

How does Brocklehurst justify his extreme lifestyle in the Crucible?

Brocklehurst justifies this extreme lifestyle by referring to Christian doctrines. Like the primitive Christians and tormented martyrs, the girls should revel in their suffering and accept Jesus' consolations. Brocklehurst's hypocrisy becomes most apparent when his own wife and daughters enter the classroom.

How does Brocklehurst humiliate Jane?

He told the teachers to punish Jane's body to make her a good person. 6. Brocklehurst said Jane must stand in front of the whole school for another half hour.

How does Brocklehurst treat Jane?

Brocklehurst immediately brands her as careless. Although Miss Temple tells her not to be afraid of punishment, Jane is soon made the dunce of the school. Brocklehurst stands her on a stool and announces to the entire school that Jane is a liar.

What does Brocklehurst say about Jane?

Mr Brocklehurst tells everyone at Lowood School that Jane is a liar. “A careless girl!” said Mr. Brocklehurst, and immediately after—“It is the new pupil, I perceive.” And before I could draw breath, “I must not forget I have a word to say respecting her.” Then aloud: how loud it seemed to me!

What does Mr. Brocklehurst complain about?

Mr. Brocklehurst is especially upset about the two times Miss Temple served the girls an extra lunch to make up for their burned porridge.

What makes Mr. Brocklehurst a hypocrite?

He enjoys the power he has and enjoys doling out punishments. Brocklehurst wants the pupils of Lowood School to be modest and pious and he cruelly restricts their food rations. This is hypocritical, as his family enjoys very fine things and is not deprived of anything.

Why does Brocklehurst call Jane a liar?

Brocklehurst; 'it is akin to falsehood, and all liars will have their portion in the lake burning with fire and brimstone.” Jane was severely humiliated at Lowood by standing on a stool and being called a liar by Mr. Brocklehurst.

What does Mr. Brocklehurst give Jane before he leaves?

As he leaves, Mr. Brocklehurst gives Jane a book called the Child's Guide, full of stories about sinful children who die unpleasantly. He tells her to read the story about Martha, who is a liar.

What happens to Brocklehurst in Jane Eyre?

Brocklehurst finally meets his comeuppance, as a public investigation reveals all his mistreatment. As such he is removed from an active role in the school, losing all his influence in how it is, and although remaining in his wealthy position, he loses all his credibility and is only mentioned twice more in the book.

What is Jane's first impression of Mr. Brocklehurst?

Jane's first impression of Mr. Brocklehurst is that he is like "a black pillar." Later she notices his features. What fairy tale character does her description of him bring to mind? She is accused of being deceitful, this is ironic because her aunt is the deceitful one.

Why was Jane filled with fear whenever Brocklehurst visits school?

Brocklehurst spends his time away from the school. When he returns, Jane becomes quite nervous because she remembers his promise to her aunt, Mrs. Reed, to warn the school about Jane's supposed habit of lying.

How did Jane's character change in her confrontation with both Mr. Brocklehurst and Mrs Reed?

How had Jane's character changed in her confrontation with both Mr. Brocklehurst and Mrs. Reed? She had found an inner-resolve and an adult like strength.

What does Helen tell Jane about how the students feel about Mr. Brocklehurst?

Helen tells Jane she is exaggerating: Only eighty people of the hundreds of millions in the world heard Brocklehurst, and most of those people probably pity, rather than dislike Jane. Miss Temple also befriends Jane, allowing her to present her side of the story.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9