Examples of Informed Consent Cases A landmark case in informed consent occurred after a young patient, 19-year-old Jerry Canterbury, underwent a spinal surgery that left him paralyzed in 1959. Canterbury claimed that the surgeon did not inform him of the risks and described the procedure as routine and ordinary.
Full Answer
What does consent to treatment include?
As such, consent to treatment encompasses permission for all modalities of the assessment processes, diagnostic investigations, and procedures and (or) ongoing monitoring for same, as well as physical, medical or psychotherapeutic interventions.
What are some recent cases dealing with the law of consent?
There have been a number of cases dealing with the law of consent to medical treatment in recent years, the most notable of which was the Supreme Court decision in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015], a case which redefined the legal relationship between doctors and patients.
What happens to informed consent when a patient regains capacity?
If a patient regains capacity, the duty of informed consent returns to the patient and the role of the proxy in informed decision making is extinguished. This is why reassessment of the patient’s capacity is essential.
How should practicing nurses help patients obtain informed consent?
As practicing nurses, we should act as advocates, and build rapport with our client to facilitate the process of obtaining informed consent; Tschudin (2002) affirms that it is also a caring act that involves connecting one another. The next few paragraphs, the professional, ethical and legal drivers will be identified and explained.
What are some examples of informed consent?
I understand that my participation is voluntary and that I am free to withdraw at any time, without giving a reason and without cost. I understand that I will be given a copy of this consent form. I voluntarily agree to take part in this study.
What are 4 things to remember when obtaining consent?
There are 4 components of informed consent including decision capacity, documentation of consent, disclosure, and competency.
How do you explain consent to a patient?
Obtaining informed consent in medicine is process that should include: (1) describing the proposed intervention, (2) emphasizing the patient's role in decision-making, (3) discussing alternatives to the proposed intervention, (4) discussing the risks of the proposed intervention and (5) eliciting the patient's ...
What should be included in informed consent for therapy?
The informed consent agreementThe nature of all services provided.Any issues related to purposes, goals, techniques, procedures, limitations, potential risks, and benefits.The counselor's qualifications, credentials, relevant experience, and approach to the counseling they're providing.More items...•
How would you properly obtain consent?
Several key considerations for obtaining informed consent are described below:Timing. ... Ongoing conversation. ... Additional approaches. ... Qualifications of person obtaining consent. ... Subject ability and willingness to consent. ... Explain the study to the potential subject verbally.More items...•
What are the 5 essential components of informed consent in the therapeutic setting?
In current clinical practice, these four elements translate into five components that should be included in a discussion seeking to obtain informed consent: the diagnosis, the proposed treatment, the attendant risks and benefits of the treatment, alternative treatments and their risks and benefits, and the risks and ...
What are the 4 types of consent?
Implied Consent. Participation in a certain situation is sometimes considered proof of consent. ... Explicit Consent. ... Active Consent. ... Passive Consent. ... Opt-Out Consent. ... Key Takeaway.
Why is consent to treatment important?
If adult patients are mentally able to make their own decisions, medical care cannot begin unless they give informed consent. The informed consent process makes sure that your health care provider has given you information about your condition along with testing and treatment options before you decide what to do.
Why is consent important in healthcare?
Nurses and other health professionals are required to obtain valid consent before starting any form of treatment or intervention. Even when they give consent, patients may withdraw it at any point, and professionals must generally respect patients' wishes, regardless of their own personal views.
What is the significance of the Supreme Court decision on consent?
This is a very significant decision. The Supreme Court has rejected a clinician-centred and paternalistic approach to consent, replacing paternalism with patient autonomy. The decision has great significance for clinical negligence cases and a number of claimants have since amended their pleadings to allege lack of consent.
Why was the issue not resolved solely on the basis of expert evidence?
However the claimant’s case was that the issue could not be resolved solely on the basis of expert evidence because it was one of consent: her mother should have been advised of the material risk of injury and been able to elect for a Caesarean at this stage.
What is the significance of the case of Montgomery?
There are some interesting features of this case. The first is that it made plain some of the concerns within the medical profession about the impact of the decision in Montgomery. The Defendant’s expert obstetrician described it as creating challenges for obstetricians. He was concerned it would be impractical to raise options of foetal blood sampling or Caesarean section at every clinical encounter, particularly during the dynamic and highly charged process of labour.
Why was Ms Montgomery admitted to hospital?
Ms Montgomery was admitted to hospital in Lanarkshire for the delivery of her baby. There was a relatively high risk of shoulder dystocia of 9-10% because of the mother’s diabetes and her small size. There was a relatively low risk of prolonged hypoxia from shoulder dystocia of around 0.1%.
What did the Supreme Court reject?
The Supreme Court therefore rejected application of the Bolam test to a doctor’s duty to advise. The test was not whether a doctor acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical practitioners but was based instead on what a particular patient would expect to know.
What was the change in the social, medical and legal landscape since the Sidaway?
Behind the scenes there had been a change in the social, medical and legal landscape since Sidaway. People were now regarded as autonomous bearers of rights, governing their own lives and making choices for themselves. They had more access to medical information through the internet and information leaflets.
Is David Spencer v Hillingdon Hospital a consent case?
David Spencer v Hillingdon Hospital NHS Trust [2015] is not a case about consent but develops the implications of Montgomery in defining a doctor’s duty to advise in a different context.
Text preview of this essay
This page of the essay has 2,580 words. Download the full version above.
About this essay
If you use part of this page in your own work, you need to provide a citation, as follows:
What happens when informed consent is obtained?
When informed consent is obtained, it acts as a safeguard against legality issues; battery and false imprisonment. However nurses may be faced with obstructions such as time constrains and may choose to obtain implied consent instead.
What is informed consent?
Informed consent is a requirement necessary prior to any invasive procedure to be performed.
Is informed consent required in nursing?
As much as possible, informed consent in nursing procedures should also be included. Consent differs from informed consent. Consent is the act of asking approval to proceed onto a procedure. Conversely, informed consent is a process in which all information relayed is understood by the receiver and decides independently.
Optimal Communication
At the beginning of the session,” complained one client, “my massage therapist started chanting. I didn’t understand what he was doing. It really freaked me out, but I didn’t say anything.”
No Surprises
It’s important to have a written explanation of the services you offer, along with a listing of their benefits and risks, if any. Give this to every new client and ensure they have time to read it and ask questions before you start working with them. As therapists, we take some aspects of bodywork for granted, but our clients may not.
The Right of Refusal
The inherent power difference in our relationships with our clients makes it easy for them to slip into a compliant, passive role. As already mentioned, clients may be reluctant to refuse, interrupt, or stop a treatment for fear of offending.
What is the process of giving informed consent?
For any type of medical care that comes with significant risks, the informed consent that must be given is more complex. There is a process that physicians are supposed to go through to make sure the patient can actually give reliable informed consent: Providing adequate information about benefits and risks.
Why is informed consent important?
Informed consent is important for patient safety because, when done correctly, it means a patient or the person caring for the patient has all the information necessary to make the right decision about a procedure, treatment, or diagnostic test. When a patient does not have all the information, specifically about risks, ...
What does "simple informed consent" mean?
It means that the patient is given information about care and consents to receive that care. Simple informed consent happens all the time. When a patient takes and uses a prescription from a doctor, sees a recommended specialist, or allows a blood or urine test to be conducted, he or she is consenting after the doctor makes a simple explanation ...
What does it mean when a doctor says no informed consent?
A failure to get signed consent may be proof that there was no informed consent, even if the doctor says that the patient gave verbal consent. Each state has its own laws about what constitutes informed consent, so malpractice cases can vary a lot depending on location.
What happens if a patient does not have all the information?
When a patient does not have all the information, specifically about risks, they may end up undergoing a treatment that causes harm and that they would not have consented to if they had all the information. Medical malpractice suits sometimes cite a lack of informed consent as a breach of duty on the part of a physician and a reason for negligence.
What is informed consent?
From the point of view of the medical professionals, informed consent means a patient who is an adult and mentally capable of making health care decisions, has been given every chance to make the best choice. Alternatively, the guardian or person authorized to make decisions for the patient has the ability to make the decision.
Why was the woman not given full informed consent?
The woman alleged that she was not given full informed consent because she was not aware of the risk of a uterine rupture with vaginal delivery after a previous cesarean. The case was settled in the plaintiff’s favor.
What are the risks and benefits of psychotherapy?
Risks may include experiencing uncomfortable feelings, such as sadness, guilt, anxiety, anger, frustration, loneliness and helplessness, because the process of psychotherapy often requires discussing the unpleasant aspects ...
Is psychotherapy good for you?
However, psychotherapy has been shown to have benefits for individuals who undertake it. Therapy often leads to a significant reduction in feelings of distress, increased satisfaction in interpersonal relationships, greater personal awareness and insight, increased skills for managing stress and resolutions to specific problems.
What is a medical authorization letter?
Medical treatment authorization letters are documents that give a third party permission to get medical attention for a person when their legal guardian is not available to give permission. A medical treatment authorization letter may also give permission for treatment to be given when a person is incapacitated and unable to authorize ...
What should be mentioned in a letter of authority?
If the person receiving authority is a grandparent or babysitter, their name should be stated in the letter.
Why do parents and guardians write letters to their children?
Some parents and guardians give this type of letter to their child’s school even if the parent is locally available, because it allows the school to take action in an emergency rather than waiting for the parent to be informed to take action.
Do authorization letters need to be updated?
Authorization letters should be updated regularly, so they contain the correct names of the people receiving the permission. For example, the principal may change, the nanny may change and a new letter would need to be provided.
Do you have to mention allergies in a medical authorization letter?
Even if there are no allergies or intolerances, that should also be mentioned. It will make it easier for a doctor to act if this information is known from the start. • The parent or guardian who signs the medical authorization letter should also state their relationship to the child or elderly person.
