Treatment FAQ

how has treatment of gender identity disorder changed over time

by Helene Ritchie Sr. Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

In contrast to the treatment of other DSM diagnoses where emphasis is on changing thoughts, feelings and behaviors, the treatment of GID from adolescence onward often emphasizes modification of the body.

With the publication of DSM–5 in 2013, “gender identity disorder” was eliminated and replaced with “gender dysphoria.” This change further focused the diagnosis on the gender identity-related distress that some transgender people experience (and for which they may seek psychiatric, medical, and surgical treatments) ...

Full Answer

What are the treatment options for gender identity disorder?

But treatment needs to be individualized. What might help one person might not help another. The process might or might not involve a change in gender expression or body modifications. Treatment options might include changes in gender expression and role, hormone therapy, surgery, and behavioral therapy.

How can I change my gender identity?

1 Changes in gender expression and role. This might involve living part time or full time in another gender role that is consistent with your gender identity. 2 Medical treatment. Some people use hormone therapy to seek maximum feminization or masculinization. ... 3 Behavioral health treatment. ... 4 Other steps. ...

Is gender identity disorder changing in DSM-5?

A draft proposal of DSM-5 has been submitted, in which the diagnostic name of gender identity disorder has been changed to gender dysphoria. Also, it refers to 'assigned gender' rather than to 'sex', and includes disorders of sexual development. Moreover, the subclassifications regarding sexual orientation have been deleted.

What happens at a gender identity clinic?

People who present at a gender identity clinic usually state that they have transsexualism and seek immediate treatment with hormones, surgery or both. They may arrive at this point from any of a number of rather distinct earlier trajectories.

What is the first step in reversible gender change?

What are the disciplines involved in gender identity?

Can androgens be used for female patients?

Can androgen insensitivity cause gender identity disorder?

Is transsexualism a disorder?

Is gender identity a mental illness?

Is gender identity disorder common?

See more

About this website

image

How can we solve the problem of gender identity?

Where to Begin?Do Your Research. There is growing recognition that gender is not a simple binary (male and female), but rather a spectrum. ... Show Respect. Be respectful of an individual's affirmed gender identity, name, and pronouns. ... Be an ally and advocate. ... Get support if needed.

What is the most effective treatment for gender dysphoria?

Hormone therapy for adults The hormones usually need to be taken for the rest of your life, even if you have gender surgery. It's important to remember that hormone therapy is only one of the treatments for gender dysphoria. Others include voice therapy and psychological support.

Why did they change the name of gender identity disorder?

The diagnosis was renamed from gender identity disorder to gender dysphoria, after criticisms that the former term was stigmatizing. Subtyping by sexual orientation was deleted. The diagnosis for children was separated from that for adults, as "gender dysphoria in children".

How do you deal with dysphoria MTF?

Exercise – a healthy amount of exercise can improve your mood. Do what you like - dance your heart out in your bedroom, do some yoga, ride a bike, go to circus classes, use the local park gym equipment, or look up exercises that will shape your body in ways that could reduce your dysphoria.

Is there a way to change gender without surgery?

Hormone therapy can help you achieve more masculine or feminine characteristics. Commonly prescribed by a primary care provider or endocrinologist, hormone treatments can be part of a presurgical plan or a stand-alone service.

How do schools deal with gender dysphoria?

Talk with your school counselor about getting them an IEP or 504 plan to accommodate their needs. If they start to miss too much school due to anxiety, schedule an appointment with a psychiatrist to have a consult on the option of using medication as a tool.

When did the concept of gender change?

It was in the 1970s that feminist scholars adopted the term gender as way of distinguishing "socially constructed" aspects of male–female differences (gender) from "biologically determined" aspects (sex).

Who was the first man to become a woman?

Lili Elbe, birth name Einar Wegener, Einar also spelled Ejner, (born December 28, 1882, Vejle, Denmark—died September 13, 1931, Dresden, Germany), Danish painter who was assigned male at birth, experienced what is now called gender dysphoria, and underwent the world's first documented sex reassignment surgery.

What are the 4 genders?

There are four different types of genders that apply to living and nonliving objects.Masculine gender: It is used to denote a male subtype. ... Feminine gender: It is used to denote the female subtype. ... Neuter gender: It is used to denote nonliving and lifeless things. ... Common gender: It denotes either a male or female sex.

How do I know if I have MTF?

You may feel:certain that your gender identity conflicts with your biological sex.comfortable only when in the gender role of your preferred gender identity (may include non-binary)a strong desire to hide or be rid of physical signs of your biological sex, such as breasts or facial hair.More items...

Can gender dysphoria be caused by trauma?

Gender dysphoria currently exists as a mental health diagnosis, perpetuating stigma as well as pathologizing gender variance. Clinical social workers have preserved a harmful formulation that gender dysphoria is a disorder caused by trauma.

Can puberty cause gender dysphoria?

Additionally, while some transgender adolescents have shown gender non-conformity since early childhood, other adolescents might experience gender dysphoria during or after the onset of pubertal physical changes. Some adolescents may have kept their gender incongruence to themselves for a long time.

What is the first step in reversible gender change?

As mentioned earlier, reversible changes should precede irreversible changes. It follows from this that the first step should be a change of social gender role. This involves the patient changing their name to one clearly appropriate to their preferred gender role, and altering all their associated civil and legal documentation. They should make it clear to everyone that they have changed their social gender role. In the UK, people doing this are protected from discrimination in the workplace and elsewhere by the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

What are the disciplines involved in gender identity?

Disorders of gender identity involve a greater number of disciplines than most other areas of psychiatry.#N#Footnote#N#a Endocrinologists, speech and language therapists, and surgeons (ears, nose and throat, plastic and urological) are routinely involved. Further, the field is highly politicised, attracting much public fascination and arousing strong opinions.

Can androgens be used for female patients?

Female patients require treatment with androgens, either by implant or by intramuscular injection. Oral treatment is anecdotally associated with a raised rate of hepatocellular carcinoma. It is thus ethically and legally challenging to use oral agents (#N#Reference Seal and Barrett#N#Seal 2007 ).

Can androgen insensitivity cause gender identity disorder?

Rarely, partial androgen insensitivity syndromes may cause cross-gender identification and males with these syndromes would qualify for a diagnosis of gender identity disorder (not otherwise specified) because there is an abnormality of endocrine function. These syndromes can only be detected with the endocrine expertise and complex pathological testing offered by a gender identity clinic. They cannot be detected if hormone treatment has already started. The presence of a partial androgen insensitivity syndrome does not greatly alter the subsequent management of the affected patient but is important because, as inherited conditions, they may affect the sons of the patient’s sisters. Genetic counselling may be indicated (#N#Reference Seal and Barrett#N#Seal 2007 ).

Is transsexualism a disorder?

There is a public and to some extent a general psychiatric perception that transsexualism is the only or at least the main disorder of gender identity. This is illusory (#N#Reference Levine#N#Levine 1980 ), but the illusion persists in part because most dual-role transvestites do not come to the attention of psychiatric services. Certainly, transsexualism is the diagnosis for which most treatment evidence is available. There is little research into dual-role transvestism, nor much into dysmorphophobia or autogynaephilia presenting as or relating to a gender identity disorder (#N#Reference Blanchard#N#Blanchard 1991,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#1993a ,b,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#c,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#d ), even though these are important differential diagnoses and there is the suggestion that non-transsexual disorders of gender identity are more associated with psychopathology (#N#Reference Miach, Berah and Butcher#N#Miach 2000 ). These differential diagnoses may require different management to transsexualism (#N#Reference Blanchard, Steiner and Clemmensen#N#Blanchard 1989 ).

Is gender identity a mental illness?

Currently, in ICD-10 ( World Health Organization 1992 ), disorders of gender identity are classified not as mental illnesses but as disorders of adult personality and behaviour ( Box 1 ).

Is gender identity disorder common?

Gender identity disorders are not common. The most frequent is dual-role transvestism, but it rarely needs medical attention. The least frequent is transsexualism. Transsexualism is not usually indicative of serious psychopathology. Diagnoses should be made by a gender identity clinic and never by the patient, and a clear change of gender role should precede any hormone treatment. Patients must have lived and thrived entirely in their new gender role for at least 2 years before any genital surgery is undertaken. However, bilateral mastectomy might be considered for females after a year of life in a male role. With these selection criteria, the outcomes of surgery are generally good. In the UK, individuals may legally change their recorded sex, usually after gender reassignment treatment.

Is GID a DSM?

It is important that journalists and others in the media be aware of this approved change in the DSM-V and acknowledge that the term "Gender Identity Disorder" (GID) will no longer be used by many healthcare professionals.

Is the DSM V a stigma?

Some transgender advocates see this approved change in the DSM-V as an important step toward removing stigma against transgender people based on false stereotypes about gender identity and expression, as well as the word "disorder.". Transgender people may no longer be subject to a lifelong default diagnosis of their mental health.

Can transgender people be subject to a mental health diagnosis?

Transgender people may no longer be subject to a lifelong default diagnosis of their mental health. This approved change follows previous statements from the APA on mental healthcare for transgender people.

What is gender identity disorder?

It involves a conflict between a person’s physical or assigned gender and the gender with which he / she / they identify. People with this disorder may feel very uncomfortable with their assigned gender and with their body (particularly developments during puberty) or uncomfortable with the expected roles of the assigned gender.

Symptoms of gender identity disorder

It can be different in different age groups, below are the criteria that health professionals look for to diagnose it in children, adolescents and adults.

Causes of gender identity disorder

There is no clearly understood or universally accepted cause, however, most experts agree that there may be a strong biological basis for the disorder.

Treatment for gender identity disorder

Individual and family counseling is recommended for children, and individual or couples therapy is recommended for adults. Sex reassignment through surgery and hormone therapy is an option, but identity issues can continue after this treatment and should be discussed in psychotherapy.

What is gender identity?

Genderidentityis typically defined as the concept of the self as male or female. But the reality of gender identity is far more complex since gender variance is not uncommon. For example, gender identity may differ from an individual’s birth-assigned gender.

What is transgender people?

Transgender people include those whose gender identity does not match their assigned gender. And transgender people differ. While some experience distress and want to live as the other gender, this is not true of all transgender individuals (Cohen-Kettenis & Pfafflin, 2010).

When do children identify themselves as boys?

Developmentally, most children identify themselves as a “boy” or a “girl” by age three.

Is gender identity different from sexual orientation?

And gender identity is different than sexual orientation(e.g., a transwoman who identifies as a woman although their birth sex was male, may be straight, gay, or bisexual). Shawn Meghan Burn. It's also important to recognize that not everyone is clearly biologically male or female.

What are the treatment options for gender dysphoria?

Treatment options might include changes in gender expression and role, hormone therapy, surgery, and behavioral therapy. If you have gender dysphoria, seek help from a doctor who has expertise in the care of transgender people.

What is gender dysphoria?

Gender dysphoria involves feelings of distress due to a strong desire to be of another gender than the one assigned and by the extent and pervasiveness of gender-variant activities and interests.

What is the procedure to change breasts?

Surgery, such as feminizing surgery or masculinizing surgery to change the breasts or chest, external genitalia, internal genitalia, facial features, and body contouring. Some people use hormone therapy to seek maximum feminization or masculinization.

Is surgery necessary for gender dysphoria?

Treatments are based on your goals, as well as an evaluation of the risks and benefits of medication use, the presence of any other conditions, and consideration of your social and economic issues. Many people also find that surgery is necessary to relieve their gender dysphoria.

Does behavioral therapy help with gender dysphoria?

Behavioral therapy isn't intended to alter your gender identity. Instead, therapy can help you explore gender concerns and find ways to lessen gender dysphoria.

How many studies did Junge and Pfäfflin review?

The review by Pfäfflin and Junge ( 1992, 1998) included only 14 studies of MtF (male-to-female), 9 studies of FtM (female-to-male), and 2 studies that did not distinguish between MtF and Ft M with an average follow-up period of more than 5 years. Yet, most of them comprised a very small sample.

Where was the forensic psychology study conducted?

The current study was conducted in the Section of Forensic Psychotherapy at the Department of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy, University Hospital Ulm, Germany. Since the early 1990s, this department has been a point of contact for patients with gender identity disorders. The Ethics Committee at the University of Ulm discussed the concept of the study on January 11, 2010 and did not object to its implementation.

What is the first step in reversible gender change?

As mentioned earlier, reversible changes should precede irreversible changes. It follows from this that the first step should be a change of social gender role. This involves the patient changing their name to one clearly appropriate to their preferred gender role, and altering all their associated civil and legal documentation. They should make it clear to everyone that they have changed their social gender role. In the UK, people doing this are protected from discrimination in the workplace and elsewhere by the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

What are the disciplines involved in gender identity?

Disorders of gender identity involve a greater number of disciplines than most other areas of psychiatry.#N#Footnote#N#a Endocrinologists, speech and language therapists, and surgeons (ears, nose and throat, plastic and urological) are routinely involved. Further, the field is highly politicised, attracting much public fascination and arousing strong opinions.

Can androgens be used for female patients?

Female patients require treatment with androgens, either by implant or by intramuscular injection. Oral treatment is anecdotally associated with a raised rate of hepatocellular carcinoma. It is thus ethically and legally challenging to use oral agents (#N#Reference Seal and Barrett#N#Seal 2007 ).

Can androgen insensitivity cause gender identity disorder?

Rarely, partial androgen insensitivity syndromes may cause cross-gender identification and males with these syndromes would qualify for a diagnosis of gender identity disorder (not otherwise specified) because there is an abnormality of endocrine function. These syndromes can only be detected with the endocrine expertise and complex pathological testing offered by a gender identity clinic. They cannot be detected if hormone treatment has already started. The presence of a partial androgen insensitivity syndrome does not greatly alter the subsequent management of the affected patient but is important because, as inherited conditions, they may affect the sons of the patient’s sisters. Genetic counselling may be indicated (#N#Reference Seal and Barrett#N#Seal 2007 ).

Is transsexualism a disorder?

There is a public and to some extent a general psychiatric perception that transsexualism is the only or at least the main disorder of gender identity. This is illusory (#N#Reference Levine#N#Levine 1980 ), but the illusion persists in part because most dual-role transvestites do not come to the attention of psychiatric services. Certainly, transsexualism is the diagnosis for which most treatment evidence is available. There is little research into dual-role transvestism, nor much into dysmorphophobia or autogynaephilia presenting as or relating to a gender identity disorder (#N#Reference Blanchard#N#Blanchard 1991,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#1993a ,b,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#c,#N#Reference Blanchard#N#d ), even though these are important differential diagnoses and there is the suggestion that non-transsexual disorders of gender identity are more associated with psychopathology (#N#Reference Miach, Berah and Butcher#N#Miach 2000 ). These differential diagnoses may require different management to transsexualism (#N#Reference Blanchard, Steiner and Clemmensen#N#Blanchard 1989 ).

Is gender identity a mental illness?

Currently, in ICD-10 ( World Health Organization 1992 ), disorders of gender identity are classified not as mental illnesses but as disorders of adult personality and behaviour ( Box 1 ).

Is gender identity disorder common?

Gender identity disorders are not common. The most frequent is dual-role transvestism, but it rarely needs medical attention. The least frequent is transsexualism. Transsexualism is not usually indicative of serious psychopathology. Diagnoses should be made by a gender identity clinic and never by the patient, and a clear change of gender role should precede any hormone treatment. Patients must have lived and thrived entirely in their new gender role for at least 2 years before any genital surgery is undertaken. However, bilateral mastectomy might be considered for females after a year of life in a male role. With these selection criteria, the outcomes of surgery are generally good. In the UK, individuals may legally change their recorded sex, usually after gender reassignment treatment.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9