Treatment FAQ

motivational interviewing recommended for treatment of depression? why or why not?

by Verna Lockman Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Mental Health Disorders Motivational Interviewing may be helpful for people with mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and bipolar disorder. It can provide support and guidance on how to make healthy changes to their diet and exercise habits.

Motivational interviewing used to treat depression specifically was found to result in a more favorable trajectory of the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 and a higher remission rate compared to standard management of depression.Jun 1, 2018

Full Answer

Can motivational interviewing be used to improve depression treatment?

This article presents a motivational interviewing, stepped-care approach that can be utilized to improve these encounters and decrease frustrations for all involved. Depression is the most common mental health disorder seen in primary care, 1 and numerous treatment options are available.

When is motivational interviewing most beneficial?

However, it is unclear for which behavioural problems and populations Motivational Interviewing is most beneficial, or in some cases, where there is evidence of no effect or possible harm.

Is motivational interviewing alone enough for recovery?

However, motivational interviewing alone is not enough for true recovery to take place, particularly when you are living with a severe psychological illness and/or struggling with any co-occurring disorders. Rather, it is best when integrated into a comprehensive curriculum of therapies.

What is motivational interviewing for addiction?

Motivational Interviewing as a Treatment for Addiction. The spirit of Motivational Interviewing is based on three key concepts: collaboration between the therapist and the person with the addiction, rather than confrontation by the therapist; drawing out the individual's ideas, rather the therapist imposing their ideas;

image

Can motivational interviewing be used for depression?

Motivational interviewing (MI; Miller & Rollnick, 1991, 2002) provides a framework for strengthening or modifying usual treatments of depression in adolescents. Arkowitz and Burke (2008) suggested three reasons why MI might be particularly appropriate for improving treatment response in clinical depression.

What are the benefits of using motivational interviewing?

The Benefits of Motivational Interviewing Benefits of motivational interviewing include: Helping clients to take responsibility for themselves and their actions. Encouraging clients to envision a future free of substance abuse or mental health struggles. Preparing clients to become more receptive to treatment.

When is motivational interviewing not appropriate?

Motivational Interviewing may not work well in treatment for trauma or depression. The patient needs to be ambivalent about changing their behavior, habits or lifestyle; MI doesn't work well if you're already highly motivated to make a change—or on the flip side, if you absolutely don't believe you have a problem.

What clients or disorder would benefit from motivational interviewing?

Motivational interviewing helps individuals with mental health conditions, including obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), depression, and anxiety.

Who does not benefit from motivational interviewing?

5 Cons. It will not work well for clients with trauma or depression, as motivation may be limited. It can be a dangerous approach for clients with bipolar conditions and schizophrenia. It will not work for a client already highly motivated to make a change.

Is motivational interviewing cost effective?

In two-way sensitivity analyses, MI was still relatively cost-effective for relapse prevention ($17,300/QALY saved) even if it cost as much as $2000/participant and was less effective.

What is motivational interviewing and when is it useful to be used?

Motivational interviewing is a counseling approach designed to help people find the motivation to make a positive behavior change. This client-centered approach is particularly effective for people who have mixed feelings about changing their behavior.

What is motivational interviewing used for in therapy?

Motivational Interviewing (MI) is a counseling approach designed to help individuals resolve ambivalence about their alcohol and/or drug use, and support efforts to change it. Motivational Interviewing (MI) is often delivered as a brief intervention based on client-centered principles.

What is motivational interviewing?

Motivational interviewing is a counseling approach designed to help people find the motivation to make a positive behavior change. This client-centered approach is particularly effective for people who have mixed feelings about changing their behavior.

What is the concept of a counselor drawing out a client's ideas rather than imposing their own opinions?

The notion of the counselor drawing out a client's ideas rather than imposing their own opinions is based on the belief that motivation to change comes from within. As such, it cannot come from the counselor.

How to support self efficacy?

Support Self-Efficacy. Self-efficacy is a person's belief or confidence in their ability to perform a target behavior. 2 A counselor following the motivational interviewing approach supports their client's self-efficacy by reinforcing their power to make the changes they want.

What is reflection in therapy?

Reflection is a foundational skill of motivational interviewing and how therapists express empathy.

What is the spirit of a therapist?

According to Miller and Rollnick, the "spirit" is collaborative, evocative, and honors client autonomy. 1. In order for motivational interviewing to be effective, the therapist must maintain this overall "spirit.".

What is collaboration instead of confrontation?

Collaboration Instead of Confrontation. Collaboration is a partnership formed between the counselor and the client. In motivational interviewing, this relationship is based on the point of view and experiences of the client.

Why are people reluctant to go to therapy?

People may initially be reluctant to go to therapy for fear of being judged by their therapist. Some may even feel guilty about their negative behavior, making that judgment valid in their eyes. But judgment is not what motivational interviewing is about.

What are the factors that contribute to depression?

There are also many factors that contribute to or exacerbate depression that medication alone cannot address (eg, marital/relational strife, difficulties with children, grief or loss, chronic or terminal illnesses, poor coping strategies), which often necessitate adjunctive treatment approaches and modalities.

How to treat mental health disorders?

When treating mental health disorders, it is essential to first explore patient preferences 10 and to establish what the patient already knows (including existing beliefs and practices) about depression and treatment options. Once the extent of the patient’s existing knowledge is established, the physician asks permission to provide additional information (responsive to what has been said by the patient). After sharing brief, concise information, the physician then explores the patient’s thoughts and feelings about what has been shared. The following dialogue provides an example:

Why use scaling questions?

The use of scaling questions to assess importance and confidence allows for a more nuanced, continuous approach to assessing readiness to change rather than a dichotomous one (yes/no; ready/not ready ). Patients usually feel ambivalent about change and are often having an inner dialogue about the pros and cons of behavior change. Scaling questions purposefully explore the patient’s needs, desire, ability, and readiness to change and are designed to evoke from the patient statements toward change or “change talk.” Patients are more likely to build self-motivation based on their own, rather than others’, arguments for change.

What are the barriers to change for patients who are presented with medication as the primary treatment option?

Some of the obstacles/barriers to change for patients who are presented with medication as the primary treatment option include cost, unwanted side effects, sub-therapeutic relief, risk of polypharmacy, and limited symptom reduction without remission.

Is depression a first line treatment?

Research on depression has revealed varying levels of effectiveness by modality, with medication, psychotherapy, or a combination of both consistently reported in the literature as first-line treatments. 2,3 The severity of the depression and functional impairment reported by the patient often determines the recommendation provided by the physician, such as:

Is depression a primary health problem?

Depression is the most common mental health disorder seen in primary care , 1 and numerous treatment options are available. Regardless of the treatment “prescribed” (ie, pharmacologic, psychotherapeutic, etc), there remains the clinical challenge of effectively engaging the patient in steps that will lead to behavior change, ...

Is depressive disorder prevalent in primary care?

ABSTRACT: Encounters with persons who have depressive disorders are prevalent in primary care. With all of the complexities of these encounters, these experiences can prove difficult for health care providers and patients alike. Patient-provider collaboration is an essential component to improved outcomes. This article presents a motivational interviewing, stepped-care approach that can be utilized to improve these encounters and decrease frustrations for all involved.

What is motivational interviewing?

Miller and Stephen Rollnick in the 1980s through their work with people struggling with alcohol use disorder, motivational interviewing (MI) is a person-centered, goal-oriented therapeutic approach designed to help resolve ambivalence and develop the motivation needed to make meaningful changes.

How does recovery work with mental illness?

When you’re struggling with mental illness or addiction, recovery depends not just on gaining insight into your condition, but on making emotional and behavioral changes to support recovery in concrete ways. However, making those changes can be hard, especially when you are still in the midst of psychological distress.

What is cognitive behavioral therapy?

For example, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is often an essential part of the recovery process for many people struggling with mental health disorders and addiction, but it relies on implementing specific behavioral techniques in order to overcome damaging emotional and behavioral patterns.

How does a therapist help you?

Rather, the therapist acts as a guide, helping draw out your own thoughts and feelings and harness your inner resources to engage in change. This not only helps you conceptualize change, it also helps you create a deep and lasting commitment to it because it comes from you rather than someone else.

What is MI therapy?

MI, however, recognizes the autonomy and right to self-determination of the client while emphas izing that there is no one right way to change. This can be deeply empowering and helps you appreciate the ability you have to control your own life. At the same time, it also helps you stay accountable for your own behaviors.

Is motivational interviewing a treatment?

Integrating Motivational Interviewing in Comprehensive Treatment. The broad applicability of motivational interviewing makes it ideally suited for anyone struggling with ambivalence, and it can be a core part of your healing process whether you are suffering from a mental health disorder, substance use disorder, or both.

What is motivational interviewing?

Motivational interviewing (MI) is a set of communication techniques that can spark behavior change in people with chronic conditions such as diabetes. This style of communication can be a dramatic shift for some providers.

Why is empathy important in medicine?

Over time, your empathy may help keep your patient motivated and lead to better health.

What Is Motivational Interviewing?

Motivational interviewing is a counseling technique that helps people with addictions and other behavioral health problems change their behavior. This is on the idea that people are more likely to make changes if they are motivated to do so.

Goal of Motivational Interviewing

The goal of Motivational Interviewing is to help people resolve any ambivalence they have about making changes, and start talking about the changes they want to make.

When To Use Motivational Interviewing?

These are some of the situations in which Motivational Interviewing may be useful:

Principles of Motivational Interviewing

These are some of the principles of Motivational Interviewing as identified by the developers:

Benefits of Motivational Interviewing

These are some of the benefits of Motivational Interviewing for counselors and clients:

Side-Effects of Motivational Interviewing

There are some potential side-effects of Motivational Interviewing that counselors should be aware of:

Conclusion

Motivational Interviewing is very helpful and effective in helping people make changes within various areas of their lives. It offers flexibility and promotes collaboration between the counselor and client. The benefits of this approach include increased motivation, empowerment, and self-efficacy.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9