People have made ethical challenges to a popular treatment method known as Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA). Critics of ABA argue that ABA does not actually improve the skills of autistic people, but instead only teaches them to mimic neurotypical behavior without really understanding the meaning of the social cues they are using.
Full Answer
What are our theoretical ambitions for the treatment of autism spectrum disorder?
The theoretical ambitions are to explore what would constitute both effective and ethical treatment of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD).
What are the ethical issues in assessment?
Ethical Issues in Assessment 1 Ethical Standards 2 Competence – Acquiring It & Maintaining It 3 Informing Patients/Clients & Obtaining Consent 4 Providing Accurate and Adequate Feedback 5 Providing Access to Test Reports & Data 6 Other Ethical Issues in Assessment. Describe the Ethical Standards that especially apply in assessment cases. ...
Are autism advocates justified in their concerns?
Our contribution is to argue that, from a bioethical perspective, autism advocates are fully justified in their concerns-the rights of autistic children and their parents are being regularly infringed upon.
How does ABA help individuals with autism?
Furthermore, ABA focuses on changing socially significant behaviors with procedures that are clearly defined and replicable. Unlike other interventions for individuals with autism, much data exist that supports the effectiveness of ABA in the treatment of individuals with autism.
What ethical issues are involved in helping individuals with autism?
Complexity encourages us to consider the ethical dilemmas autism unveils: questions of autonomy, decision making, and intrinsic worth. It forces us to question the assumption that people with autism can't speak for themselves and to carefully balance the need for treatment with the respect for the person.
What are the ethical issues with intervention?
Too often, interveners focus on the outcome without considering the mediating variables that can influence the outcome; therefore, intervention outcomes may fail or be short-lived. Many ethical issues with respect to how interventions are designed and implemented can affect their success or failure.
What are ethical issues in ABA?
The seven ethical issues applied behavioral analysts must consider are:Self-Care Concerns.Friendships with Clients or Families.Inappropriate Parenting.Financial Concerns.Ethical Concerns with Employer.Ethical Considerations Regarding Research.Complicated Decision-Making.
Is ABA for autism ethical?
Wilkenfeld and McCarthy (2020) demonstrated that ABA is unethical from a bioethics perspective. ABA violates autonomy insofar as it coercively closes off certain paths of identity formation.
What are ethics issues?
Ethical issues occur when a given decision, scenario or activity creates a conflict with a society's moral principles. Both individuals and businesses can be involved in these conflicts, since any of their activities might be put to question from an ethical standpoint.
What are moral ethical issues?
“Moral issue is a working definition of an issue of moral concern is presented as any issue with the potential to help or harm anyone, including oneself.”
Why are ethics in ABA important?
If a Behavior Analyst is not acting in an ethical manner, she or he could put themselves or their organization in danger of losing clients. This could lead to new potential clients avoiding care, as well as the exit of long-term clients.
What is an ethical dilemma example?
Some examples of ethical dilemma include: Taking credit for others' work. Offering a client a worse product for your own profit. Utilizing inside knowledge for your own profit.
Is applied Behaviour analysis ethical?
In §6 we look at objections, of which the most prominent is that ABA is ethical because “it works”; we will consider this as an argument from the bioethical principle of beneficence (that everything should be done to benefit patients).
Can ABA be harmful?
In short, ABA is a safe, highly beneficial therapy. But if a therapist is not properly trained or attuned to the child, the therapist could inadvertently make target behaviors worse or lead to the creation of new problem behaviors.
What does ABA stand for in autism?
Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) is an approach to understanding and changing behaviour. It's not a specific therapy itself, but a range of different strategies and techniques that can be used to help autistic people learn new skills and behaviour.
What is the most effective treatment for autism?
The most common developmental therapy for people with ASD is Speech and Language Therapy. Speech and Language Therapy helps to improve the person's understanding and use of speech and language. Some people with ASD communicate verbally.
What should a physician do when treating children with autism?
In treating children with autism, physicians should reframe the common dynamic in which the family wants medication that the doctor is withholding to focus instead on the family’s and physician’s share goal —the patient’s well-being.
When was autism first diagnosed?
The level of debate over autism spectrum disorder belies its relatively short history among recognized diagnoses. Since the first US use of the term in the 1940s, much disagreement has been voiced about its causes, whether it is an illness or a feature of our neurodiversity, and how best to support those who have the diagnosis.
What is an epidemic autism?
The autism "epidemic": Ethical, legal, and social issues in a developmental spectrum disorder. Classic autism has gradually evolved into the concept of a larger "spectrum disorder.".
Is autism a spectrum disorder?
Classic autism has gradually evolved into the concept of a larger "spectrum disorder.". The rising prevalence of autism and autism spectrum disorder (autism/ASD) diagnoses can be largely attributed to broader diagnostic criteria, adoption of dimensional assessment strategies, increased awareness, linking of services to diagnosis, ...
What is the ultimate responsibility of autism researchers?
Autism researchers must remember that their ultimate responsibility is to the autistic individuals, not their parents or guardians . In the end, everyone involved in autism research should be working toward the goal of improving quality of life and remediating disability for those on the spectrum.
Is it possible to have more than one autistic child?
The real threat today – new studies show parents with one autistic child are far more likely to have additional children with autism. Parents with autism and one autistic child are at even greater risk. That news will have significant family planning impact.
How can behavior analysts help parents?
Behavior analysts can help parents to evaluate the impact of such interventions by suggesting a way to objectively assess their effect on targeted skills or behaviors. In many cases this may involve some type of single case design.
What is behavior analytic services?
Often in clinical practice, behavior analytic services are offered in combination with interventions that are not empirically validated. Essentially, ABA is often combined with other (non-validated) approaches in an eclectic model of intervention. Such dilution of services often leads to reduced effectiveness.
Is there inconsistency between approaches and treatments?
In addition, there may be inconsistencies between approaches or interactions between treatments with differing philosophies and methods. Furthermore, many families pursue a wide variety of alternative interventions. Challenges are multiple and progress is slow, even with very effective and excellent intervention.
Is ABA effective for autism?
Unlike other interventions for individuals with autism, much data exist that supports the effectiveness of ABA in the treatment of individuals with autism. It is important to note that these studies have been published over the course of several decades, by hundreds of researchers worldwide, and many of them have been published in peer-reviewed ...
Abstract
Treatment efficacy is very important. However, establishing ethical guidelines that examine the intrusiveness, cost, time commitment, and side effect (s) is critical. These factors are essential in determining the most humane way to provide care.
References (76)
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.