Treatment FAQ

which is best for scar treatment-vitamin e or mederma

by Pink Huel Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago

Vitamin E

vitamin E

This supplement is used to prevent or treat a lack of vitamin E in the body.

has long been touted as a useful treatment for scars. You can also purchase a commercial product, Mederma

Mederma

Mederma is a topical product used to improve scar appearance. It is a gel based on an onion extract and produced by Merz Pharmaceuticals of Frankfurt, Germany, although it is not sold in Germany. Mederma's marketing claims it can make scars "softer, smoother, and less noticeable". Generic versions are sold under the name cepalin.

, which claims to diminish scars 2. When using either treatment, watch for evidence of itching or swelling.

Neither trial found that Mederma improved the appearance of scars more than petroleum jelly. Vitamin E oil didn't fare any better. “If it helps,” says Kenneth Arndt, a dermatologist in Newton, Mass., “it's not the E but the oil.” He notes that it often causes skin irritation.Apr 17, 2011

Full Answer

How effective is Mederma really at treating SCARs?

  • There are some cheaper products on the market
  • Not certain to work for everyone or for every scar or imperfection
  • Some have claimed to have allergic reactions to the product. Be mindful of the ingredients in addition before you decide to use the scar gel
  • It takes a much longer time to heal older scars vs. healing more recent scars

What is the best vitamin E for Scars?

Rankings

  1. Garden of Life Vitamin Code Raw Vitamin E. One of the biggest paradoxes in the scientific research on vitamin E is the disconnect between the observed health benefits of ...
  2. Solgar Vitamin E. Solgar Vitamin E is a supplement that provides pure alpha-tocopherol dissolved in a mixture of safflower oil and soybean oil.
  3. Amazon Elements Vitamin E. ...

More items...

Does Mederma Cream really work?

Most of the reviews we found for Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy are very positive. Consumers claim that the product works, even on scars that are years old. The key to experiencing desired results seems to be in the consistent and repeated use of the cream.

Does vitamin E heal wounds and get rid of scars?

Vitamin E is an excellent topical ointment for reducing scars. You can rub vitamin E oil on old scars and new wounds to reduce permanent scarring. While many commercial creams contain it, you can also just use the contents of a vitamin E capsule to apply to the scar or the wound. Clean the scar or wound area very carefully.

Can you use both scars?

Is massage good for skin?

Does Vitamin E help scars?

Can scar revision be done under local anesthesia?

Is Vitamin Ee good for scars?

About this website

Is vitamin E good for reducing scars?

Does vitamin E diminish scars? While vitamin E may help moisturize the skin, research indicates that vitamin E oils and supplements have no notable effect on scars.

Which cream is best for scar removal?

Healthline's picks for the best scar creamsMederma Advanced Scar Gel.SkinCeuticals Phyto +Cica-Care Gel Sheet.Cimeosil Scar and Laser Gel.ScarAway Silicone Scar Gel.Tosowoong Green Tea Natural Pure Essence.Honeydew Blemish Cream.Mederma for Kids.More items...

Which treatment is best for scar?

Common scar treatments recommended by dermatologists include:Surgical procedure. Surgically removing a scar is the most invasive type of treatment. ... Laser scar removal. ... Chemical peels. ... Dermabrasion. ... Injections. ... Ointments.

Is Mederma effective for old scars?

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is one of the most popular and effective all-around treatments for various scars. The Mederma website state that the cream is effective for both new and old scars due to acne, surgeries, burns, and cuts.

What works better than Mederma?

Treat wounds with silicone-based sheeting … “Silicone sheets are very effective in treating scars, providing an optimal dressing for helping scars heal,” says Karp. These are more effective than popular onion-extract-based products like Mederma.

How can I permanently remove old scars?

Scars cannot be removed completely, but they can often be made less visible. A GP may refer you to a dermatologist (skin specialist) or a plastic surgeon for treatment. Some treatments, such as laser therapy and steroid injections, are not widely available on the NHS, so you'll need to pay for them privately.

When should I start using Mederma?

For best results, start using Mederma® as soon as your wound has closed and continue using daily for at least 8 weeks on new scars and 3-6 months on existing scars. Make sure the scab has come off naturally and any stitches have been removed.

What are the 3 types of scars?

What are the different types of scars and treatment?Keloid scars. These are thick, rounded, irregular clusters of scar tissue that grow at the site of a wound on the skin, but beyond the edges of the borders of the wound. ... Hypertrophic scars. Hypertrophic scars are similar to keloid scars. ... Contractures. ... Adhesions.

Can I use Mederma on my face?

A: Yes, Mederma gel can be used on the face; however, while applying near the eye area, make sure it does not get into the eyes.

Which Mederma is best for dark spots?

Mederma Scar Cream Plus SPF 30 - Clinically shown to reduce discoloration, improve overall appearance, softness, and texture of scars. - Effective on old and new scar.

Can Mederma remove black marks?

The gel works well if you have had hypertrophy, accident scars, blemishes and spots on the skin. While the gel should not be used as a daily beauty cream, it does lighten dark spots, old and new scars.

What are the side effects of using Mederma?

Signs of an allergic reaction, like rash; hives; itching; red, swollen, blistered, or peeling skin with or without fever; wheezing; tightness in the chest or throat; trouble breathing, swallowing, or talking; unusual hoarseness; or swelling of the mouth, face, lips, tongue, or throat.

How to use Mederma for scars?

Merz Pharmaceuticals, makers of Mederma products, claim that using Mederma helps make scars less noticeable and promotes softer and smoother skin tissue in the area of the scar 2. Mederma Skin Care for Scars is a greaseless, invisible topical gel 2. The primary active ingredient in the product’s patented formula is a proprietary botanical extract called Cepalin. You can apply Mederma to a wound as soon as it is healed, or in the case of surgical scars, when the sutures are removed 2. You use the gel three to four times per day for eight weeks on a new scar, or for three to six months on an existing scar 2.

What is vitamin E?

Vitamin E is the term used to describe a group of tocol and tocotrienol derivatives, one of which -- alpha-tocopherol -- is a useful part of the human diet.

How long does mederma gel last?

You use the gel three to four times per day for eight weeks on a new scar, or for three to six months on an existing scar 2.

Can vitamin E cause scars?

Vitamin E Effects. Evidence from scientific studies suggests against the use of vitamin E as a scar preventive. The effectiveness of topical vitamin E in treating surgical wounds is not proven, and in some individuals it can cause contact dermatitis.

Does Vitamin E help with scars?

Vitamin E has long been touted as a useful treatment for scars. You can also purchase a commercial product, Mederma, which claims to diminish scars 2. When using either treatment, watch for evidence of itching or swelling. If you experience any symptoms, discontinue use of the product and consult your physician.

Does Mederma 2 help with scars?

The "Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology" reported on a 2009 study that found among subjects who had lesions removed from their upper chests, more than three-quarters of those using Mederma reported a moderate to significant improvement is the appearance of their scars 2 5.

Can you use both scars?

Yes : As long as no irritation to the normal skin around the scar occurs , using both will be fine. However, it does not mean that by using both the scar w ... Read More

Is massage good for skin?

Massage is Good: The skin is a great barrier, and most oils cannot penetrate to the living cells. The massaging action of application does help. Vaseline works well to ... Read More

Does Vitamin E help scars?

Don't bother with E.: Vitamin e doesn't have any benefit on scars - and many people actually get an allergic reaction & rash from it. There are much better products availa... Read More

Can scar revision be done under local anesthesia?

Scar revision.: If the scar is irregular, thick, or wide, no topical of any kind will be helpful, but plastic surgical scar revision under local anesthesia may give t... Read More

Is Vitamin Ee good for scars?

Never: Vitamin ee may be a good moisturizing agent but there is very little research to show it will improve scars other than the effects of massaging it in ... Read More

How to use Mederma for scars?

Merz Pharmaceuticals, makers of Mederma products, claim that using Mederma helps make scars less noticeable and promotes softer and smoother skin tissue in the area of the scar. Mederma Skin Care for Scars is a greaseless, invisible topical gel. The primary active ingredient in the product’s patented formula is a proprietary botanical extract called Cepalin. You can apply Mederma to a wound as soon as it is healed, or in the case of surgical scars, when the sutures are removed. You use the gel three to four times per day for eight weeks on a new scar, or for three to six months on an existing scar.

What is vitamin E?

Vitamin E is the term used to describe a group of tocol and tocotrienol derivatives, one of which -- alpha-tocopherol -- is a useful part of the human diet. Vitamin E is an ingredient in most skin creams, and when applied topically, a small amount penetrates the skin surface where it has beneficial antioxidant effects, according to the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University. You can purchase vitamin E in liquid or capsule form. If using the pill form, puncture the capsule with a pin and squeeze out the liquid.

Does vitamin E help scars?

Evidence from scientific studies suggests against the use of vitamin E as a scar preventive. The effectiveness of topical vitamin E in treating surgical wounds is not proven, and in some individuals it can cause contact dermatitis. A 1999 study performed at the University of Miami Department of Dermatology and Cutaneous Surgery showed that applying topical vitamin E not only did not help the appearance of scar tissue, but in some cases actually worsened the cosmetic appearance of scars.

What is the best product for scars?

Scar creams can be an effective choice for certain types of scars. The ingredients in OTC scar reduction products that have been clinically found to be the most effective include silicone and onion extract. Last medically reviewed on July 13, 2020.

What is the best treatment for scarring?

Severe or deep scarring can require medical treatments to reduce them, such as cryosurgery, laser therapy, injections, or radiation . For scars that fall somewhere in between mild and severe, at-home treatments, including scar creams, may have benefit.

What is the best cream for scars after surgery?

Best scar cream after surgery. Silicone products have been clinically proven. Trusted Source. to be one of the most effective at-home scar treatments available for a variety of scar types, including hypertrophic, keloid, acne, and burn scars, as well as surgical scars, including those from a cesarean delivery.

How is scar tissue formed?

Scar tissue in a wound is formed quickly by parallel collagen fibers. If too much collagen is produced, the scar may become raised, forming a hypertrophic scar.

How to make scars heal faster?

If so, using them more often won’t make your scar heal any faster. Start with a clean area. To use scar creams, and especially silicone sheets, wash and dry your skin where they’ll be applied. Use in combination. Talk to your doctor about ancillary treatments, which may make the use of scar cream more effective.

How long does it take for a scar to heal?

They can determine if it’ll be beneficial for the type of scar you have. In some instances, your provider may recommend waiting up to 1 year for the scar to completely heal and mature before any treatment is attempted. In other instances, immediate treatment will be recommended.

Does Mederma gel help with scars?

Allantoin: Allantoin reduces itching, irritation, and dryness. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel works nicely on reducing the overall appearance of scars, eliminating redness, and improving skin texture. It doesn’t work on reducing the appearance of hypopigmentation, though.

What is the best product to use for scars?

Products that contain either medical-grade silicone or centelline are probably your best bet. Over the counter scar gels or creams can be a great place to start for someone who wants to start treating a scar immediately. If you’re into all-natural ingredients, brands like Derma E are also a great place to start.

What is the best ingredient for scar cream?

Silicone is a common ingredient in scar creams, and it works by keeping the affected area hydrated. Keeping skin hydrated helps promote cell growth, and turnover. “Research has shown it to be the most effective ingredient for scar improvement,” says Latanya Benjamin, M.D., a Florida-based pediatric dermatologist.

How to fade scars?

There are ways to fade your scar, even if you’ve had it for longer than a year. Products that contain either medical-grade silicone or centelline are probably your best bet. Over-the-counter scar gels or creams can be a great place to start for someone who wants to start treating a scar immediately. If you’re into all-natural ingredients, brands like Derma E are also a great place to start. Know your scar and exactly the type of healing you want. Buying a scar cream that’s targeted for your problem area may help—especially if you’re looking for a product specifically for facial scars.

What is the best face cream for scars?

When it comes to treating scars on your face, you want the best quality formula to help restore your natural beauty. X-Scar's Facial Scar Cream with Vitamin E uses both silicone and vitamin E to help reduce the appearance of facial scars as well as surgical scars, C-section scars, cuts, and burns.

What is the best treatment for burn scars?

Medical-grade silicone is one of the best non-surgical treatments for burn scars. It’s been used in the treatment of burn scars for more than 30 years. It blends easily, and it should begin improving your scar’s appearance within two months of twice-daily treatments.

Can scar cream be used on face?

Targeted Anatomy. Dr. Benjamin notes that most scar creams are designed to work for your face and body. If you have particularly sensitive skin , you may want to look for a scar cream that specifically lists that it’s made to be used on the face. Otherwise, it’s mainly about preference.

Does Bio Oil help with stretch marks?

Reviewers routinely give Bio-Oil’s skincare oil five stars, and lovers of this product say they've seen scar fading from stretch marks, acne scars, and even hand scars. This product contains PurCellin Oil, which helps the product absorb into the skin. It’s also made with vitamin E, which helps provide a more even skin tone and natural chamomile, which soothes the skin as the product gets to work.

1. Puriderma Scar Removal Cream

Allantoin helps skin to slough off dead cells minimizing scar thickness

7. ScarAway Scar Diminishing Gel

We all have scars that are decades old, along with those newly acquired ones. In both cases, we want to get rid of them, and ScarAway scar diminishing gel helps to flatten and fade raised scars and keyloids.

9. ScarFade Silicone Gel for Scar Repair

It doesn’t matter what types of scars you’re dealing with, what’s probably clear by now is that the big hitter in scar management is silicone. That’s the magic in this formula from ScarFade. This clear silicone serum has been clinically proven to improve the look and feel of scars, leaving them smoother, lighter and flatter.

When was vitamin E discovered?

Vitamin E was discovered in 1922 in Berkeley, California when scientists noticed a vital ingredient was missing in the semipurified diet of lab rats. The missing ingredient was responsible for reproductive complications in the control group. When the rats were fed lettuce, their conditions improved. This led researchers to predict the existence of an unknown organic compound, later known as vitamin E.

What is the purpose of metabolizing vitamin E?

Consuming and metabolizing vitamin E is what allows people to obtain its health-related benefits. When consumed, vitamin E is broken down as a fat-soluble and absorbed by our cell membranes. Our cells then use this vitamin as a protective barrier against oxidative (stress-related) damage. Cell oxidation occurs when our immune system fights off an infection, or when our cells metabolize glucose to make energy.

What are the two classes of organic compounds that make up the vitamin E?

Vitamin E is a group of compounds consisting of tocopherols and tocotrienols —two classes of organic chemical molecules. Four tocopherol and four tocotrienol molecules make up the entire vitamin E compound and contribute to the vitamin’s nutritional activity in mammals. Gamma-Tocopherol is the most abundant class of vitamin E found in American diets. Almonds, spinach, and wheat germ oil are just some of the foods that contain vitamin E.

What is biodermis?

Biodermis is an innovative market leader with 30 years of expertise in the medical silicone industry. Visit Biodermis.com today to explore a complete range of scar management and post-operative care solutions.

Does vitamin E help scars?

The short answer: there are no proven benefits for using vitamin E topically, and it may even worsen the appearance of your scar.

Is silicone gel good for scars?

Silicone gel technology was introduced to the market over 30 years ago and numerous clinical studies support its efficacy in flattening and reducing the appearance of keloid and hypertrophic scars. Medical silicone, when applied topically, mimics the occlusion properties of the stratum corneum layer of the skin. The ability to induce hyrdation and regulate collagen synthesis at the scar site are silicone's understood mechanisms of action. Silicone is semi-permeable, so it allows the user to control the perfect balance (homeostasis) of oxygen and moisture retention at the scar bed.

Can you use both scars?

Yes : As long as no irritation to the normal skin around the scar occurs , using both will be fine. However, it does not mean that by using both the scar w ... Read More

Is massage good for skin?

Massage is Good: The skin is a great barrier, and most oils cannot penetrate to the living cells. The massaging action of application does help. Vaseline works well to ... Read More

Does Vitamin E help scars?

Don't bother with E.: Vitamin e doesn't have any benefit on scars - and many people actually get an allergic reaction & rash from it. There are much better products availa... Read More

Can scar revision be done under local anesthesia?

Scar revision.: If the scar is irregular, thick, or wide, no topical of any kind will be helpful, but plastic surgical scar revision under local anesthesia may give t... Read More

Is Vitamin Ee good for scars?

Never: Vitamin ee may be a good moisturizing agent but there is very little research to show it will improve scars other than the effects of massaging it in ... Read More

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9