why is family treatment court better than dependency court

Family Treatment Court is an alternative to regular Dependency Court for parents who need access to drug and alcohol treatment, judicial monitoring of their sobriety, and individualized services to support the family. It is a "drug court" for families involved in the child welfare system. FTC

Perspectives: Hear from FTC Graduates and the Judge!

Full Answer

What is a family treatment court?

Family treatment courts, also known as family drug courts and dependency drug courts, utilize a multidisciplinary, collaborative approach to serve parents and families who enter the child welfare system due to parental substance use disorders. Resources on this page present research on the benefits of family treatment courts.

Do drug courts offer services to families and children of program participants?

This case study looks at three adult drug courts that are in the process of expanding services to families and children of program participants. From Children and Family Futures and the National Drug Court Institute. This publication provides a guide on planning and implementing a family treatment court.

What are the family treatment court best practice standards?

The Family Treatment Court Best Practice Standards: Provide practitioners with a shared definition of the elements required in quality practice Establish a common language across various systems and programs that work with families

What are the advantages and disadvantages of drug court?

Drug courts keep offenders in treatment programs for a longer time. One of the advantages that a drug court provides to a community is the ability to keep people in treatment programs longer. Other forms of intervention may not be able to impose the same restrictions on an offender that a judge can in this situation.

How does Family Drug Treatment Court participation affect child welfare outcomes?

Bruns et al. (2012) found that children of participants in FDTC programs were 2.5 times more likely to be returned to the custody of their guardian and were half as likely to remain in out-of-home placement, with a slightly higher rate of adoption than the comparison group.

How many family treatment courts are there in the US?

In 2019, approximately 500 FTCs were operating in 48 states, the District of Columbia, and Guam. FTCs are one element of a full spectrum of services for families in the child welfare system, including proactive pre-petition and multidisciplinary post-petition quality legal representation, and parent partner programs.

Do drug treatment services predict reunification outcomes of mothers and their children in child welfare?

Completion of substance abuse treatment has been shown to increase the rate of reunification of mothers with children, independent of whether mothers reported ongoing drug use or demonstrated risks for poor parenting behaviors (Smith, 2003).

Where was the first drug court in the US?

The first jurisdiction to implement a drug court was New York City; it created the court in 1974 in response to the enforcement of the draconian Rockefeller Drug Laws, which overwhelmed the state's criminal justice system with an unrelenting spate of drug cases throughout the 1970s (Belenko & Dumanovsky, 1993).

How many mental health courts are there in the US?

There are currently more than 90 mental health courts in operation, which vary widely in their organization and status.

How many veteran treatment courts are there in the United States?

As of November 2020, VJO Specialists report serving in 601 Veterans Treatment Courts (VTCs) and other Veteran-focused court programs across the U.S. The number of these courts has grown significantly since June 2016, when VJO Specialists reported serving in 461 courts. What is a Veterans Treatment Court?

What is the success rate of reunification?

Among children who were reunified, 82.7 percent remained reunified at the end of the study. Approximately a quarter (24.6 percent) of reunified children were re-reported to child protective services with an allegation involving maltreatment by a family member.

How does family reunification work?

The Family Reunification Program allows Canadians and permanent residents to sponsor certain categories of family members to immigrate to Canada as permanent residents. The Program delivers the Family Class component of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), sub-section 12(1).

What does family reunification process mean?

UNESCO defines “family reunion/reunification” as “the process of bringing together family members, particularly children, spouses and elderly dependents” in its Handbook of selected terms and concepts.

Are drug treatment courts effective?

Drug treatment courts reduced recidivism rates by 14% compared to traditional criminal justice system responses. There is, however, an explicit relationship between statistical significance, effect size and sample size whereby the size of a study increases the level of significance (Rosenthal, 1991).

How are drug courts beneficial?

Drug courts help participants recover from addiction and prevent future criminal activity while also reducing the burden and costs of repeatedly processing low‐level, non‐violent offenders through the Nation's courts, jails, and prisons.

What are the three types of drug courts?

Drug Courts. Specialized court docket programs that help criminal defendants and offenders, juvenile offenders, and parents with pending child welfare cases who have alcohol and other drug dependency problems.Adult Drug Courts and Medication-Assisted Treatment (MAT) for Opioid Dependence. ... Family Treatment Drug Courts.

What is family treatment court?

Family Treatment Court is an alternative to regular Dependency Court for parents who need access to drug and alcohol treatment, judicial monitoring of their sobriety, and individualized services to support the family. It is a "drug court" for families involved in the child welfare system.

Is family time a risk?

For most families, family time is now able to occur in person. COVID -19 continues to pose a risk to everyone, so family time providers will ask everyone involved about any possible symptoms or exposures before each contact. Everyone over age 2 is required to wear a mask during family time.

Does sober support stay in place?

Current court ordered sober support attendance will remain in place along with drug testing requirements. If parents have concerns about drug testing, please contact their FTC Social Worker immediately to problem solve those circumstances.

Family Treatment Courts

Family Drug Treatment Courts offer an alternative approach to handling … complex child welfare cases by helping parents better engage with services, navigate the court process, and access and complete treatment.

Essential Elements of Family Drug Treatment Courts 4

Integration of drug and alcohol treatment services within case planning and access to a continuum of related treatment and rehabilitation services.

Why are FTDCs not placed in permanent homes?

In some circumstances, children whose parents are participating in FTDCs are not placed in their permanent homes as quickly as children whose parents are in usual care, perhaps because FTDCs allow parents more time to achieve sobriety than the traditional justice system 6, 8.

What are the benefits of FTDC?

Parents who participate in FTDCs receive more treatment than parents who receive usual care 1, 6, 7, 8. FTDCs may also improve family functioning 9, 10 and decrease children’s re-entry to foster care 9. Parents who complete FTDC programs are more likely to reunite with their children than parents who do not participate or participate ...

What is Family Treatment Court?

Family Treatment Court (FTC) is a special program designed to help respondents and their children get back together and stay together. This program is designed to service individuals who have a neglect case against them with alcohol or substance abuse allegations.

How does a Family Treatment Court Case Begin?

Once a person is accused of child neglect and a neglect petition is filed with the Family Court by ACS, a FTC screening clerk determines if substance abuse has been alleged and if the case meets other specific screening criteria for the Treatment Court. Eligible cases are sent immediately to Treatment Court for intake, arraignment and orientation.

What cases are eligible for Family Treatment Court?

Child neglect cases where alcohol or substance abuse has been alleged in the petition by the Administration for Children's Services (ACS) meeting the following specific screening criteria: open /pending cases are reviewed on a case by case basis; respondent is over 18 years old, At least one respondent named in the petition must be independently eligible for FTC participation, and respondent's whereabouts must be known.

What happens at a Fact-Finding Hearing?

When a respondent agrees to participate in the Family Treatment Court Program they make an admission of neglect due to substance abuse and sign the Treatment Court contract, in which they formally agree to the treatment plan and agree to abide by all Treatment Court Rules and Regulations. This appearance constitutes a fact-finding.

What happens at a Case Conference?

Upon admission into the treatment court program, a case conference is held. The respondent's attorney, the child's law guardian, and ACS lawyer and court liaison meet with the clinical staff to implement a treatment plan.

What happens at Court Appearances?

Court appearances in Family Treatment Court are very detailed sessions. Each respondent is tested for alcohol and illicit substances on-site at the treatment court at every court appearance. At each appearance, respondents compliance with treatment and permanency planning for the children will be addressed.

What happens at a Disposition?

Family Treatment Court dispositional orders can vary widely. Child may be placed in foster care until completion of the first permanency hearing which will be stated in the dispositional order.

How has the Family Court impacted the child welfare system?

Family court has been greatly impacted by parental substance abuse and the rise of caseloads containing parents with co-occurring problems. Simultaneously, the 1997 Adoption and Safe Families Act created additional pressure on the system by requiring the courts and child welfare systems to resolve dependency cases within strict time limits. ASFA also has thrust upon the courts the role of judging the adequacy of efforts made by state departments of social services to assist families and the role of approving or modifying the case plan. All this is in addition to the court’s preexisting duty to hear the evidence, determine if there is enough evidence to establish a case, and assure due process to parents, children, and families.

What is the role of CPS in dependency cases?

For instance, treatment providers are required to have a treatment plan for the substance abusing parent, while CPS has statutory responsibility to develop a comprehensive service plan for each case to assure child safety and well being and to promote the reunification of families. Service plans must be developed to assist parents to gain the skills necessary to meet the needs of their children, and these plans must meet the child’s needs, such as developmental delays and physical and mental health problems and may be developed by the service provider or an independent diagnostic assessment agency.

What is FDTC jurisdiction?

In some states, FDTCs will be limited to dependency cases only. In states where the court has broader jurisdiction, a determination must be made as to what other types of cases (i.e., criminal matters) involving the same family will be heard by the FDTC judge and incorporated into the case plan.

What is advocacy in case management?

“Advocacy is one of case management's hallmarks . While a professional conducting therapy may speak out on behalf of a client, case management is dedicated to making services fit clients, rather than making clients fit services,” (Siegal, 1998). FDTCs serve as an example of this kind of advocacy. Miami’s Dependency Drug Court has reached out to other community agencies to provide needed services. Aftercare services, ordered at the graduation, are provided by the Project Safe program. They provide peer support, urine testing, and employment assistance. Given the prevalence of traumatic history in their client population, the Miami court also has made arrangements for therapeutic and educational services through another local agency, Victims Services Center.

What is FDTC monitoring?

FDTCs become involved in monitoring parents’ participation in planned services to the same extent that they are exercising jurisdiction over the matter. Where the FDTC has taken jurisdiction over only substance abuse treatment and abstinence issues, its efforts are limited to monitoring these issues. Where the court has taken a more holistic approach, monitoring occurs across many more domains.

What is a FDTC assessment?

All FDTCs require a substance abuse assessment of the participating parent to determine the appropriate level of treatment and to establish treatment goals. Courts often make use of existing resources in arranging for substance abuse assessments. Suffolk County was able to outsource a psychiatric social worker from the health department to conduct assessments at the courthouse. The social worker then referred participants to local treatment providers. Other courts depend on treatment providers to conduct assessments. Child welfare, mental health, and other assessments also are conducted by FDTCs, depending on the breadth of their missions.

What are the three groups of players in the FDTC process?

[14] In reviewing 14 FDTCs, it was found that three groups of players emerge as part of the court development process: a steering committee , a planning team which often evolves into an ongoing administrative oversight team, and the operational or “therapeutic” FDTC team. Some steering and planning/administrative committees had overlapping or identical memberships. Committee/team composition varied from jurisdiction to jurisdiction based on the range of legal and social issues each court needed to address, as well as the extent to which local law enforcement and social service providers were available and willing to participate in the collaborative effort that FDTCs require.

Why are drug courts important?

3. Drug courts keep offenders in treatment programs for a longer time. One of the advantages that a drug court provides to a community is the ability to keep people in treatment programs longer. Other forms of intervention may not be able to impose the same restrictions on an offender that a judge can in this situation.

Why do we need a drug court?

1. It can cause drug offenders to receive a lighter sentence for their actions.#N#The goal of a drug court is to keep non-violent users out of jail so that they can receive the treatment that they need. Because there are legal ramifications to such a behavior, there can be community members and groups who feel like a judicial sentence to a treatment program is a lighter sentence than the jail time that someone deserves. Some critics even suggest that the presence of a drug court encourages people to break the law so that they can receive treatment opportunities that they would not be able to afford otherwise.

What are the pros and cons of drug court?

List of the Pros of Drug Courts. 1. The cost of a drug court is less than what incarceration costs. When looking at the short-term costs of managing offenders who qualify for a drug court, this system is comparatively cheaper to the standard practice of incarceration.

Why do drug courts cherry pick their participants?

Some jurisdictions can cherry-pick their participants to boost their success rates. Drug courts might sometimes choose to admit people that they feel will have the best chance for success in the program instead of offering the services to those who have the severe substance abuse problems that need the intervention.

How much money does a drug court receive?

The average drug court receives about $10 million per year in funding to provide resources. In some states, that the equivalent to housing about 150 inmates in a jail or prison for only a year. 2. It reduces the levels of criminal behavior and drug abuse.

What happens when there is an active drug court?

When there is an active drug court in a community, the everyone benefits from the experience. Probation officers, law enforcement, and social service providers receive more information about the treatment options that are available locally, making it easier to use non-violent intervention techniques.

Can a drug test revoke an offender's status?

Although some critics say that drug courts go easy on people who are convicted of non-violent drug- related crimes, a failed drug test or relapse at any time during the program can revoke an offender’s status and send them to jail. 7. Offenders must complete intense, frequent sessions to say in compliance.