What are the disadvantages of evidence based medicine?
Feb 10, 2022 · Evidence-based therapies (EBTs) have been shown to improve a variety of mental health conditions and overall well-being. These treatments are tailored to each Veteran’s needs, priorities, values, preferences, and goals for therapy.
What are the principles of evidence based practice?
Jun 15, 2016 · Evidence-based medicine (EBM) seeks reliable answers that can help you find the treatment that is right for you. It is based on scientific proof, and not just theories or expert opinions. If you're ill, you'll usually want to get better as soon as possible.
Which treatment is best?
Aug 05, 2017 · Therapists who use treatments based on science engage in what is called “evidence-based practice” (EBP). If the treatments they use have scientific evidence supporting the effectiveness of the treatments, they are called evidence-based treatments (EBTs).
What are some examples of evidence based practices?
“Evidence based medicine is the conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients. The practice of evidence based medicine means integrating individual clinical expertise with the best available external clinical evidence from systematic research.” Sackett et al., 1996
See more
Evidence-based treatment is defined as any therapy that’s proven its effectiveness during peer-reviewed scientific experiments. It’s broken down by The Association for Behavioral and Cognitive Therapies as “adherence to psychological approaches and techniques based on scientific evidence.”
What are examples of evidence-based treatments?
Evidence-based TherapiesApplied Behavior Analysis.Behavior therapy.Cognitive behavioral therapy.Cognitive therapy.Family therapy.Dialectical behavior therapy.Interpersonal psychotherapy.Organizational Skills Training.Aug 5, 2017
Why is it important to use evidence-based treatments?
What are evidence-based treatment methods, and why is it important to use them? When we say that a treatment method is “evidence-based,” we mean that it is backed up by objective, scientific evidence that proves it is effective, so evidence-based methods keep us in the lineage of the scientific method.Jun 16, 2017
What defines evidence-based?
A widely used adjective in education, evidence-based refers to any concept or strategy that is derived from or informed by objective evidence—most commonly, educational research or metrics of school, teacher, and student performance.Feb 5, 2016
How do you know if a treatment is evidence-based?
A Definition. Evidence-Based Therapy (EBT), more broadly referred to as evidence-based practice (EBP), is any therapy that has shown to be effective in peer-reviewed scientific experiments.
What is the greatest benefit of evidence-based therapy?
Ultimately, the goal of EBP is the promotion and implementation of psychotherapies that are safe, consistent, and cost-effective [32]. As a result, evidence-based psychotherapies are associated with higher quality and more accountability [29], as well as the enhancement of the health and well-being of the public [19].Jun 26, 2017
What is evidence-based practice in simple terms?
Evidence-based practice is a conscientious, problem-solving approach to clinical practice that incorporates the best evidence from well-designed studies, patient values and preferences, and a clinician's expertise in making decisions about a patient's care.
What is evidence-based practice in healthcare?
Evidence-based practice (EBP) is defined by Duke University Medical Center as "the integration of clinical expertise, patient values and the best research evidence into the decision-making process for patient care."Oct 26, 2018
What does evidence-based health care mean?
Evidence-based practice is the use of the best available evidence together with a clinician's expertise and a patient's values and preferences in making health care decisions.
What is a randomized controlled trial?
As the name suggests, randomized controlled trials randomly allocate participants to treatment condition and control for extraneous factors that could confound interpretations of causality. However, recent critics have begun to question whether the findings achieved under such tightly controlled studies will translate into routine clinical practice. Instead, many researchers are suggesting effectiveness trials, which test interventions in real-world settings, with the patients and therapists likely to be using the intervention. This design choice consequently limits intervention studies to those that can be realistically administered given staff preferences, time, and resources ( Hunsley & Lee, 2007 ).
What is motivational interviewing?
Motivational interviewing (MI) is a brief, client-centered, directive intervention that enables clients to explore and resolve ambivalence about change ( Rollnick & Miller, 1995 ). In MI, therapists are encouraged to take a nonjudgmental stance and guide patients through the process of exploring their substance use in the context of personal goals and values. This intervention has been widely studied and shows moderate levels of efficacy in the treatment of alcohol and drug disorders, as well as in engaging people in other forms of addiction treatment ( Hettema, Steele, & Miller, 2005 ). MI techniques are discussed further in Chapter 9.
What is cognitive behavioral therapy?
Cognitive behavioral approaches are based on the theory that learning processes play a formative role in the development and maintenance of addictive behaviors. These treatments are among the most widely studied. Considering the extensive research that has been conducted in establishing cognitive behavioral therapy as an empirically supported treatment and that few differences are found when comparing cognitive behavioral treatments (see the Mesa Grande study described earlier), researchers have suggested that effective elements across cognitive behavioral approaches be combined ( Kadden, 2001 ). For more information on cognitive behavioral therapy as a treatment method, see Chapter 8.
What is Project Match?
Project MATCH was a multisite, collaborative project supported by the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. The study was designed to test matching hypotheses, which predicted that clients with certain characteristics would fare better in one treatment versus another. Clients were assigned randomly to one of three treatments (cognitive behavioral treatment [CBT], motivational enhancement therapy [MET], or 12-step facilitation [TSF]) and their outcomes were compared based on 10 client variables, including psychiatric severity and level of motivation ( Project MATCH Research Group, 1993 ). At a 12-month follow-up, participants from all three treatments had more days abstinent and drank fewer drinks per episode when compared with baseline assessments. However, few of the matching hypotheses were supported. Findings indicated that CBT, MET, and TSF were equally effective in improving alcohol outcomes and that specific patient characteristics do not differentially influence the effectiveness of these interventions.
Why is there increasing pressure for programs to justify their outcomes against competing approaches?
Across the country, there is increasing pressure for programs to justify their outcomes against competing approaches so that they can collect insurance reimbursement. Increasingly, treatment programs need hard scientific evidence to maintain their existence.
Can acamprosate and naltrexone be combined?
The COMBINE study expanded on the findings of Project MATCH to determine whether combining medications for alcohol dependence (naltrexone, a camprosate) could improve the effectiveness of behavioral interventions. In COMBINE, a combined behavioral intervention was created that incorporated aspects of all three treatments from Project MATCH. In addition, COMBINE tested a medication management (MM) intervention, a less involved treatment focusing on providing support and medication compliance. To explore which medication and behavioral treatment combination led to better outcomes, participants in the study were randomly assigned to one of nine treatment combinations. Results from the COMBINE study showed that adding a brief intervention (MM) to naltrexone can be a cost-effective way of treating alcohol dependence and that a combination of medication and behavioral treatment was more effective than medications alone ( Anton et al., 2006 ). The implication of these results is that, via the use of a variation of MM (i.e., more focused and fewer sessions) combined with naltrexone, it may be possible to treat alcohol dependence in primary care settings.
Is there any research on substance abuse?
Although a great deal of research has been conducted on substance abuse intervention, clear-cut evaluation of the quality and relevance of such research is not easy. There are many factors to consider when deciding how much weight to give a particular piece of evidence.
What is EBT treatment?
Evidence-Based Treatment (EBT) Evidence-based treatment (EBT) refers to treatment that is backed by scientific evidence. That is, studies have been conducted and extensive research has been documented on a particular treatment, and it has proven to be successful. The goal of EBT is to encourage the use of safe and effective treatments likely ...
What is EBP in psychology?
To date, EBP has received a great deal of attention from organizations like the American Psychological Association (APA), which advocates for more evidence-based practices and treatments in dealing with mental health issues. In a statement from the APA Council of Representatives (2005), EBP was defined as “the integration ...
Why is evidence based medicine important?
EBP evolved from evidence-based medicine (EBM), which was established in 1992 for the same reasons: to encourage the use of safe, effective medicine as opposed to poorly studied, potentially harmful options.
Why is it important to look at who is funding the research?
It is also important to look at who is funding the research, as well as how and where the studies are conducted; ideally, multiple independent and unbiased studies will be conducted that verify the safety and effectiveness of a treatment.
What is the National Registry for Evidence-Based Programs and Practices?
The National Registry for Evidence-Based Programs and Practices (NREPP), which is maintained by the United States’ Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), lists all evidence-based programs and practices. To be listed in NREPP, a practice must be determined, after extensive research, to have significant impact on ...
Is EBT a controversy?
The subject of EBT has sparked a substantial amount of controversy in the mental health field over the years, mainly regarding the process of evaluating whether something is an EBT (Nathan, 2004; Tanenbaum, 2005).
Is EBT based on scientific evidence?
EBT in Child and Adolescent Therapy. Since they are presumably based on scientific evidence, evidence- based treatments are encouraged in coping with issues faced by children and adolescents. However, it is important to note that when choosing a treatment for a minor, parents, guardians, and practitioners should always examine ...
What is evidence based therapy?
Therapists who use treatments based on science engage in what is called “evidence-based practice” (EBP). If the treatments they use have scientific evidence supporting the effectiveness of the treatments, they are called evidence-based treatments (EBTs).
What is mental health care?
Mental health care providers (psychologists, social workers, psychiatrists) use different treatment approaches to help children and adolescents who are experiencing mental health problems. Some treatment approaches have a strong backing in scientific evidence and other treatments have less evidence supporting them.
Do treatments work better for children?
Research studies have shown that some treatments work better than others for specific problems that children and adolescents experience. In this research, treatments are compared in large studies called clinical trials that involve dozens of children in each study.
What Are The Goals of Evidence-Based Treatment?
The primary goals of this treatment approach are increasing accountability and increasing the quality of treatment. Meeting the goals increases the likelihood a client’s insurance company will approve treatment, and it increases the chances a client will pay the fees and seek treatment.
Types of Evidence-Based Treatment
For the method to become evidence-based, it requires in-depth academic and scientific research. The effectiveness must be demonstrated in more than one study, and it must integrate medical-based research and client experiences and values of the clinical provider.
Helpful Terms
Aspects of evidence-based practice are referred to by several similar terms. Some of these are used interchangeably, though they do have different meanings and applications.
Principles and Benefits of EBT
Evidence-based treatments are attractive options for many and offer several benefits. Some people feel more confident knowing the treatment they’re receiving has been tested and proven to be effective enough to be classified as an EBT. Below are a few of the foundational principles and benefits of evidence-based treatments.
Potential Disadvantages of EBT
Not all patients, or even behavioral health professionals, prefer evidence-based therapies. One reason for this is because the process for evaluating and classifying something as “evidence-based” is debatable and can even be seen as subjective.
Why You May Still Want to Consider Other Treatments
There are a lot of types of substance use and mental health disorder treatments that aren’t classified as EBTs. Just because their effectiveness may not necessarily be measurable or backed by large bodies of scientific evidence, doesn’t mean they aren’t still useful (or even effective).
Finding the Best Evidence-Based Addiction Treatment for You
In the field of substance use and mental health disorder treatment, there are many different approaches to recovery. What works for one person may not work for another. For some, scientific evidence is an important factor in choosing a treatment and rehab center.
What is the purpose of the expansion of the definition of psychotherapy?
This expansion of the definition is particularly important in the context of psychotherapy where the effectiveness of the treatment is in large part determined by the patient’s investment and belief in the efficacy of the treatment.
What is evidence based therapy?
Evidence-Based Therapy (EBT), more broadly referred to as evidence-based practice (EBP), is any therapy t hat has shown to be effective i n peer-reviewed scientific experiments. According to the Association for Behavioral and Cognitive Therapies, evidence-based practice is characterized by an:
What are the goals of evidence based practice?
Two of the main goals behind evidence-based practice are: 1 increased quality of treatment, and 2 increased accountability.
Is ICBT effective for anxiety?
One such effort examined the feasibility of internet-delivered cognitive behavior therapy (IBCT), which found that ICBT can be effective in treating children and adolescents with anxiety and depressive symptoms (Vigerland et al., 2016).
Is cognitive behavior therapy evidence based?
Since cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the strongest evidence-based therapies out there, it is important to include a book that discusses CBT specifically. This book discusses the literature surrounding CBT and also how to incorporate these findings into a clinical practice.
Is DBT a good treatment for BPD?
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is also an evidence-based treatment, as it has been shown to be effective for relieving the symptoms and improving outcomes for patients with both borderline personality disorder (BPD) and substance abuse (Linehan et al., 1999) as well as for patients with trichotillomania (Keuthen et al., 2011).
Is EBT a good practice?
The American Psychiatric Association and the American Psychological Association both consider EBT/EBP to be: “‘best practice’ and one of the ‘preferred’ approaches for the treatment of psychological symptoms”. In relevant literature, evidence-based medicine has also been defined as the:
