Full Answer
Where do minority students go to school?
Apr 29, 1998 · Yes, of course; persons may indeed be entitled to remedy for unlawful injury done to them because they were black or brown or female. We give such remedy, rightly--but it is the injury for which...
How do minority enrollments affect a student’s education?
Jul 02, 2006 · Whether targeted minority applicants do or should receive preferential treatment in admission has been the subject of heated debate at the University of Wisconsin-Madison for the past two years. The question is almost certain to come up again when the campus must develop, approve, and submit to the Board of Regents a new diversity plan.
Should Universities give admission preference to blacks?
Oct 25, 2009 · As a minority, you get SPECIAL treatment. It's called affirmative action. Some schools, like WashU Med, used to pay for plane and hotel for Second Look for URM's.
Are minority students put at greatest risk by teachers?
Aug 17, 2020 · My hope is that my candor in sharing my story may help heal lingering resentments or bust the myth that some minority students are in college, not due to merit, but because of “special” treatment. That simply isn’t true. Because honestly, if there were any breaks or perks for being a URM…I would have found them!
Do you have a better chance of getting into college if you are a minority?
Overall, Americans are now more likely to say that blacks and whites have the same chance of being accepted into college, compared with sentiment in 2003. In 2003, 34% of whites said the black student had the better chance, compared with 24% who say that today.Sep 13, 2005
How does ethnicity affect college acceptance?
For example, students with the average characteristics of those applying to a four-year college had a 60 percent chance of being admitted at an elite four-year school if they were white non-Hispanics. However, black or Hispanic applicants with the same characteristics had an 87 or 75 percent chance, respectively.
Do demographics affect college admissions?
Demographics of enrolled students also can vary significantly from the background of all who were offered admission. More broadly, experts say, highly selective schools tend to be less diverse than those that are less selective.Jan 24, 2022
Is affirmative action required for colleges?
As of January 1, 2012 (House Bill 623), affirmative action is not allowed in college admissions and employment.
Do colleges check your ethnicity?
Admissions experts have varying views of the survey. Most said that colleges do not routinely attempt to verify applicants' answers on what race or ethnicity they are.Oct 25, 2021
How does race affect GPA?
Whites were more than twice as likely as Blacks to graduate with grade point averages better than 3.5. Two out of every five White graduates but less than one in five Black graduates achieved a GPA greater than 3.5. Blacks were nearly three times as likely as Whites to graduate with a GPA of less than 2.5.Nov 5, 2012
Why do schools ask for race?
This information is used by the federal government for a variety of purposes, including monitoring job discrimination and school segregation and determining how to allocate large amounts of federal aid. The Census Bureau has included a question on race in each census since 1790.
What is the demographic cliff?
Even before the pandemic struck, enrollment numbers were declining as higher education approaches the “demographic cliff”—an expected sharp fall-off in enrollments for traditional college-age students beginning in 2025, resulting from a decline in birth rates that began with the financial crisis and recession of 2008.Oct 29, 2021
Does geography help with college admissions?
Generally speaking, geography is a minor factor in the decision-making process of college admissions officers, Chu says. "All things being equal, it may be considered, but colleges are significantly more keen on a student's academic and extracurricular profiles, essays, and recommendations," she wrote.Sep 10, 2018
Is diversity hiring legal?
Yes, diversity hiring is legal –– when done properly. Legislation, including the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, and the Americans with Disabilities Act, safeguard the rights of people in protected classes from discriminatory hiring practices.Jan 20, 2021
What are the disadvantages of affirmative action?
What Are the Disadvantages of Affirmative Action?It promotes discrimination in reverse. ... It still reinforces stereotypes. ... Diversity can be just as bad as it can be good. ... It changes accountability standards. ... It lessens the achievements that minority groups obtain. ... Personal bias will always exist.May 9, 2017
What are the negative effects of affirmative action?
The harms of affirmative action are clear. Academic mismatch perpetuates low grades and high dropout rates for minority students who need a racial preference to gain admission. Basing admissions on race rather than merit also contributes to the dearth of minorities in STEM fields.Dec 2, 2015
Summary
Does the UW-Madison discriminate in admissions on the basis of race/ethnicity? Do applicants from targeted minority groups receive preferential consideration in admission decisions? Many people believe that targeted minority groups do receive preferential consideration. Yet, campus officials typically avoid discussing the issue.
Introduction
Whether targeted minority applicants do or should receive preferential treatment in admission has been the subject of heated debate at the University of Wisconsin-Madison for the past two years. The question is almost certain to come up again when the campus must develop, approve, and submit to the Board of Regents a new diversity plan.
Faculty Perspective
The admission criteria for UW-Madison are determined by the faculty through legislation adopted by the Faculty Senate. The most recent full statement of admissions policy appears in Faculty Senate Document 843, dated 5 March 1990. Faculty legislation lists three minimum requirements for admission:
Table: Minimum Required and Typical Course Preparation
Faculty legislation also discusses the case of applicants who do not meet the minimum requirements, stating:”Applicants lacking minimum qualifications may be considered if, on the basis of other factors, they appear to have a reasonable probability of success.
Admissions Office
As applications arrive in the admissions office, they are checked for completeness, color-coded to reflect the status of the applicant, i.e., by special outreach category, residence status, etc.
Applicant Perspective
The student perspective is reflected in the contents of the booklet made available to potential applicants; the most recent issue is the Wisconsin Undergraduate Admissions Materials: Celebrating 150 Years (1999), published by the UW-Madison Office of Admissions.
Table: Percent of Fall 1998 Freshman Applicants Admitted by High School Percentile Rank
The publication, The University of Wisconsin System: Introduction 1997-98, repeats much of this same information for all UW System campuses, including the UW-Madison.
What Really IS Middle Class?
We assumed we were middle class, but barely, when you factor in that we have six children.
Diversity Programs
Because my daughter checked the boxes requesting mail from prospective colleges on College Board, she got recruiting letters from almost everywhere.
Going After Merit-Based Aid
This year found me going down the road to college with my two middle kids; 16-year-old seniors.
Lessons to Be Learned
1. To give a heads up to people new to this process, including other minorities.
Is affirmative action fair?
Mr Clegg: I simply think it's unfair to treat people differently because of skin colour and as a lawyer, I think that it's not consistent with the way our laws read. I think it's a bad idea and I would oppose it if I were somehow or other a beneficiary of it.
Are white students discriminated against?
Mr Clegg: I think that in a country that is increasingly multi-ethnic and multi-racial that kind of policy is simply untenable. I think the only legal approach that can possibly work is one that treats everybody the same regardless of their skin colour or what country their ancestors are from.
Is it time for affirmative action to go?
Mr Clegg: I understand the visceral sense that African Americans have been treated badly in this country for a very long time, and right after we got rid of Jim Crow [segregation laws], it wasn't such a bad idea to give special consideration over someone who was a recent beneficiary of Jim Crow. But now we're in 2017.
Who are the contributors?
Roger Clegg is president of the conservative Center for Equal Opportunity and a former top official in the justice department's civil rights division under President Ronald Reagan and George HW Bush.
What is affirmative action in US colleges?
Affirmative action, or the idea that disadvantaged groups should receive preferential treatment, first appeared in President John F Kennedy's 1961 executive order on federal contractor hiring.
What does equality mean?
Equality means there are no special rights for any one group based on something as arbitrary as sex, race, etc , and yet many would argue those people deserve special privilege because "the system is built against them" or "they've historically been oppressed", but that's ridiculous.
Do we deserve equal treatment?
We are all created equal, thus we all deserve equal treatment. Just because the skin on your body is a different shade or you're not exactly like everyone else it doesn't mean you deserve more or less because of it. It is not "Equality" if minority groups, or any group really, gets special treatment over others.
How does tracking systems affect minority students?
In combination, these policies leave minority students with fewer and lower-quality books, curriculum materials, laboratories, and computers; significantly larger class sizes; less qualified and experienced teachers; and less access to high-quality curriculum. Many schools serving low-income and minority students do not even offer the math and science courses needed for college, and they provide lower-quality teaching in the classes they do offer. It all adds up.
What is the color line divides us?
W.E.B. DuBois was right about the problem of the 21st century. The color line divides us still. In recent years, the most visible evidence of this in the public policy arena has been the persistent attack on affirmative action in higher education and employment. From the perspective of many Americans who believe that the vestiges of discrimination have disappeared, affirmative action now provides an unfair advantage to minorities. From the perspective of others who daily experience the consequences of ongoing discrimination, affirmative action is needed to protect opportunities likely to evaporate if an affirmative obligation to act fairly does not exist. And for Americans of all backgrounds, the allocation of opportunity in a society that is becoming ever more dependent on knowledge and education is a source of great anxiety and concern.
Do minority students still attend schools?
Two-thirds of minority students still attend schools that are predominantly minority, most of them located in central cities and funded well below those in neighboring suburban districts.
Is the US educational system unequal?
In fact, the U.S. educational system is one of the most unequal in the industrialized world, and students routinely receive dramatically different learning opportunities based on their social status.