The difference between the two cross-examinations is Atticus shows respect and courtesy towards Mayella and Mr. Gilmer speaks to Tom Robinson disrespectfully and with contempt. To Kill a Mockingbird has a motif that shows kindness and disrespect existing in the same scene throughout the book.
How does Mr Gilmer treat Tom Robinson in court?
Mr. Gilmer is the prosecutor who faces off against Atticus in court. Scout thinks their rivalry is strictly a legal one, but Dill notices something else: while Atticus treats all the witnesses, even the Ewells, with respect, Mr. Gilmer treats Tom Robinson with a rudeness and contempt he doesn't show to the white witnesses.
How is Mr Gilmer treated in to kill a Mockingbird?
Despite representing the Ewells, Mr. Gilmer seems just as put off by them as everyone else in the courtroom. He treats Tom Robinson rudely during his questioning, which disturbs Dill. The To Kill a Mockingbird quotes below are all either spoken by Mr. Gilmer or refer to Mr. Gilmer.
What is the difference between Mr Gilmer and Atticus?
Expert Answers. The difference between the two cross-examinations is Atticus shows respect and courtesy towards Mayella and Mr. Gilmer speaks to Tom Robinson disrespectfully and with contempt. To Kill a Mockingbirdhas a motif that shows kindness and disrespect existing in the same scene throughout the book.
How does Atticus react to Gilmer's impugning of Mayella?
Atticus had to be respectful of Mayella while impugning her testimony; Gilmer wanted to be demeaning to Tom as a way of presenting the accused as worthless and guilty of something, whether that something was rape or simply being black.
How does Mr. Gilmer treat Mayella?
He addresses her as "ma'am" or "Miss Mayella." Even when contradicting her story, he uses only the facts, never her social class, to call her testimony into question. He is so courteous that Mayella, unused to such treatment, assumes he is mocking her.
What is the difference between Atticus and Mr. Gilmer?
Atticus is a different kind of lawyer then Mr. Gilmer because of their differences in their calmness, respect, and sensitivity. Unlike Mr Gilmer, Atticus is calm, respectful, and sensitive during the trial.
How does Gilmer treat Tom during questioning?
Despite representing the Ewells, Mr. Gilmer seems just as put off by them as everyone else in the courtroom. He treats Tom Robinson rudely during his questioning, which disturbs Dill.
What does Mr. Gilmer say to Tom?
Calling Tom “boy” and accusing him at every turn, the racist Mr. Gilmer believes that Tom must be lying, must be violent, must lust after white women—simply because he is black.
Why was it a mistake for Tom to say he was sorry for Mayella?
What "mistake" did Tom make by saying that he felt sorry for Mayella? He is supposed to be "lower" than her.
How old is Mayella in TKAM?
19Mayella Violet Ewell, 19, is the oldest of the eight Ewell children. Before the trial, Mayella is noted for growing red geraniums outside her otherwise dirty house to bring some beauty into her life.
What is Mr. Gilmer's tone towards Tom Robinson?
Gilmer is harsh and insulting. He does not talk about evidence or ask questions relevant to Tom's testimony. Instead, he insinuates that Tom "had [his] eye" on Mayella for a long time and that this was the reason Tom helped her with her chores around the Ewell house.
What does Scout explain about the relationship between Atticus and Mr. Gilmer What does this suggest about how each views his role in the trial?
Gilmer is the prosecutor who faces off against Atticus in court. Scout thinks their rivalry is strictly a legal one, but Dill notices something else: while Atticus treats all the witnesses, even the Ewells, with respect, Mr. Gilmer treats Tom Robinson with a rudeness and contempt he doesn't show to the white witnesses.
Does Atticus pity Mayella?
Atticus does not pity Mayella. He said he has pity for the chief witness, but that does not extend to her using Tom to get out of her own guilt of liking a black man. She broke a code of society and the guilt of that made her lie.
What two points does Mr Gilmer make in cross examining Tom?
What two points does Mr. Gilmer try to make in cross-examining Tom? Mr. Gilmer tries to prove that Tom was strong enough to rape Mayella even though he is disabled and that Tom ran because he was guilty.
What is Tom actually guilty of?
Tom is found guilty of raping Mayella although reasonable doubt and Tom's handicap is proven, HOWEVER, the jury deliberates for a few hours, which implies that they are considering the defense's testimony.
What does Tom say when Mr Gilmer asks him if Mayella is lying?
When Mr. Gilmer asks questions about that night, Tom refuses to accuse Mayella of lying, but persistently says that she is "mistaken in her mind" (19.135).
Who has to correct Mr. Gilmer?
Judge Taylor has to correct Mr. Gilmer to not try to prejudice the witness against counsel for the defense. There is never such a correction made toward Atticus. Atticus is more clever than Mr. Gilmer. He asks Mayella questions, but they are not sufficiently irrelevant or immaterial for Mr. Gilmer to object to them.
Is Mr. Gilmer as professional as Mr. Finch?
While both men do their jobs, Mr. Gilmer is not as professional as is Mr. Finch. For instance, after Mr. Gilmer finishes his questioning of Mayella, he says, "That's all...but you stay there. I expect big bad Mr. Finch has some questions to ask you.".
Does Atticus treat Tom Robinson with courtesy?
Atticus is always polite to the witnesses, despite how he may be treated by the witnesses, but Mr. Gilmer does not treat Tom Robinson with courtesy when he testifies truthfully. When, for instance, Tom testifies, Mr. Gilmer tries to twist Tom's meanings.
Who is the prosecutor in Tom Robinson's trial?
Mr. Gilmer. Next. Mrs. Grace Merriweather. The prosecutor in Tom Robinson ’s trial. He could be anywhere between 40 and 60 years old and Scout doesn’t know him well, as he’s from Abbottsville. Despite representing the Ewells, Mr. Gilmer seems just as put off by them as everyone else in the courtroom.
Who said "To Kill a Mockingbird"?
Mr. Gilmer Quotes in To Kill a Mockingbird. The To Kill a Mockingbird quotes below are all either spoken by Mr. Gilmer or refer to Mr. Gilmer. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one: ).
What chapter does Scout say Tom is just?
Gilmer spoke to Tom, calling him “boy” and sneering. Scout points out that Tom is “just... (full context) Chapter 21. ...when Scout assures Reverend Sykes that she knows exactly what Jem is talking about.
What do the colored dots and icons indicate in Chapter 17?
The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance. Chapter 17. ...Ewells, but he turns her attention to Mr. Tate’s testimony. Scout doesn’t know the solicitor, Mr. Gilmer , well, as he’s from Abbottsville and she and Jem seldom come to court.
