Domestic Violence Treatment: Legal and Ethical Issues
- Any wound or other physical injury, either self-inflicted or other inflicted, by means of a firearm.
- Any wound or other physical injury inflicted upon the person where the injury is the result of assaultive or abusive...
Full Answer
Are You a victim of domestic violence?
If so, you are a victim of domestic violence. You are also the victim of crime. In 1994, Congress passed the Violence Against Women Act ("VAWA"). This Act, and the 1996 additions to the Act, recognize that domestic violence is a national crime and that federal laws can help an overburdened state and local criminal justice system.
Are there any federal laws against domestic violence?
Federal Domestic Violence Laws. You are also the victim of crime. In 1994, Congress passed the Violence Against Women Act ("VAWA"). This Act, and the 1996 additions to the Act, recognize that domestic violence is a national crime and that federal laws can help an overburdened state and local criminal justice system.
What is domestic violence treatment?
Domestic violence, also known as partner violence (PV), is a major social and public health problem in the United States. For the past three decades, individuals arrested for PV have been mandated to complete a course of treatment in accordance with the various standards in the states in which they were arrested.
Why don’t health providers assess for domestic violence?
Domestic violence is a highly prevalent event in the United States. Health providers frequently treat abused patients; however, many do not routinely assess for family violence or suspect it when the injuries seem fairly obvious. Because abused women feel stigmatized by the violence, they are hesitant to volunteer the abuse.
What are the legal consequences of abuse?
Domestic abuse cases often involve a number of criminal charges, including assault, battery, sexual assault, and rape. If criminal charges are brought against the offender, it can result in criminal penalties such as a jail or prison sentence, as well as monetary fines.
What are domestic violence issues?
Domestic violence refers to acts of violence that occur within intimate relationships and take place in domestic settings. It includes physical, sexual, emotional and psychological abuse. Family violence is a broader term that refers to violence between family members, as well as violence between intimate partners.
What does the Australian law say about domestic violence?
The law can do much to discourage domestic violence – by making it a crime and attaching penalties intended both to punish and to deter offenders and would-be offenders, and by establishing mechanisms (such as protection orders) designed to protect and assist the persons against whom domestic violence is perpetrated or ...
Is domestic violence a human rights issue?
Although international human rights instruments and institutions have only recently acknowledged domestic violence as a human rights violation, the right to life and to bodily integrity are core fundamental rights that are protected under international law.
Why is domestic violence a big issue?
Domestic violence is a serious problem around the world. It violates the fundamental human rights of women and often results in serious injury or death. While statistics vary slightly, women are victims of violence in approximately 95% of the cases of domestic violence.
When did domestic violence become illegal?
Domestic Violence and Matrimonial Proceedings Act 1976. The Domestic Violence and Matrimonial Proceedings Act 1976 is the first piece of legislation dedicated to combating domestic violence. It gives victims new rights by offering civil protection orders for those at risk of abuse.
What were the new laws against domestic violence introduced?
The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act 2005 is an Act of the Parliament of India enacted to protect women from domestic violence. It was brought into force by the Indian government and Ministry of Women and Child Development on 26 October 2006.
Why is domestic violence a problem in Australia?
Women living in rural and remote areas Factors such as access to services, a perceived lack of confidentiality and anonymity, stigma attached to the public disclosure of violence and lack of transport and telecommunications may compound the isolation victims of domestic violence already experience as part of the abuse.
Which court deals with domestic violence in Australia?
32.33 As noted above, in Australia there are family violence courts in NSW, Victoria, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia, and the ACT. All these are part of the local or magistrates court in the relevant jurisdiction.
How the law the citizens and community can protect and support victims of human rights violations?
On the support of victims of human rights violation, the law should clearly state and express the repercussions of violating human rights. The citizen on the other hand should be well versed with human rights and should report any violator of human rights to the relevant authorities for immediate action to be taken.
How does the domestic violence Act protect citizens against human right violations?
Brief Description. This act defines domestic violence as an attack against someone by any other person with whom that they are presently, or have been in a domestic relationship. It also provides protection for victims of domestic violence and seeks to punish the perpetrators of such crimes.
Which laws protect citizens from human rights violations?
Bill of Rights Chapter 2, Section 7-39Rights.Application.Equality.Human dignity.Life.Freedom and security of the person.Slavery, servitude and forced labour.Privacy.More items...
THE INITIAL INTERVIEW
What information must the domestic violence treatment program collect and discuss with the client during the intake process or assessment interview? Treatment programs must conduct an individual, complete clinical intake and assessment interview with each perpetrator who has been accepted into the treatment program.
CONTRACT YOU SIGN AS PART OF PROGRAM
The contract between each participant and the domestic violence treatment program must include the following elements:
TREATMENT ITSELF – WHAT IS REQUIRED
All participants in domestic violence treatment must attend consecutive, weekly group treatment sessions. The program must assign each participant to a home group and the participant must be required to attend the same scheduled group each week.
Robert Rhodes
With a successful background in law, courtrooms, wrestling, rugby and jujitsu, Robert Rhodes’s nature is well-suited for argument and litigation. Mr. Rhodes knows how to talk clearly and directly to his clients, adversaries and to the Court. His common sense, straight talk and experience put his clients immediately at ease. Mr.
What are the rights of a domestic violence victim?
Section 10606 (b): 1) The right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and privacy ; 2) The right to be reasonable protected from the accused offender; 3) The right to be notified of court proceedings;
What rights do victims have in VAWA?
A victim in a VAWA case shall have the right to speak to the Judge at a bail hearing to inform the Judge of any danger posed by the release of the defendant. Any victim of a crime of violence shall also have the right to address the Court in person at the time of sentencing. Victims' Rights. A federal domestic violence victim has ...
What is a VAWA case?
In a VAWA case, the Court must order restitution to pay the victim the full amount of loss.
When did the Violence Against Women Act come into effect?
You are also the victim of crime. In 1994, Congress passed the Violence Against Women Act ("VAWA"). This Act, and the 1996 additions to the Act, recognize that domestic violence is a national crime and that federal laws can help an overburdened state and local criminal justice system. In 1994 and 1996, congress also passed changes to ...
What are the losses of a civil protection order?
These losses include costs for medical or psychological care, physical therapy, transportation, temporary housing, child care expenses, loss of income, attorney's fees, costs incurred in obtaining a civil protection order, and any other losses suffered by the victim as a result of the offense.
Is domestic violence a felony?
All the federal domestic violence crimes are felonies. It is a federal crime under the Violence Against Women Act ("VAWA"): to cross state lines or enter or leave Indian country and physically injure an "intimate partner"; to cross state lines to stalk or harass or to stalk or harass within the maritime or territorial lands of the United States ...
Is it normal to feel scared when you are a victim of domestic violence?
If you are the victim of a domestic violence crime, it is normal to feel scared, helpless, and vulnerable. Remember, you are not alone. The following agencies exist to help:
Why are domestic violence clients less motivated than other clients?
First, many domestic violence clients are generally less motivated than other clients who usually seek services as a result of their own realization of their need for treatment or the value of such services.
Why is reporting a domestic violence case important?
The problem of reporting is critical in cases of domestic violence as treatment decisions will be made based on the types of abuse occurring within the family and reports of child abuse may ultimately affect the clients status within the criminal justice system.
What are pre-existing agreements between the provider and referral agency?
There also may be pre-existing agreements between the provider and referral agency (e.g., probation) mandating disclosures specific to the domestic violence issue , such as reoffenses, drug or alcohol relapses, violations of the law, etc..
What is informed consent?
Informed consent statements often include policies regarding confidentiality, fees, insurance, missed sessions, both patient and therapist vacations, emergencies and termination of treatment. A program may want to make a distinction between informed consent and program rules.
What is the law governing mental health?
Laws governing the practice of mental health professionals are specifically articulated in the licensing law . Most states have a section in their licensing law that lists grounds revocation or suspension of a license.
Is failure to report a child abuse violation a misdemeanor?
Like the child abuse reporting law, failure to report is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine and/or imprisonment. For a short period of time, there was talk in California about using the adult dependent abuse law to justify the reporting of domestic violence with victims seeking psychotherapy services.
Is domestic violence a result of social forces?
The domestic violence field has been slow to adapt this view. Historically, feminist activists have believe d that violence is a result of social forces, psychologists have tended to focus on the individual and systemic theorists have argued that family dynamics are the main contributors to violence.
Get Help
If you are in immediate danger, call 911. OVW does not provide services directly to the general public. Find local help on our map or call the national hotline:
What is Domestic Violence
The term “domestic violence” includes felony or misdemeanor crimes of violence committed by a current or former spouse or intimate partner of the victim, by a person with whom the victim shares a child in common, by a person who is cohabitating with or has cohabitated with the victim as a spouse or intimate partner, by a person similarly situated to a spouse of the victim under the domestic or family violence laws of the jurisdiction receiving grant monies, or by any other person against an adult or youth victim who is protected from that person’s acts under the domestic or family violence laws of the jurisdiction..
Domestic Violence Resources
Looking for information that used to be on OVW's website? Visit OVW's archive .
What is domestic violence?
Domestic violence is a serious issue affecting millions around the world. The most pervasive form of violence experienced by women in Australia is violence perpetrated by a male intimate partner, commonly referred to as domestic violence.
Why do people not report domestic violence?
Reasons for non-reporting incidents of domestic violence are complex but may include fear of the perpetrator, fear of not being believed or of being blamed, feelings of confusion, shame and embarrassment, fear of psychologically reliving the incident, or a reluctance to acknowledge the incident ever occurred.
What is the DVO in Australia?
At the Council of Australian Governments’ (COAG) meeting in April 2015, various efforts to reduce violence against women were discussed, including the progress of the National Domestic Violence Order (DVO) scheme and an information sharing system.
What powers do police use to enforce laws?
In responding to domestic violence and in obtaining civil protection orders, police may use powers and procedures mainly designed to enforce criminal laws—powers of entry, search, seizure, arrest, direction and detention. [122] .
What is the role of police in domestic violence?
As stated in the ALRC/NSWLRC report, the police play a key role in responding to domestic violence , and are often the first point of contact for many. Police are responsible for recording incidents, interviewing victims and collecting evidence to support charges and applying for protection orders in the civil system. It is well recognised that initial positive police response is vital not only to the safety of those affected, but also to whether they report any further victimisation, or seek engagement with the legal system more generally. [120] In most jurisdictions in Australia, there are specialised police units in the areas of domestic or family violence, sexual assault and child protection. [121]
What is the primary approach to preventing domestic violence?
A public health approach to preventing domestic violence classifies preventative strategies into primary, secondary and tertiary strategy, although the differences between the levels are not always clear-cut. Primary prevention strategies aim to prevent domestic violence before it begins, whereas secondary prevention is focused on at-risk populations and tertiary prevention aims to prevent reoccurrence of violence after it has occurred. [55]
What is the National Plan to Reduce Violence against Women and Children?
In its National Plan to Reduce Violence against Women and Children 2010–2022 (National Plan), the Council of Australian Governments targets domestic, family and sexual violence and provides definitions of these three terms:
What is domestic violence?
Domestic violence, also known as partner violence (PV), is a major social and public health problem in the United States. For the past three decades, individuals arrested for PV have been mandated to complete a course of treatment in accordance with the various standards in the states in which they were arrested.
Is level IV evidence based?
Level IV information is the least reliable and policies and interventions based on this alone cannot be considered evidence-based. Based on these criteria, current policies on batterer intervention are not evidence-based for a number of reasons.
Is there evidence that treatment should be limited to one particular modality?
There does not appear to be clear-cut evidence that treatment should be limited to one particular modality. Due to serious mental health or personality issues, some offenders are too disruptive in a group setting and may be required to enroll in individual counseling, but research is inconclusive as to whether individual therapy is superior to group for partner-violent offenders (Murphy & Eckhardt, 2005). With respect to couples work, one RAC study found offenders in couples treatment less likely to re-offend during a follow-up period compared to offenders in a Duluth-type group (Brannen & Rubin, 1996). Both single-couple and multi-couple formats have been shown to significantly reduce recidivism when compared to no-treatment control groups, with the multi-couple format somewhat more effective (Stith et al., 2004). The few remaining studies using RAC or quasi-experimental designs found no significant difference between modalities of group versus couples (see Eckhardt et al., 2012). One important caveat is that all of the interventions targeted only low-moderate risk male offenders. Nevertheless, Level I and II experimental studies (Eckhardt et al., 2012) and Level III program reviews (e.g., Geffner et al., 1989; Shupe et al., 1989) have shown the couples format to be as safe for victims as traditional group programs. The objection to couples treatment are based on qualitative reports or clinical experience and therefore not evidence-based.
Does Gondolf's study show recidivism?
A quasi-experiment al study by Gondolf (2007) found no difference in recidivism between African American offenders who completed a heterogeneous group versus those who completed a culturally focused homogeneous group limited to African Americans.
How prevalent is domestic violence?
Domestic violence is a highly prevalent event in the United States. Health providers frequently treat abused patients; however, many do not routinely assess for family violence or suspect it when the injuries seem fairly obvious. Because abused women feel stigmatized by the violence, they are hesitant to volunteer the abuse. In 1990, the Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations added requirements for emergency and ambulatory care services to develop and use protocols for the identification of violence among patients. This article addresses the ethical and legal dilemmas facing nurses that influence their assessment and intervention in family violence.
Why are women hesitant to volunteer for abuse?
Because abused women feel stigmatized by the violence, they are hesitant to volunteer the abuse. In 1990, the Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations added requirements for emergency and ambulatory care services to develop and use protocols for the identification of violence among patients.
The Initial Interview
Contract You Sign as Part of Program
- The contract between each participant and the domestic violence treatment program must include the following elements: A statement regarding the treatment program’s philosophy that: (a) The victim may not be blamed for the participant’s abuse; (b) The perpetrator must stop all forms of abuse; (c) An abuser is to be held accountable for the abusers ...
Treatment Itself – What Is Required
- All participants in domestic violence treatment must attend consecutive, weekly group treatment sessions. The program must assign each participant to a home group and the participant must be required to attend the same scheduled group each week. The program’s director must authorize any exceptions to this requirement and document the reason for the exception. The group size i…