Treatment FAQ

why did ernest hemingway get electroshock treatment

by Domenic Kutch Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago

ERNEST HEMINGWAY underwent 20 gruelling rounds of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) to cure him of his depression. Having lost many of his memories as a result, he said, “It was a brilliant cure but we lost the patient,” and took a shotgun to his head not long afterwards.Sep 15, 2005

Full Answer

What was Ernest Hemingway treated for at Mayo Clinic?

On January 10, while Mary visited relatives in Bemidji, Hemingway’s medical care at Mayo became national and international news. The following morning, the clinic uncharacteristically released a statement acknowledging that doctors at Saint Marys were treating him for hypertension, with no mention of depression or ECT.

Why did Ernest Hemingway not respond to ECT?

It is now understood that alcoholics often don’t respond to ECT, and Hemingway was undoubtedly an alcoholic. If he was also suffering from undiagnosed dementia, as some medical historians now suspect, the shock treatments could have worsened his condition.

Did Ernest Hemingway have hemochromatosis?

The idea of hemochromatosis is certainly intriguing. It was first introduced in 1990, but this was an easy enough diagnosis to make and to test for in 1960 and 1961. So when Hemingway was at the Mayo Clinic, an iron level would have easily revealed whether he had hemochromatosis.

What happened to Ernest Hemingway in Rochester NY?

Don Anderson, a husky friend, drove him. At the back door, Hemingway bolted out of the car and through the house. He got a shell in the shotgun before Anderson yanked the barrel and shoved him to the sofa. On April 25, Larry Johnson once again flew Hemingway, along with Saviers and Anderson, to Rochester.

Why did Hemingway go to Mayo Clinic?

Ernest Hemingway had spent the majority of his last seven months being treated for depression at the Mayo Clinic, during two separate stays in the winter and spring of 1960 and 1961. He had been delusional, depressed, paranoid, and suicidal.

Did Ernest Hemingway suffer from CTE?

Smithsonian Magazine contacted Kevin Bieniek, a research fellow who studies CTE at the Mayo Clinic, where Hemingway was eventually hospitalized. Bieniek agreed that Hemingway sustained traumatic brain injuries and that his paranoia and other symptoms tracked the accounts of confirmed CTE cases.

Was Hemingway a manic?

Farah is not the first to doubt the depression diagnosis. Others have diagnosed bipolar disorder, such that it gets frequently repeated as true, but Farah points out Hemingway never had a manic episode, and his depressive episodes were situational.

How did Hemingway lose his life?

Having departed Cuba, his home for some 20 years, Ernest Hemingway settled in Ketchum, Idaho, in 1960 and temporarily resumed his work, but, anxiety-ridden and depressed, he was twice hospitalized at the Mayo Clinic. On July 2, 1961, he took his life with a shotgun at his house in Ketchum.

What is the scar on Hemingway's head?

The prominent scar on Ernest's forehead is said to have been inflicted in Paris when a drunken Hemingway mistakenly pulled a skylight down over his head while trying to flush a toilet. 6. Hemingway married his second wife, Pauline Pfeiffer, merely weeks after divorcing his first, Hadley Richardson, in 1927.

What does CTE do to the brain?

The brain degeneration is associated with common symptoms of CTE including memory loss, confusion, impaired judgment, impulse control problems, aggression, depression, suicidality, parkinsonism, and eventually progressive dementia.

Who is the most famous person with bipolar?

These eight celebrities and famous historical figures have all lived with bipolar disorder.Russell Brand. Russell Brand is a British comedian, actor, and activist. ... Catherine Zeta-Jones. ... Kurt Cobain. ... Graham Greene. ... Nina Simone. ... Winston Churchill. ... Demi Lovato. ... Alvin Ailey.

Did Ernest Hemingway have anthrax?

Throughout his life, Hemingway was struck down hard by things like anthrax, malaria, pneumonia, dysentery, skin cancer, hepatitis, anemia, diabetes, high blood pressure, and mental illness.

Did Ernest Hemingway lose a leg?

Two Italian soldiers standing between Hemingway and the shell's point of impact were not so lucky, however: one was killed instantly and another had both his legs blown off and died soon afterwards.

Why did Hemingway dislike his mother?

His friend, the writer John dos Passos, said later that Hemingway was the only man he ever knew who truly hated his mother. His bitterness toward his mother over his upbringing spilled out in the way he treated female characters in his fiction—and in the way he treated his four wives.

How did Ernest Hemingway get his first concussion?

In addition, Hemingway sustained his first concussion at the age of 18 when he was nearly killed by a mortar blast in Italy while serving as an ambulance driver in World War I. When he returned to his placid hometown of Oak Park, Ill., he suffered from PTSD, despite the air of bravado he projected.

What did Hemingway admire most about the bull?

And yet from his childhood Hemingway was enchanted by the natural world, and as an adult he admired the beauty and power of wild animals, the bravery of the bull. He wrote about them with extraordinary sensitivity and precision. “The pleasure in killing,” Tobias Wolff admits, “is a mystery to me.”.

What is the letter Hemingway wrote to Tobias Wolff?

For Tobias Wolff, it is the sadistically cruel letter Hemingway writes upon reviewing the manuscript of From Here to Eternity, a 1951 novel by newly-discovered young writer James Jones.

Where did Ernest Hemingway live?

Ernest Hemingway at his home in Cuba (Photo by A.E. Hotchner, courtesy of PBS). Ernest Hemingway was a terrible person. He was selfish and egomaniacal, a faithless husband and a treacherous friend. He drank too much, he brawled and bragged too much, he was a thankless son and, at times, a negligent father. He was also a great writer.

Was Ernest Hemingway a great writer?

He was also a great writer. This is the argument in a nutshell of “ Hemingway ,” the new documentary by Ken Burns and Lynn Novick and the most recent installment in the revered PBS “ American Masters ” series.

Can Hemingway pluck out the heart of another human being?

One cannot—and should not—pluck out the heart of another human being’s mystery. We know this, and yet Hemingway himself invites the prying eye, having created a larger-than-life version of himself for public consumption, a mythos meant to identify him with the similarly larger-than-life characters he wrote about.

Was the inquest done in Robin Williams case?

The beauty of an unbiased public inquest should have been done – but was not – in the case of Robin Williams and all the school shooters, is the subpoena power of a grand jury to open up the previously secretive medical records and enforce testimony from Williams’ (and Hemingway’s) psychiatric treatment team.

Did Ernest Hemingway have physical pain?

Hemingway, who consumed large volumes of hard liquor daily, had also been wounded by shrapnel in Italy during WWI so he also had physical pain issues and suffered psychologically during his recovery.

Why did terror stalk the halls of euthanasia hospitals?

According to history professor Henry Friedlander, “Terror stalked the halls of the euthanasia hospitals not only because patients feared being selected for killing at any time or because some of the staff beat and maltreated them, but also because some medical procedures imposed unusual pain.”.

When is ECT administered?

Promotional materials are careful in describing the procedure and present a picture that’s quite benign: “ECT treatment is generally administered in the morning, before breakfast,” reads one brochure. “Prior to the actual treatment, the patient is given general anesthesia and a muscle relaxant.

Why do we use higher voltages in the brain?

Much higher voltages are employed in the modern procedure because muscle relaxants and anesthetics raise the seizure threshold, with more electricity required to produce a seizure. The greater heat and electricity themselves cause more brain cell death, he says.

Does electricity shock the brain?

And Baughman says using electricity to shock the brain into a seizure—no matter how you do it—results in real and lasting harm. “You are creating a seizure which is prima facie evidence of brain damage,” he observes.

Does electric current cause seizures?

While the modern procedure is generally carried out without busted teeth and the more grisly features of its early practice, the principle is still the same: Electric current blazes through the brain to provoke a seizure—the logic being that seizures occurring in the brain have some therapeutic benefit, somehow.

Does ECT cause memory loss?

The brain damage caused by ECT results in varying degrees of memory loss and intellectu al and cognitive impairment , says Dallas psychiatrist Colin Ross. Ross also cites “substantial evidence” that the death rates from natural causes rise following an ECT regimen, particularly in the older patient population.

What is electro shock therapy?

Electroshock therapy, also known as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), is a treatment for severe major depression, bipolar depression, and other mental health conditions. Psychiatrists may recommend ECT when a person does not respond well to other treatments. ECT uses electric currents to stimulate a person’s brain to induce a controlled seizure.

Why do doctors recommend ECT?

However, doctors recommend ECT for some people because it is low risk and carries few side effects. Researchers are still not sure how ECT works, but they understand that it has many effects on the brain, including increasing blood flow and triggering the release of neurotransmitters and hormones.

Why was the VNS developed?

Researchers originally developed VNS to treat seizure conditions. However, they realized that it was also an effective treatment#N#Trusted Source#N#for depression. Before stimulating the vagus nerve, a doctor places an electrode under the skin of a person’s chest.

How does ECT work?

ECT uses electric currents to stimulate a person’s brain to induce a controlled seizure. Researchers do not exactly know how ECT works, but one theory is that it could regulate neurotransmitter activity. This article looks at how ECT works, whether it is an effective treatment, and its controversial history. It also discusses some alternative ...

How long does an ECT last?

An ECT session may last for about 1 hour, which includes 15–20 minutes for the procedure and 20–30 minutes of recovery time. A person may receive ECT two or three times a week for a total of between six and 12 sessions. The frequency and number of sessions will differ among individuals depending on the severity of the condition and ...

Why is ECT negative?

The negative perceptions of ECT originate from previous misuse and the historical lack of consistent administration of general anesthetics or muscle relaxants. Furthermore, when healthcare professionals first introduced ECT, many people did not consent to the therapy.

How long can you drive after ECT?

After the session, a person must not drive for 24 hours. They should also try to arrange for someone to stay with them until they go to sleep. Although ECT is an effective treatment, a person will need to continue their medication and receive more ECT sessions to prevent a relapse.

What disease did Hemingway have?

The Mayo Clinic badly botched Hemingway’s treatment when he was admitted for depression and given two disastrous series of electroshock therapy in 1960—61, He had been frightened and depressed when told by a Cuban doctor in the summer of 1960 that he had hemochromatosis, a rare, chronic, and fatal form of diabetes “that makes you go blind and permanently impotent.” The Mayo doctors also suspected that he had this disease, but they did not attempt to relieve his anxiety by doing a biopsy and making a definite diagnosis.

Who was Hemingway's main physician?

Hemingway’s main physician, Howard Rome (1910—92), was born in Philadelphia, earned his medical degree at Temple University, and began to practice at the Mayo in 1937. While Hemingway was being treated at the Mayo, Rome increased his anxiety by discussing his case with an FBI agent in Minneapolis.

Why didn't Hemingway tell Martha that she could have children?

Hemingway later told a friend that Martha could not have children because she’d had so many abortions before she met him. Martha’s biographer does not explain why she suddenly left Africa after living there for more than a decade. But, as usual, her heavily autobiographical fiction gives the answer.

What was Hemingway's poem about Martha Gellhorn's vagina?

After their marriage broke up, with great bitterness on both sides, Hemingway treated a group of war correspondents to a crude but funny pornographic poem, “To Martha Gellhorn’s Vagina,” which he was pleased to compare to the wrinkled neck of an old hot-water bag.

What did Gregory try to exorcise?

In a fascinating, agonizing interview with The Washington Post on July 29, 1987, Gregory attempted to exorcise the demons by telling his story in public. He described himself as a transvestite, a recovering alcoholic, and a manic-depressive.

What was Hemingway's problem with Martha?

The problem was in part anatomical. Hemingway, jokingly suggesting that most upper-class women had sexual difficulties, told Bernard Berenson: “She was not built for bed but few nice people are.”. He also told Gregory and Duran that Martha’s narrow vagina made her sexually unresponsive.

When did Hemingway's biography get published?

After my book Hemingway: A Biography had been accepted for publication by Harper & Row in 1984, it had to be read by the company lawyer to make sure there were no libelous passages and no infringement of copyright. I was told this would take two weeks, but the agonizing process dragged on for several months.

Where was Hemingway admitted to the hospital?

The hospital admitted Hemingway secretly, under Saviers’s name, and placed him in a private corner room on the first floor of Saint Marys Hospital, concealed among rheumatism and arthritis patients. Mary followed by train, plane, and bus, checking into Room 1060 at the Kahler Hotel as Mrs. George Saviers.

When did Ernest Hemingway wake up?

Sunday morning, July 2, 1961 , Ernest Hemingway woke before the sun crept above the mountains in the clear, cloudless sky and knew it had to be done. He tucked his feet into the moccasins he used as slippers, fastened his plaid bathrobe over his blue pajamas, and stepped past his wife’s bedroom, where Mary lay sleeping.

How many sessions did Hemingway have?

A typical course of treatment ran 10 to 12 sessions, administered twice a week. Despite the violence of the procedure, Hemingway may not have resisted. Three years earlier, he had urged his son Gregory to get ECT after seeing the positive effects his older son Patrick realized from the treatment several years previous.

Where did Hemingway and Saviers fly?

On April 25, Larry Johnson once again flew Hemingway, along with Saviers and Anderson, to Rochester. Shortly after takeoff, Hemingway struggled to open the door and jump out of the plane. Saviers and Anderson teamed up to restrain him. They stopped for a minor repair and to refuel in Rapid City, South Dakota.

What is Hemingway's brain?

Farah suspects Hemingway suffered from chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) and was in the early stages of dementia.

Where did Ernest Hemingway go to shoot a shotgun?

Instead, he roamed the sleepy city of Rochester in search of friendship, good meals, and a place to shoot a shotgun. Sunday morning, July 2, 1961, Ernest Hemingway woke before the sun crept above the mountains in the clear, cloudless sky and knew it had to be done.

What did Rome do to help the mentally ill?

Rome also administered electroconvulsive therapy. At a time when the mentally ill were warehoused in asylums, Mayo stood out for its attempts to cure these patients in a hospital setting. Rome would describe himself as “an unregenerate optimist” in an interview with the Mayo alumni magazine.

How many electroshocks did Ernest Hemingway get?

Tricked into a psychiatric institution, Nobel Prize-winning author Ernest Hemingway ( A Farewell to Arms, 1929; For Whom the Bell Tolls, 1940; Old Man and the Sea, 1952) was given 20 electroshocks. [5] . Several weeks later, he confided, “What these shock doctors don’t know is about writers and such….

What did Nurse Ratched say about ECT?

It is just as controversial and destructive today (despite its alleged changes) as it was in 1975, when the Academy-Award-winning film One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest was released and Nurse Ratched was famous for saying ECT “might be said to do the work of the sleeping pill, the electric chair and the torture rack.”.

What did Vivien Leigh suffer from?

A new book published in February 2019 claimed that famed actress, Vivien Leigh who starred in Gone with the Wind (1939) and A Street Car Named Desire (1951) had suffered from bipolar disorder. [1] . However, Leigh, along with many other artists, were victims of psychiatric treatment, especially electroconvulsive therapy (electroshock, ...

How old was Judy Garland when she was electroshocked?

Under a psychiatrist’s orders, she began the first of many stays in psychiatric hospitals. In 1949, not yet 27 years old, she was subjected to electroshock. Assertions that the source of Garland’s troubles was some inherent artistic neurosis came from psychiatrists or psychoanalysts with purses to fill.

Did Leigh see a psychiatrist?

In the early 1950s, Leigh began seeing a psychiatrist. Typically, psychiatrists do not test for underlying physical conditions that may manifest in behavioral and emotional issues. While filming Elephant Walk (1954) in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka), Leigh began having hallucinations, making it impossible to film.

What is Ernest Hemingway's brain?

In Dr. Andrew Farah’s new biography of Ernest Hemingway, Hemingway’s Brain, he details the neuropsychiatric demise of a great literary mind. Dr. Farah argues that Hemingway suffered from chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) as the result of numerous severe concussions during his life, and this ultimate dementia was complicated by alcoholism as well as untreated diabetes and hypertension, possibly contributing a vascular component. He believes this condition not only informed Hemingway’s day-to-day life, interactions, and relationships, but the later literary works as well.

What were the symptoms of Hemingway's concussion?

Hemingway had no difficulty describing the symptoms, such as persistent headaches, irritability, sensory changes, and double vision, which were typical for post-concussion syndrome. In his letters, he directly attributed them to his concussions.

What is ECT in dementia?

The piece of truth to that is that ECT was the biological stressor on a brain compromised by CTE as well as a probable component of vascular dementia, and a component of alcoholic dementia. ECT was a stressor that this compromised brain could not handle-not on a molecular level and not on a psychological level.

What were the major events of the 20th century?

As we consider the major events of the 20th century-World War I, the Lost Generation in Paris, the Spanish Civil War (which is now more correctly referred to as “the Spanish Holocaust”), World War II, and the Cuban revolution-Hemingway is a figure in each of these, sometimes a major figure.

Does Enlyte lower homocysteine?

Dr. Farah: Neuroprotection is key. Much like the military’s post-concussion protocol, vitamins such as Enlyte are designed to lower homocysteine in the CNS, as are high doses of N -acetylcysteine as an antioxidant and a good omega-3 supplement.

Who described post-concussion syndrome?

Dr. Farah: The symptoms of post-concussion syndrome were clearly described by Hemingway in various letters after different injuries, particularly after the fall on his fishing boat, and after the World War II concussions, and certainly after the plane crashes.

Did Hemingway box in high school?

It is also noteworthy that Hemingway boxed as a young man, feeling it a testament to his manhood, and he played football in high school as well. Certainly, the football equipment in 1915 and 1916 was not particularly protective. Ms. Smith: You emphasize the 2 blast-type injuries in your book.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9