Treatment FAQ

how was the british treatment of the irish similar to the treatment of native americans in americ

by Deja Hayes Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

It made English settlers regard the Native Americans as inferior heathens, much as the English regarded the Irish as heathen.

British Occupation
Both Natives and the Irish were occupied by the British—both were sent to boarding schools and forced to abandon their traditional language and culture. Both suffered genocide, starvation and diseases at the hands of the British.
Mar 16, 2015

Full Answer

How did England treat the natives in their colonies?

Oct 04, 2017 · The English creator of the period drama “Victoria” has said the British treatment of the Irish has an equivalent in the history of racism in America and she wanted to tackle "ignorant ...

How was religion used to justify the treatment of the natives?

Stereotyped. Irish and Native Americans both fall foul of the annoying human desire to tar groups of people with the same brush. Katie Kane is a professor of the Colonial Studies Program at the ...

Were England’s colonists hostile to Native Americans?

Mar 10, 2018 · The treatment of America’s native population is one of the great stains on the history of Western colonialism. The reality of conquest has been cloaked in …

Were Irish people mistreated in the early United States?

Mar 07, 2015 · Another similarity between the history of Native Americans and the Irish is that both were subjected to what has been called “othering.” As Kiberd explains, “the English have presented themselves to the world as controlled, refined and rooted; and so it suited them to find the Irish hot-headed, rude and nomadic, the perfect foil to set off their own virtues” (9)(full …

How were the Irish treated when they came to America?

Disease of all kinds (including cholera, typhus, tuberculosis, and mental illness) resulted from these miserable living conditions. Irish immigrants sometimes faced hostility from other groups in the U.S., and were accused of spreading disease and blamed for the unsanitary conditions many lived in.

How did British settlers treat Natives?

They welcomed the Natives into their settlements, and the colonists willingly engaged in trade with them. They hoped to transform the tribes people into civilized Christians through their daily contacts. The Native Americans resented and resisted the colonists' attempts to change them.May 14, 2004

What was the relationship between the English and the Natives?

While Native Americans and English settlers in the New England territories first attempted a mutual relationship based on trade and a shared dedication to spirituality, soon disease and other conflicts led to a deteriorated relationship and, eventually, the First Indian War.Jun 26, 2020

How were Irish immigrants treated in the United States in the 1840s?

Conditions for many Irish immigrants to U.S. cities in the 1840s and 1850s were not much better than those they had left behind. They often crammed into shanty towns, living in shacks cobbled together out of discarded boards and other debris. Sanitation was haphazard at best.

How did the English treat the Natives compared to the Spanish?

The Spanish and English colonies were slightly alike in the poor and unfair treatment of indigenous people and substantially different in religion and economic base. The Spanish and English were slightly comparable in terms of treatment of indigenous people because of enslavement of native people and taking their land.

How did the British treat the colonists?

They had to pay high taxes to the king. They felt that they were paying taxes to a government where they had no representation. They were also angry because the colonists were forced to let British soldiers sleep and eat in their homes. The 13 original states.

How did the southern colonies treat the Natives?

Relations with American Indians in the Southern Colonies began somewhat as a peaceful coexistence. As more English colonists began to arrive and encroach further into native lands, the relationship became more violent.

What was the relationship between the Europeans and Native Americans?

During the colonial period, Native Americans had a complicated relationship with European settlers. They resisted the efforts of the Europeans to gain more of their land and control through both warfare and diplomacy.Mar 23, 2020

How were Native American treated by white settlers?

They stole livestock; burned and looted houses and towns; committed mass murder; and squatted on land that did not belong to them. State governments joined in this effort to drive Native Americans out of the South.Jul 7, 2020

How were the Irish treated in American society?

These people were prejudiced against the Irish. Irish immigrants often entered the workforce by taking low-status and dangerous jobs that were avoided by other workers. Many Irish women became household workers. Many Irish men labored in coal mines and built railroads and canals.Mar 15, 2017

How were the Irish treated when they came to Canada?

The Irish went through a lot of discrimination, and difficulties years after they migrated. What is this? The Irish famine immigration in the 1840s significantly affected Canada's history in that it helped Canada grow, hit them with their first epidemic, and saw the impact of discrimination.

How were the Irish treated when they came to Australia?

Over four thousand young female orphans from Irish workhouses were shipped to the Australian colonies at the time of the Great Famine (1848–50) to meet a demand for domestic servants. Some settlers greeted them with hostility and some were exploited or abused by employers and others.

A Famine Forces An Unprecedented Migration.

Fleeing a shipwreck of an island, nearly 2 million refugees from Ireland crossed the Atlantic to the United States in the dismal wake of the Great...

British Neglect Exacerbates The Irish Plight

More than just the pestilence was responsible for the Great Hunger. A political system ruled by London and an economic system dominated by British...

The Influx Heightens Religious tensions.

Conflict between Protestants and Catholics in the United States had already broken out in violence before the first potato plant wilted in Ireland....

A Nativist Backlash Begins.

The discrimination faced by the famine refugees was not subtle or insidious. It was right there in black and white, in newspaper classified adverti...

Nativists Use Violence to Further An Agenda.

In 1854, an anti-Catholic mob in Ellsworth, Maine, dragged Jesuit priest John Bapst—who had circulated a petition denouncing the use of the King Ja...

The Irish Find Their Footing—At The Ballot Box.

Although stereotyped as ignorant bogtrotters loyal only to the pope and ill-suited for democracy, and only recently given political rights by the B...

How did Irish music and stories get passed on?

Irish music and stories were passed on through word of mouth and stories and tunes were learned by ear by roaming harpists and the honorable scéalaí (storyteller). Native Americans share our passion for a story and used stories about the Great Spirit to explain the world around them. These too were never traditionally written down.

Where did poor relief officers go in 1847?

When they discovered that Poor Relief officers were not there, they took a desperate 15-mile walk to the home of the landlord to beg for food. Having been turned away from the house for disturbing the landlord’s lunch, many died on the return journey, some with grass in their mouths from attempts to stave off hunger.

How much money did the Choctaws raise for the Irish?

Despite the oppression faced by the Choctaws in the years preceding the famine, in 1847, on hearing of the plight and hunger of the Irish people, they raised $170 to send to Ireland and ease their suffering. This figure is equivalent to tens of thousands of dollars in today’s currency.

What was the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek?

Despite the allegiance shown by the Choctaws to General Jackson during the War of 1812, the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek signed on September 27, 1830, resulted in the Choctaws signing away the remainder of their traditional homelands in Alabama, Mississippi, and Florida and undertaking a forced march off the land.

Why did the Choctaws die on the Trail of Tears?

Over half the 21,000 Choctaws forced on this march perished on the trail due to malnutrition, disease, and exposure. The winter the Choctaws spent on the Trail of Tears was one of the coldest on record and even those who survived the journey to Oklahoma faced further hardships in creating new communities for themselves, along with new homes, ...

What is Irish folklore?

Irish folklore is full of cures and treatments using plants and stories about the birds and animals that share our countryside. A common theme in Native American stories is also the link between the people and the land and many of their traditions hold reverence for the land, too.

What were the consequences of the British colonization?

Both victims of British colonization and both suffered from hunger, genocide, and diseases as a result. Both peoples also walked a Trail of Sorrow that resulted in many deaths of their people.

What is the treatment of America's native population?

The treatment of America’s native population is one of the great stains on the history of Western colonialism. The reality of conquest has been cloaked in national myths that have been perpetuated through modern American history.

What happened to Native Americans after Columbus?

The reality is very different. While many Native Americans were wiped out by Western diseases following their early encounters with European explorers after Columbus, it was during the 19th-century that the wholescale displacement of a race of people accelerated.

What tribe was killed in the Sand Creek massacre?

The book depicts the brutality at the heart of the project, such as the mass hanging of the Santee Sioux tribe in Minnesota in 1862, the largest mass hanging in American history, and the Sand Creek Massacre two years later, which saw Southern Cheyenne and Arapaho Indians in Colorado killed by Union soldiers during the American civil war.

What is Varadkar's visit to the US?

Varadkar’s visit serves as a reminder of the plight of America’s indigenous inhabitants, at a time of heightened awareness in the US about the challenges facing immigrants and non-white Americans. The treatment of America’s native population is one of the great stains on the history of Western colonialism.

When did Mary Robinson visit the Choctaw Nation?

It won’t be the first visit to the tribe by an Irish representative. In 1995 , president Mary Robinson visited the Choctaw Nation in Oklahoma and was made an honorary chief.

Who donated to the Irish Famine?

Irish connections also reportedly spurred the Choctaw Indians farther south to donate to the Irish Famine victims. It was reportedly through an Irish soldier who was implementing the government’s mass displacement policy that the tribe heard of the famine devastating Ireland.

Who was the Irish general who was involved in the Bear River massacre?

Many Irish form part of this story – and not always in positive ways. Patrick Edward Connor from Co Kerry, a Union general during the civil war, played a central role in the assault on the Native American community. He masterminded the infamous Bear River Massacre of 1863, when hundreds of Shoshone villagers were killed in retaliation for a series of raids by the tribe.

What is the similarity between Native Americans and Irish?

Another similarity between the history of Native Americans and the Irish is that both were subjected to what has been called “othering.”.

What did the Choctaw do to help the Irish?

This incredible act of generosity was never forgotten and to this day the two communities retain a bond. In 1992, the Irish unveiled a plaque at the Lord Mayor’s Mansion in Dublin, Ireland that reads, “Their humanity calls us to remember the millions of human beings throughout our world today who die of hunger and hunger-related illness in a world of plenty.” In 2015, a feather sculpture entitled “Kindred Spirits” will debut in Cork, Ireland, to permanently commemorate the act of generosity of the Choctaw Nation.

How were American Indians affected by the Bureau of War?

The history of American Indians is all too similar to this violent takeover. The Nations in North America faced forced relocations and brutal attacks. Practices and cultural ceremonies like the Ghost Dance were outlawed, children were forcibly removed from homes, and efforts to eliminate their cultural practices, or “kill the Indian to save the man” dominated. Tribes were forced onto what are now called Reservations created by the Bureau of War — communities neither designed nor intended for sustainability. For over a century treaty and trust obligations were — and continue to be — ignored.

What did I learn about the Trail of Tears?

At some point during my secondary school education I learned about the Trail of Tears and that due to regular war-like conflicts American Indians were placed onto reservations to keep them “safe.” I learned that the Indian Wars ended at the “Battle of Wounded Knee” and that conflicts with American Indians are a thing of the past; ancient history that is unfortunate but irreversible.

Why did the American Indians portray themselves as savages?

A similar process occurred when American settlers portrayed the American Indians as savages in order to justify a complete cultural takeover. The legacy of these invented identities remain in the media and public consciousness.

What did the Lord Protector do?

The Lord Protector proceeded to outlaw all practice of Catholicism, punishable by death, and soon landed in Ireland with an extensive army that burned its way across the country, vanquishing resistance and taking the lives of civilians.

Why did the Irish clung to Catholicism?

As the English took away lands from Irish nobility and replaced them with English gentry, the Irish clung to their Catholicism as a stand against the invaders. In order to prevent the British from “going native” the English landowners in Ireland were forbidden from marrying Irish women or dressing like the Irish.

Why were the Irish vilified?

However, while the number of German immigrants entering the United States nearly matched that of the Irish during the 1850s, the Irish were particularly vilified by the country’s Anglo-Saxon Protestants whose ancestors had explicitly made their exodus across the ocean to find a refuge from papism and ensure their worship was cleansed of any remaining Catholic vestiges. Feelings toward the Vatican had softened little in the two centuries following the sailing of the Mayflower. The country’s oldest citizens could still personally remember when America was an English colony and papal effigies were burned in city streets during annual Guy Fawkes Day celebrations.

Who was the British civil servant in charge of the apathetic relief efforts?

Charles E. Trevelyan, the British civil servant in charge of the apathetic relief efforts, even viewed the famine as a divine solution to Hibernian overpopulation as he declared, “The judgement of God sent the calamity to teach the Irish a lesson, that calamity must not be too much mitigated.”.

What are some of the most famous stories of Ireland?

Through seven terrible years of famine, Ireland’s poetic landscape authored tales of the macabre. Barefoot mothers with clothes dripping from their bodies clutched dead infants in their arms as they begged for food. Wild dogs searching for food fed on human corpses. The country’s legendary 40 shades of green stained the lips of the starving who fed on tufts of grass in a futile attempt for survival. Desperate farmers sprinkled their crops with holy water, and hollow figures with eyes as empty as their stomach scraped Ireland’s stubbled fields with calloused hands searching for one, just one, healthy potato. Typhus, dysentery, tuberculosis and cholera tore through the countryside as horses maintained a constant march carting spent bodies to mass graves.

How many pounds of potatoes did the Irish eat?

They even ate them for breakfast. According to “ Irish Famine Facts ” by John Keating, the average adult working male in Ireland consumed a staggering 14 pounds of potatoes per day, while the average adult Irish woman ate 11.2 pounds. VIDEO — Deconstructing History: Ireland.

How many potatoes did the Irish eat in a year?

The Irish consumed 7 million tons of potatoes each year. They ate potatoes for dinner. They ate them for lunch. They even ate them for breakfast. According to “ Irish Famine Facts ” by John Keating, the average adult working male in Ireland consumed a staggering 14 pounds of potatoes per day, while the average adult Irish woman ate 11.2 pounds.

How many refugees from Ireland came to the United States?

Fleeing a shipwreck of an island, nearly 2 million refugees from Ireland crossed the Atlantic to the United States in the dismal wake of the Great Hunger. Beginning in 1845, the fortunes of the Irish began to sag along with the withering leaves of the country’s potato plants. Beneath the auld sod, festering potatoes bled a putrid red-brown mucus as ...

What were the refugees seeking haven in America?

The refugees seeking haven in America were poor and disease-ridden. They threatened to take jobs away from Americans and strain welfare budgets. They practiced an alien religion and pledged allegiance to a foreign leader. They were bringing with them crime. They were accused of being rapists. And, worst of all, these undesirables were Irish.

What did Anti-Catholics think of the Irish?

Anti-Catholics thought the Irish would not blend in, that they would always be Catholic first and American second. These fears prompted the terrible treatment of these immigrants that the meme of enslavement invokes even as it misrepresents.

What were the problems of the Irish?

The Irish, along with other immigrant groups, suffered from prejudice and poverty. They took low-paying jobs, lived in horrific urban slums and faced harassment from those in the larger society who resented their presence and their differences in language and religion. Download.

Why do white supremacists equate African slaves with Irish immigrants?

White supremacists equate African slaves with Irish immigrants as part of their effort to dismiss the historical experience of Africans in the United States. Just like the Irish of the 19th century, Muslims currently live in a society that thinks of them as an alien presence.

What is the Irish as slaves meme?

The Irish-as-slaves meme promotes a racist agenda. A meme circulating widely equates the enslavement of millions of Africans in the Americas over many centuries with the experience of Irish immigrant laborers, stating that the Irish too were enslaved.

Is the Irish/African meme a parallel?

The Irish experience in America does have a better modern parallel, however: today’s Muslim community in the United States.

Can non-Muslims be assimilated?

Many non-Muslim Americans look upon them as perpetually foreign, as a people who can never be assimilated. Peaceable, hardworking Muslims trying to make a life in the United States and facing ignorance and prejudice make a closer parallel to the Irish.

Did the Irish overcame oppression?

Subtly, too, the meme hints that the Irish overcame their oppression and therefore African Americans should as well. The descendants of Irish Catholics in fact blend in to American society, coming out to drink and parade for St. Patrick’s Day but otherwise living in ways that are indistinguishable from most white Americans. Why can’t African Americans do the same?

How were the Irish treated in America?

As immigrants to America, the Irish were treated poorly . Employment ads began to contain the phrase, "Irish need not apply." Boarding houses and other public establishment might display signs which read, " No dogs or Irish allowed." The Irish were blamed for outbreaks of disease. Anti-Irish and anti-Catholic riots broke out in New York and Boston. Churches, convents and orphanages were attacked and burned. Even black slaves were more highly regarded than the Irish.

What went against the Irish in America?

A few other things went against the Irish in America as well: 1. They were primarily, as Mescalhead noted, Roman Catholics. In the 19th century, calling yourself a Roman Catholic in Protestant America was like calling yourself a Communist in 20th century America.

What is the second largest ethnic group in the US?

According to the 2000 census, Americans with an Irish ethnic heritage are the second-largest ethnic group in the U.S., topping some 43 million (of a total population of 281 million, or about 15% of the population). Roman Catholics are now one of the largest Christian groups in the country; if you walk quietly near a 19th century American cemetery you can probably hear them spinning in their graves.

What was the English monarchy trying to supplant?

Also, the English Monarchy was trying to supplant any sort of Irish autonomy for centuries, which perpetuated a loathing of a people who were seen as industrially inferior and crude.

What were the Irish blamed for?

The Irish were blamed for outbreaks of disease. Anti-Irish and anti-Catholic riots broke out in New York and Boston. Churches, convents and orphanages were attacked and burned. Even black slaves were more highly regarded than the Irish. Riesstiu IV, Jan 25, 2004.

Where did Vrylakas say the colonials did not wish to be treated in the same manner as the Irish

Location: Bostonia . Vrylakas states that the colonials did not wish to be treated in the same manner as the Irish. One interpretation of that is the colonials did not want the colonies turned into a harsh recruiting ground for the Empire where an individuals best option is to join the military.

Did the British recruit American soldiers?

As for recruitment for the British military, that was almost never a concern for Americans , colonial or otherwise, with the possible exception of the 1796-1814 period when the Royal Navy purposely seized American sailors and impressed them into British service - but that was a political act. The 18th century British regularly gathered soldiers from Ireland indeed, but also from the slums of Britain itself. They however rarely harrassed the colonies for soldiers, except when local emergencies - like in the North American portion of the Seven Years War - required.

Why was religion used in Native American colonial life?

Religion was often used to justify the poor treatment of the natives. Both England’s economic system and religion led to Native American oppression. John Rolfe introduced tobacco to the colony of Jamestown, Virginia in 1612. Jamestown’s tobacco growers made a lot of money by trading tobacco with the Europeans.

Why did the colonists give up their land?

The Native Americans were forced to give up their lands so the colonists could grow even more tobacco. In addition to their desire for land, the English also used religion to justify bloodshed.

What were the Spanish conquistadors cruel to?

The Spanish conquistadors were unquestionably cruel to Native Americans. England’s colonists, however, were equally hostile toward the natives they encountered. The success of England’s colonies depended on the exploitation of Native Americans who were forced off their lands. Religion was often used to justify the poor treatment of the natives.

Did the Puritans believe God supported the extermination of the Pequot?

The Pequot had previously killed several English captains so the Puritans claimed God supported their extermination of the Pequot for the killing of Englishmen. Since they were Christians and the Pequot were seen as heathens, the Puritans felt justified in their actions. Like this: Like.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9