Full Answer
Why is forced treatment even a thing?
The reason forced treatment is even a thing is because THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE. A fact that you seem to miss over and over again in your thoughts.
What are the long-term effects of forced treatment?
We may be protecting someone in the short-term when treatment is forced, but the long-term effect could be detrimental. According to a 2014 study, “self-stigma, associated stress and a reduced empowerment from coerced treatment predicted a poorer quality of life and lowered people’s self-esteem.”
What is forced mental health treatment?
Forced mental health treatment involves abduction, imprisonment, torture, and the list goes on and on, and any other persons besides those in the profession would be prosecuted for what is being done in mental hospitals.
Should forced treatment be abolished in the UK?
I totally agree that we need to abolish forced treatment. In the UK, a tradition of case law provides a potentially powerful vehicle by which to take this forward, and there is plenty of downright illegal behaviour documented and out in the public domain that is ripe for challenge.
What is forced addiction treatment?
Forced addiction treatment, which is also known as involuntary commitment, is an option that can be used when an individual with severe substance abuse problems refuses to seek treatment on their own. With involuntary commitment, an addict can be admitted to treatment if they meet any one of the following conditions:
What happens if you can't stop using drugs?
If you find that you cannot stop using drugs or alcohol even though you would like to, then you may be suffering from an addiction. Addiction is an actual, recognizable disease and as such, your inability to stop on your own should not be a cause for shame or guilt.
Can you send an addict to treatment without their consent?
If there is danger of the addict harming another individual if they are not committed. If the addict is under the age of 18 then you can legally send them to treatment without their consent. It is best to try to get them to agree to go first, but if all else fails, forced addiction treatment may be the route to go.
Is forced addiction legal in Florida?
In Florida, forced addiction treatment is legal under the Marchman Act. The Marchman Act states that either a spouse or a relative that understands the condition of the addict ed person can petition the court for the addict’s care. In the absence of family members, the act states that three people who have direct contact and understanding ...
Why is involuntary treatment important?
Involuntary treatment tends to happen when a person has already reached a crisis level or nearly there. Better preventive and early mental health care could reduce the overall need for involuntary treatment, and therefore give people a chance to get the most out of treatment.
How long does it take for a patient to be discharged after voluntarily committing to a treatment?
Even if a patient enters treatment voluntarily, it can still take days for the patient to be discharged after they express a desire to leave, effectively rendering the “voluntary commitment” useless.
What is joint crisis plan?
A joint crisis plan is a negotiation between a patient and their care providers about the patient’s future treatment for psychiatric emergencies.
How long can a psychiatrist hold a patient?
Psychiatric wards can hold someone for up to three days if the doctors believe the person is a threat to themselves or others. If a doctor believes the patient needs to be held longer, they can advise a 14-day hold and the patient is entitled to a hearing about their involuntary commitment.
How long does a mental health facility have to discharge a patient in Illinois?
According to Illinois law, a mental health facility has five business days from when a patient requests discharge (in writing) to when they legally have to let the patient go. The facility can also petition a court to keep the patient longer, even if they were voluntarily admitted.
Why is motivation important in therapy?
Motivation is important for making substantial change. When it comes to therapy, you have to put in work for it to be effective. If someone’s forced to go to therapy or group therapy, the motivation to follow through on their work isn’t there, though that doesn’t mean they won’t benefit somewhat.
Is coerced treatment beneficial?
In a recent study, researchers found that patients who received coerced treatment for mental illness were less likely to view the help as beneficial compared to those who sought treatment on their own. The researchers looked at two forms of coerced treatment.
Do people who are court mandated do well?
The majority of studies have focused on mandates from the legal system (e.g., through the courts). Findings differ across studies, but most show that people who are court-mandated seem to do just as well in treatment as others. However, people who are court-mandated tend to be different from those who are not.
Can addiction be treated?
Yes, addiction treatment can help people. A continuum of services should be accessible to everyone. At the same time, the impacts of poverty, homelessness, colonialism, racism, and mental illness are not solved by a short stint in a treatment program.
Does Canada have a mandatory addiction treatment program?
Compulsory addiction treatment does exist in Canada in a number of different forms. People can be formally mandated to a treatment program as an alternative to going to jail or as a condition of parole or probation.
Why do we need to stop involuntary treatment?
In addition to the human rights and Constitutional reasons, here are some further reasons to do away with involuntary treatment: First, very few people labelled “mentally ill” actually become violent. Rates of criminal violence in this group do not exceed the general population.
What is the effect of involuntary treatment on people?
Involuntary treatment humiliates and demoralizes people, reinforcing their feelings of being worthless, powerless, and helpless. It leads to outrage, which is then crushed by psychiatric drugs.
How do neuroleptic drugs affect people?
The most profound impact of neuroleptic (antipsychotic) drugs is to render the individual indifferent, apathetic and docile; but the drugs commonly continue to inflict physical and mental torment. In my decades of clinical experience, many if not most victims of involuntary treatment experience it as torture.
How does torture break the will of a person?
Anyone who has worked or been a patient on a psychiatric ward has witnessed daily attempts to break the will of patients by limiting their freedom and activities, treating them like children, making threats, using physical restraint and isolation, and ultimately inflicting drugs and electroshocks that render the individual helpless . The most profound impact of neuroleptic (antipsychotic) drugs is to render the individual indifferent, apathetic and docile; but the drugs commonly continue to inflict physical and mental torment.
Why do people go to a psychiatrist?
Going to a psychiatrist, or to other healthcare providers, exposes the already distressed individual to the risk of incarceration and forced treatment with little or no due process. When feeling helpless and overwhelmed, seeking psychiatric treatment can turn into the most dangerous mistake of a person’s life.
Is involuntary psychiatric treatment unconstitutional?
It is an assault on basic human rights, but it is not unconstitutional–the 13th Amendment never abolished slavery.
Is it worse to be injected with psychiatric drugs?
Undergoing forcibly injected psychiatric drugs is worse than drug-free imprisonment in jail where at least your mind and spirit are free. The neuroleptic drugs crush the mind and spirit, in the extreme producing a zombie–like existence.
2. Bitterness or offense stifles your progress
It’s sad but true that people can get on each other’s nerves, hurt each other, and do things that irritate or offend others. Your recovery from addiction can’t be divorced from interaction with people. We’re not interested in sending you to a monastery for the rest of your life.
3. The rehab program is not that good
When you choose a rehab center for treatment, you’re trusting them to deliver quality counseling and a program that works. However, not all rehab centers are equal. Some of them are better than others at delivering a treatment program that gets results.
Contact Eternal Awakenings to start the enrollment process
We’d love to serve you, counsel you, and lead you to the place where you are truly free from your addiction. Our Christian-based drug and alcohol treatment is affordable, effective, and located in a serene and peaceful setting in a beautiful, historic Texas mansion. It is one of the best-kept secrets for premier rehab at an affordable price.
Why does torture not work?
5 Reasons Why Torture Does Not Work and Can Never Be Justified. Torture is one of the most extreme forms of human violence, resulting in both physical and psychological consequences. It has been used for thousands of years and it is still occurring throughout much of the world. The right to freedom from torture is a universally recognized human ...
Why do governments use torture?
When states and governments use torture to achieve their goals, they often see it as necessary to provide some type of justification for its implementation. Governments and politicians must find ways to excuse and explain the use of torture, while those who publicly advocate for it must find arguments that would justify torture as a practice that is globally and universally regarded as immoral and condemned.
Why is torture not reliable?
Therefore, information obtained through torture is not reliable because victims will often say what their torturers want to hear to make the pain stop. For example, detainees who are physically abused during an interrogation might accuse someone else of their deeds, hoping they will be tortured instead.
What is torture in psychology?
Torture methods used on victims can be of both physical and psychological nature, such as prolonged solitary confinement or sleep deprivation. Both psychological and physical torture complement each other causing severe pain to people who were affected by it. Infliction of physical torture is in most cases reflected in psychological consequences.
How does torture affect the brain?
Usually, the application of physical, mental and psychological pressure forces victims of torture to say or confess anything just to end the painful experience. According to some psychologists, the stress caused by torture will most often affect parts of the brain associated with memory and force victims to lie or repeat information they heard from their torturers. This, basically, means that interrogators may unintentionally plant false memories in victims and compromise their cognitive functions which are key in obtaining accurate information.
Why do people use torture?
They also use torture to destroy the autonomy of the victim.
What are the consequences of physical torture?
Infliction of physical torture is in most cases reflected in psychological consequences. Applying torture methods of these types on someone can directly damage their memory and cause an extreme psychological trauma.
Is forced treatment good or bad?
It has never been shown that forced treatment does more good than harm, and it is highly likely that the opposite is true. We need to abolish our laws about this, in accordance with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which virtually all countries have ratified.
Can forced treatment be defended?
Forced treatment cannot be defended, neither on ethical, legal or scientific grounds. We need to abolish our laws about this, in accordance with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. 1 The evidence we have tells us that forced treatment increases the harm done not only to patients but also to others. 2,6,14.15 Violence breeds violence, but perhaps the strongest argument against forced drugging and ECT is that, apart from psychiatric patients, only soldiers at war are forced to run risks against their will that might kill them. The difference is that soldiers have usually chosen themselves to become soldiers whereas psychiatric patients have not chosen to become psychiatric patients.