Treatment FAQ

which is more effictive, heat treatment or forging

by Mr. Chesley Homenick Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Manufacturers may prefer cold over hot forging process; since cold forged parts require very little or no finishing work. Since all bars are annealed before being forged, there is no need for a secondary heat treatment prior to machining. Another significant advantage is the material savings achieved through near net shapes.

Forgings offer better response to heat treatment.
This results in non-uniform heat treatment response that can affect straightness of finished parts. Forgings respond more predictably to heat treatment and offer better dimensional stability.

Full Answer

What are the different types of heat treatment for forging?

There are various types of heat treatment processes which are performed separately or as a combination to get the desired properties and microstructure after forging. -Annealing -Normalizing

What are the advantages of hot forging?

The high temperature during hot forging enables the highest possible level of material deformation and the access to complex 3D geometries. Hot forged components possess increased ductility which makes them desirable for many configurations.

Why heat treatment after closed die forging is important?

The heat treatment after closed die forging plays an important role in developing the desired properties such as the relieving of internal stresses, the refinement of grain structure, and the attainment of improved mechanical and physical properties.

What is the difference between isothermal and hot forging?

A form of hot forging is isothermal forging, where materials and dies are heated to the same temperature. In nearly all cases, isothermal forging is conducted on superalloys in a vacuum or highly controlled atmosphere to prevent oxidation.

image

What is better than forging?

With casting, molten metal flows into a cavity in a mold or die, which allows for more complex shapes to be easily produced. Practically any material can be cast, and products up to 200 tons can be created. Casting is often much cheaper than forging.

Why heat treatment is important for forging?

The heat treatment of forgings plays an important role in developing the desired properties such as the relieving of internal stresses, the refinement of grain structure, and the attainment of improved mechanical and physical properties.

Is forging a heat treatment?

Stress Relieving Heat Treatment Techniques for Steel Heat Treatment Forging. Heat Treating is used to alter and improve the physical properties of a given material. Typical heat treatment techniques applied to steel forgings include annealing, normalizing, quenching, and tempering.

Which is better casting or forging?

Forged steel is generally stronger and more reliable than castings and plate steel due to the fact that the grain flows of the steel are altered, conforming to the shape of the part. The advantages of forging include: Generally tougher than alternatives.

What are the advantages of heat treatment?

WHAT ARE THE BENEFITS OF HEAT TREATMENT?It can change a material's physical (mechanical) properties and it aids in other manufacturing steps.It relieves stresses, making the part easier to machine or weld.Increases strength, making the material ductile or more flexible.More items...•

What is the advantage and disadvantage of heat treatment?

Heat treatment helps to get desired mechanical and chemical properties, to reduce stresses, prevent stress relief and distortion when put to service. Whilst the disadvantages include distortion, surface oxidation or other contamination, added cost, etc.

What does heat treatment do to steel?

Heat treating can soften metal, to improve formability. It can make parts harder, to improve strength. It can put a hard surface on relatively soft components, to increase abrasion resistance. It can create a corrosion-resistant skin, to protect parts that would otherwise corrode.

What is the purpose of heat treatment of steel?

Heat treatment is a controlled process used to alter the microstructure of metals and alloys such as steel and aluminium to impart properties which benefit the working life of a component, for example increased surface hardness, temperature resistance, ductility and strength.

Can you heat treat stainless steel?

Types of stainless steel Austenitic stainless steels cannot harden via heat treatment. Instead, these steels work harden (they attain hardness during their manufacture and formation). Annealing these stainless steels softens them, adds ductility and imparts improved corrosion resistance.

What are the advantages of forging?

Benefits of ForgingStrong and reliable. No other metalworking processes can ensure the superior strength of forged metal parts. ... Highly cost-effective. ... Different alloys. ... Better metallurgical properties. ... Call Us Now.

How forging is better than casting and machining?

Forging alters the properties of the metals adding strength and durability to the configuration being produced. Machining removes “excess” material, cutting or eroding it away to reveal the desired configuration, much like a sculptor, chipping away everything not required to reveal the statue.

Which is cheaper casting or forging?

Which is Better, Casting or Forging? All in all, casting tends to be the less expensive, more versatile option, however; forging offers superior strength and wear resistance.

Why do manufacturers choose hot forging over other processes?

Finally, a manufacturer would choose one process over the other because of economic and not quality reasons.

What is minimization of energy costs during hot forging?

The minimization of energy costs during hot forging is an ongoing concern of every manufacturer. Those can be optimized when using an inductor and a billet with matching diameters and installing a flexible multi-stage heating system.

What temperature is used for hot forging?

The hot forging manufacturing process is performed at extreme high temperature (up to 1150 °C for steel, 360 to 520 °C for al-alloys, 700 to 800 °C for cu-alloys). This temperature is necessary in order to avoid strain hardening of the metal during deformation. Stamping is the most widespread hot forging manufacturing process, where the material is squeezed in a press, between a tool and a die surface.

What is cold forging?

To deliver a finished, ready to fit component, the technique includes rolling, drawing, pressing, spinning, extruding and heading. Cold forging extrusion is one of the most common manufacturing techniques, widely used in the production of automotive components.

What is forging in manufacturing?

Forging is a manufacturing process, which shapes a solid-phase metal workpiece by applying compressive forces on it. According to the temperature at which it is performed, forging is classified in “ hot ”, “ warm ” and “ cold ”. The machines used to squeeze and deform the material into high strength parts can be divided in the following categories:

What are the disadvantages of cold forging?

Depending on the manufacturer’s requirements, some of the cold forging characteristics may turn out disadvantages; e.g. only simple shapes in high volumes can be shaped. The achievable deformation levels and shaping grade are much more limited compared to stamping.

What are the machines used to squeeze and deform material into high strength parts?

The machines used to squeeze and deform the material into high strength parts can be divided in the following categories: Drop forging machines: forging hammers, screw presses, axial and incremental forging. Pressure forging machines with translational motion: mechanical and hydraulic presses.

Heat-Treated Aluminum Forgings Stack Up to Steel

When it’s forged and heat-treated, aluminum takes on some mechanical properties that are comparable with steel forgings. Depending on the processing method, aluminum can be forged to be even stronger than some steel. The big payoff is that it’s about one-third the weight of steel.

What are Heat Treatments?

Not every aluminum alloy is suitable for heat-treatment, but the ones that are can be processed in different ways. At Steel Industries, our talented crew uses specialized equipment to make sure the rigid heat control needed to get optimal results for aluminum alloys is maintained.

Advantages of Heat-Treated Aluminum Across Many Industries

The demand for heat-treated aluminum forgings continues to grow at a rapid pace. At Steel Industries, we’ve forged products ranging from pistons and gears to wheel spindles for the aerospace, defense, and marine industries.

Why is it important to use warm forging?

Since warm forging temperatures are typically lower than those used in hot forging, the workpiece is less pliable during this process and complex shapes are harder to manufacture. Warm forgings also feature lower tolerances than cold forged parts. The most common metals that are used in warm forging are steel alloys. Warm forging makes it easier to deform steel alloys than in cold forging and can have better tolerances than those made with hot forging. These advantages contributed to the increased use of the warm forging manufacturing method, especially when creating high-volume automotive parts.

What is hot forging?

Hot forging is typically conducted with metals that have a high formability ratio to prevent them from being damaged in the deformation process. Some of these metals include carbon steel, titanium, copper, aluminum alloys, and nickel alloys. There are some metals can only be hot forged due to their tough physical properties. The recrystallization temperature of steel can range from 400 to 700°C, but the hot forging temperature for steel can reach up to 1200°C. Due to the high temperatures at which this process takes place, the workpiece becomes more pliable and can be fashioned into intricate shapes. Once the forging is completely shaped, a strict cooling process ensues in order to set the forging in its new shape. Although rapid cooling is necessary in this process, cooling the material too quickly can also damage the finished piece. This cool down process must be handled very carefully in order to prevent the forging from warping.

What is the most well known forging process?

Once the workpiece reaches the required temperature, tools, such as forging hammers and forging presses, can be used to mold or deform the workpiece into a new shape or design. Hot forging is the most well-known forging process.

Why do we heat metal in isothermal forging?

Isothermal forging involves heating the metal and dies to the same temperature in a vacuum environment to avoid reductions in temperature due to conduction. The vacuum environment also limits any oxidation reactions that may occur between the metal workpiece and atmospheric gases.

What temperature can you forge steel?

The recrystallization temperature of steel can range from 400 to 700°C, but the hot forging temperature for steel can reach up to 1200°C.

What equipment is needed for hot forging?

The equipment needed for hot forging can vary by application of the finished product. Dies are metal blocks that are machined to contain forging impressions that are used to produce forgings. These dies are typically composed of a top and bottom die and are generally custom-made to match a customer’s desired shape to be used in the hot forging method. There are closed-die and open-die forms of forging. The open-die method uses dies that do not fully close around the workpiece, whereas the closed die method completely encases the workpiece. A forging press can also be used to place a large amount of pressure across an entire workpiece at once. Forging hammers apply force on localized areas of the workpiece.

What is the finished product of a forging?

The finished product is called the forging . In some forging methods, especially hot forging, the workpiece is placed inside a forge, a type of hearth that heats the metal to the desired working temperature before the shaping process can take place.

What is cold forging?

Cold, Warm and Hot ForgingHot forging is the plastic deformation of metal at a temperature and strain rate such that recrystallization occurs simultaneously with deformation, thus avoiding strain hardening . For this to occur, high workpiece temperature (matching the metal’s recrystallization temperature) must be attained throughout the process. A form of hot forging is isothermal forging, where materials and dies are heated to the same temperature. In nearly all cases, isothermal forging is conducted on superalloys in a vacuum or highly controlled atmosphere to prevent oxidation.

What temperature is steel forging?

The temperature range for warm forging of steel extends from above room temperature to below the recrystallization temperature, which is about 800 to 1,800 degrees Fahrenheit, depending upon the alloy. However, the narrower range of from 1,000 to 1,330 degrees Fahrenheit is emerging as the range of perhaps the greatest commercial potential ...

Is cold forging good?

While cold forging usually improves mechanical properties, the improvement is not useful in many common for ging applications and economic advantages remain the primary interest. Tool design and manufacture are critical.

KPS Forge (India) Pvt Ltd Follow

Forging means hammering/pressing/rolling a piece (might be hot or cold) to achieve desired shape, strength required for specific application. Forging methods refines grain structure, develops inherent strength giving characteristics, improves physical properties and produces structural uniformity free from hidden internal defects.

KPS Forge (India) Pvt Ltd

Heat Treatment is most important part in forging. Here's short article to explain the importance of suitable Heat treatment process. Please do read the same. Technical experts may share their views. If you find it informative, please do like and share so that it could reach to maximum number of peoples. Keep sharing!

Bruno Benaglia

Interesting. Wich would be the best HT for Stainless Steel 304L/316L fittings? Wall thikness from 3 up to 6mm. Water well application. Thanks

KPS Forge (India) Pvt Ltd

Hi Bruno, HT for SS316L/SS304L is Solution Annealing. Soaking would be one hour since WT is 3-6 mm only. For more details/ assistance, please feel free to ask our technical team at [email protected]

garry johnson

In my experience heat treatment (ht) is a 'grid lock' in the production line as time is money.... Too often clients push the early schedule beyond the specified quality and safety requirements for the product so, then they complain why it fails when they know that the schedule is impossible to meet and turn a blind eye and blame the supplier 😳

KPS Forge (India) Pvt Ltd

Hi Garry, Agreed with your statement but it's not that much true since HT requires 1-2 days only. We can't say it's customer mistake since he has not asked to bypass any process. It's supplier responsibility to consider Heat Treatment as essential process as Forging. When we understand this point, there would be no failures. Thanks,

KPS Forge (India) Pvt Ltd

Right Mr. Johnson. Heat Treatment requires additional cost which some of companies ignore just to sustain in market and making their product cheaper for their client. They compromise with quality without taking care of its adverse effects.

Why is heat treatment important after closed die forging?

The heat treatment after closed die forging plays an important role in developing the desired properties such as the relieving of internal stresses, the refinement of grain structure, and the attainment of improved mechanical and physical properties.

Why is normalized forging less expensive than full annealed forging?

Normalized forgings are less expensive than full annealed forgings because full annealing relies on furnace-controlled cooling. First quenches the metal forging then heats it again to a temperature between 400 and 600°C. Tempering establishes the correct balance of strength and ductility within the forging.

What is tempering in forging?

Tempering establishes the correct balance of strength and ductility within the forging. PROCESS ANNEALING. Used for low carbon steel forgings. The forging is heated to a temperature lower than those used in full annealing or normalizing and then is allowed to cool in still air.

How does forging work?

Forgings restores the softness of the metal. The forging is heated to a specific temperature then cooled in a furnace according to specific time intervals for uniform softness through the entire forging. Involves heating the forging to a specific temperature and then allowing the forging to cool in still air.

What is the most widely used heat treatment method?

Quenching and tempering is the most widely used heat treatment methods, it can effectively improve the hardness of steel forgings to add the strength for better wear resistance in a low cost.

What is CFS forging?

Heat Treatment is one of the main value added services CFS Forge offers for steel forgings. Heat treatment is a post treatment method that aims to change the mechanical properties of produdcts for better working performance. All the steel forgings can be heat treated after forging.

How does heat treatment affect the properties of steel?

Heat-treatment, changing the properties of steel forgings such as carbon steel or alloy steel by processes involving heating. It is used to harden , soften , or modify other properties of materials that have different crystal structures at low and high temperatures. The type of transformation depends on the temperature that the material is heated to, how fast it is heated, how long it is kept heated, what temperature it is first cooled to, and how fast it is cooled. For example, quenching hardens steel by heating it to high temperatures and then quickly immersing it in room temperature oil, water, or salt brine to prevent carbon atoms from moving through the crystal structure and forming carbides, which soften the metal. The two main approaches to softening a metal (to restore its ductility) are annealing, in which its temperature is slowly raised, held for some time, and slowly cooled, and tempering, in which it is slowly heated in an oil bath and held for some hours.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9