Previous research indicates that the therapeutic alliance is a main factor in determining successful outcomes of psychotherapy. The goal of this study was to expand the understanding of not only the therapeutic alliance, but also how other contributing factors such as empathy, experience of the therapist, therapeutic modality, client’s level
Full Answer
What are the factors that influence the outcome of psychotherapy?
Evidence-based research on common factors has shown that relationship factors in a therapeutic dyad or group setting predict the outcome of psychotherapy. The common factors include the therapeutic alliance, empathy, goal consensus and collaboration, positive regard and affirmation, mastery, congruence/genuineness, and mentalization.
What is the best way to predict the outcome of psychotherapy?
Luborsky L., Crits-Cristoph P., Alexander L., Margolis M., Cohen M. (1983). Two helping alliance methods for predicting outcomes of psychotherapy: a counting signs vs. a global rating method.
What is the positive psychotherapy model?
The Positive Psychotherapy Model (inc. Table with Brief Session Descriptions) Similar to other therapy models, the PPT model focuses on a series of sessions aimed at uncovering ideas, desires, vulnerabilities and strengths, and working through them to reach positive reframing and overall balance between the positive and the negative.
Are the common factors therapeutic?
The evidence, however, strongly suggests that the common factors must be considered therapeutic and attention must be given to them, in terms of theory, research and practice. One of the criticisms of the common factors is that they are an atheoretical collection of commonalities.
What factors predict a successful outcome for psychotherapy?
These common factors include:Collaboration: the therapist and patient agree on treatment goals, approach and tasks.Alliance: a confiding relationship and emotionally-charged bond between therapist and patient.Empathy: the therapist is able to adopt the patient's perspective and share the patient's emotional state.More items...•
Which factor is most predictive of positive outcomes in therapy?
The most powerful of those common factors have been referred to as the “therapeutic alliance,” referring to the bond between client and therapist. Study after study has shown that the quality of the relationship between client and therapist is the only reliable and the most powerful predictor of a positive outcome.
What are the three main factors that predict whether therapy will be successful?
The 3 Things That Influence Your Success in TherapyForming a strong bond with your therapist.Setting clear goals together.Committing to the process.
What are 2 factors that can impact the effectiveness of psychotherapy?
Three common factors which are nonspecific to a particular type of therapy are: treatment alliance, therapist effects, and extra-therapeutic factors. These common factors are responsible for much of the outcome variance.
What are possible common factors in psychotherapy that might account for its effectiveness and why is it important to know about them?
To understand the evidence supporting them as important therapeutic elements, the contextual model of psychotherapy is outlined. Then the evidence, primarily from meta-analyses, is presented for particular common factors, including alliance, empathy, expectations, cultural adaptation, and therapist differences.
Which is the most important factor in therapy outcome?
Over the years, research has confirmed what so many therapists have known intuitively, that the therapeutic relationship itself is essential to the success a patient experiences. Some studies have even called it the most important common factor in successful outcomes.
Which of the following is the best predictor of therapeutic success?
Interestingly enough, patients and therapists often (but not always) agree on the quality of their relationship. However, it is the patient's perception of the quality of the relationship that is the strongest predictor of treatment success.
What are the factors that may contribute to the success of psychodynamic therapy?
Factors that may impact what type of treatment is used include cost-effectiveness, availability, patient preferences, and the severity of the symptoms the person is experiencing.
How do you measure success in therapy?
Objective GoalsForms and Quesionnaires. One way to quantify some of these measurements is with a weekly or bi-weekly questionnaire. ... Therapy is a Non-Linear Process. ... Self-Acceptance. ... Self-Knowledge. ... Relationship Quality. ... Consideration of Others. ... Maintaining a Healthy Relationship. ... Your Goals May Change.More items...•
What are the factors that come into play in determining the effectiveness of therapy?
The effectiveness of a particular therapeutic approach can be assessed in three ways: client testimonials, providers' perceptions, and empirical research.Client Testimonials. Clients who get treatment for psychological problems often testify to their effectiveness. ... Providers' Perceptions. ... Empirical Research.
What are specific factors in psychotherapy?
The most widely studied common factors include the therapeutic alliance, therapist empathy, positive regard, genuineness, and client expectations for the outcome of therapy (i.e., the extent to which clients believe therapy will be helpful in alleviating problems) (Cuijpers, Reijnders, & Huibers, 2019).
What are the 5 common factors of psychotherapy?
In 1986, David Orlinsky and Kenneth Howard presented their generic model of psychotherapy, which proposed that five process variables are active in any psychotherapy: the therapeutic contract, therapeutic interventions, the therapeutic bond between therapist and patient, the patient's and therapist's states of self- ...
What are the common factors in psychotherapy?
Then the evidence, primarily from meta-analyses, is presented for particular common factors, including alliance, empathy, ...
Why is psychotherapy demoralized?
Frank (4) discussed how patients present to psychotherapy demoralized not only because of their distress , but also because they have attempted many times and in many ways to overcome their problems , always unsuccessfully. Participating in psychotherapy appears to be a form of remoralization.
Is common factor therapeutic?
The evidence, however, strongly suggests that the common factors must be considered therapeutic and attention must be given to them, in terms of theory, research and practice. One of the criticisms of the common factors is that they are an atheoretical collection of commonalities.
Who invented the common factors?
The so-called common factors have a long history in psychiatry, originating with a seminal article by S. Rosenzweig in 1936 (1) and popularized by J. Frank in the various editions of his book Persuasion and Healing(2–4).
Does psychotherapy have a unitary effect?
That is, psychotherapy does not have a unitary influence on patients, but rather works through various mechanisms. The mechanisms underlying the three pathways entail evolved characteristics of humans as the ultimate social species; as such, psychotherapy is a special case of a social healing practice.
Who challenged the efficacy of psychotherapy?
A challenge by Eysenck (1952), who claimed that the efficacy of psychotherapy had not been demonstrated and that any improvements were the result of so-called spontaneous remission, stimulated significant developments in the study of outcomes in psychotherapy.
Is the scale used in outcome research?
The scale has not been used in outcome research. Open in a separate window. Any attempt to measure something as complex as therapeutic alliance involves a series of conceptual and methodological shortcomings, which have probably hindered the development of research in this field.
What is the problem with clinical judgment in the treatment setting?
The problem with clinical judgment in the treatment setting is both time and method. Clinicians do not have time to routinely and thoroughly assess client functioning across all the domains of interest. With few exceptions, therapists do not routinely employ reliable assessments at each visit so that precision in assessment is lacking. Most therapists do not use modern actuarial methods that can accurately predict treatment failure and thus never become aware that the treatment is not working. Therapists in general are happy to treat clients in the absence of “lab” test data. This situation (practice without monitoring and alerting) has a long tradition in psychotherapy practice, training, and supervision, but one that is no longer justified in the age of advanced statistical modeling, computers, and appropriate software.
How long does it take to complete a mental health assessment?
We can create a reliable and valid assessment of patient mental health functioning (internal pain, interpersonal functioning, life functioning, and well being) that can be completed in 5-minutes. Clients find it perfectly acceptable to complete it on a weekly basis before each treatment session.