Treatment FAQ

how did medical treatment differ among europeans and muslims in the middle ages?

by Prof. Audra McLaughlin Jr. Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago

What were the contributions of the Middle Ages in medicine?

Scholars from this era made significant contributions in mathematics, science and medicine. Caliphs and physicians built hospitals that provided universal care and the foundation for medical education. Physician-scientists made significant advances in medical care, surgery and pharmacology.

How did the Crusades change the world of Medicine?

During the Crusades, many people traveled to the Middle East and learnt about scientific medicine from Arabic texts. These explained discoveries that Islamic doctors and scholars had made, based on Greek and Roman theories. In the Islamic World, Avicenna was writing “The Canon of Medicine.”

What was the Islamic view of Medicine?

In medieval times, Islamic thinkers elaborated the theories of the ancient Greeks and made extensive medical discoveries. There was a wide-ranging interest in health and disease, and Islamic doctors and scholars wrote extensively, developing complex literature on medication, clinical practice, diseases, cures, treatments, and diagnoses.

What was healthcare like in Europe during the Middle Ages?

Across Europe, the quality of medical practitioners was poor, and people rarely saw a doctor, although they might visit a local wise woman, or witch, who would provide herbs or incantations. Midwives, too, helped with childbirth.

What was European medicine like in the Middle Ages?

The practice of medicine in the early Middle Ages was empirical and pragmatic. It focused mainly on curing disease rather than discovering the cause of diseases. Often it was believed the cause of disease was supernatural. Nevertheless, secular approaches to curing diseases existed.

What was medical treatment like in the Middle Ages?

Surgery such as amputations, cauterization, removal of cataracts, dental extractions, and even trepanning (perforating the skull to relieve pressure on the brain) were practiced. Surgeons would have relied on opiates for anesthesia and doused wounds with wine as a form of antiseptic.

What was Islamic medicine like in the Middle Ages?

Medieval Islamic physicians performed more surgeries than their Greek and Roman predecessors, and they developed new tools and techniques. In the 10th century, Ammar ibn Ali al-Mawsili invented a hollow syringe that he used to remove cataracts by suction.

How did religion affect medicine in the Middle Ages?

Religion hindered the development of medicine to a partial extent because the Church prohibited dissections and people followed supernatural remedies. However, it established universities and hospitals to treat people as well. Religion did contribute positively to the progress of medicine by establishing hospitals.

Why was there little change in medicine in the Middle Ages?

Finally, there was a lack of progress in medicine during the middle ages because of a lack of scientific understanding. Due to Church control of medical training Physicians and medical students tried to make new discoveries fit into the older theories, rather than experimenting to explain the discoveries.

What was the reason of medical stagnation in Europe in middle age?

Medieval superstitions and Muslim knowledge Although many Medieval doctors continued to believe in the theory of the four humours, they also said disease was caused by demons, sin, bad smells, astrology and the stars, stagnant water, the Jewish people etc.

How did Islam affect medicine?

Although Ibn Sina made advances in pharmacology and in clinical practice, his greatest contribution was probably in the philosophy of medicine. He created a system of medicine that today we would call holistic and in which physical and psychological factors, drugs, and diet were combined in treating patients.

What was Islamic medicine?

Islamic medicine was an evidence based approach as exemplified by al-Rāzī and other Muslim physicians. Islamic medicine heralded a disciplinary model which included quarantine, hospitals and systematic clinical training. A point of comparison is that both medical approaches acknowledge the fitra of the human body.

What is the connection of medicine to the Islamic religion?

Islam considers human life sacred and suicide and euthanasia are forbidden. However, if a patient is suffering from a terminal condition and has been assessed as having no hope of recovery, it is permitted to stop medical treatment.

How did religion affect medicine?

Following the Egyptians, the Greeks and Romans saw Religious beliefs aid the development of medicine. Religious cults such as the Cult of Asclepious provided medical care for people who otherwise would not have been able to afford treatments.

How does religion affect medicine?

[1] Spirituality, experienced individually and/or within communal, religious forms, impacts patient well-being, satisfaction with care, medical decision-making and medical care outcomes. However, evidence demonstrates the medical profession largely neglects the spiritual dimension of patient well-being and illness.

How did they treat wounds in the Middle Ages?

Plinio used mineral remedies as lead and silver, Galen used spice ointments. These advances achieved in wound care and surgery for healing wounds by Hippocrates and Celsus were lost after the fall of the Roman Empire. In Europe, the middle ages were a regression of wound care back to potions and charms.

What was the role of cloistered monks in the development of medical science?

In western Europe, as the Latin language declined, cloistered monks became responsible for the care-taking and dissemination of medical literature.

What was the impact of the collapse of the Western Roman Empire on the early medieval world?

The collapse of the western Roman Empire brought barbarian invasions and the rise of warrior fiefdoms to Europe , both of which hampered civilization and its amenities—including the practice of scientific medicine. Medical care was provided in a practical fashion based ...

What did Galen teach about medicine?

Medieval European physicians (physics) based their medical care mainly upon the teachings of Galen of Pergamum (born c. a.d. 130 in what is now Bergama, Turkey). Galen's writings were prolific, and were based upon the relationship among the body's four humors, or bodily fluids (blood, phlegm, yellow bile, and black bile), and the four elements of external nature (earth, air, fire, and water). Galen taught that illness stems from an imbalance of the humors and the elements, and that restoring this balance would effect a cure. Galen described over 300 pharmaceutical remedies (mostly herbal concoctions), utilized bloodletting (phlebotomy), and depicted disease as an individual susceptibility rather than a general affectation. Galen took a reasoned approach to medicine based upon direct observation of the patient. Although Galen incorporated philosophy into medicine, his practical approach saw the physician as an attendant of the patient, rather than an intermediary seeking healing from spiritual sources. Galen's writings remained the dominant influence in medicine for almost a thousand years.

How many remedies did Galen use?

Galen described over 300 pharmaceutical remedies (mostly herbal concoctions), utilized bloodletting (phlebotomy), and depicted disease as an individual susceptibility rather than a general affectation. Galen took a reasoned approach to medicine based upon direct observation of the patient.

What is the Lorch book of medicine?

The Lorch Book of Medicine, written about 795 in a German Benedictine abbey, discussed the humors, and contains a brief text on simple anatomy and prognostics. The book also contained therapeutic recipes and dietary treatments, and other practical advice for tending the sick.

Why did midwives become popular?

The social status of midwives began to rise, and some villages paid the local midwife to act in an official capacity for cases involving women's illnesses, childbirth, and care of infants. Midwives were also called upon to certify virginity and infant deaths, and to provide treatment for infertility.

When did western medicine rebirth?

Not until the second millennium, around 1100, would the scholarly pursuit of medicine in western Europe experience a rebirth, when Greek and Arabic medical texts were brought to southern Italy and translated for the Latin-speaking cloistered West.

What did medieval Islamic doctors do?

The medieval Islamic world produced some of the greatest medical thinkers in history. They made advances in surgery, built hospitals, and welcomed women into the medical profession.

What was the Islamic culture of medicine?

Rather than being a subject in its own right, medicine was part of medieval Islamic culture. Centers of learning grew out of famous mosques, and hospitals were often added at the same site. There, medical students could observe and learn from more experienced doctors.

What were the contributions of Ibn Sina?

Among ibn Sina’s significant contributions to medieval medicine were “The Book of Healing,” an expansive scientific encyclopedia, and “The Canon of Medicine, ” which became essential reading at several medical schools around the world.

What were the influences of Islamic medicine?

Islamic medicine built upon the legacies of Greek and Roman physicians and scholars, including Galen, Hippocrates, and the Greek scholars of Alexandria and Egypt. Scholars translated medical literature from Greek ...

Why should a drug be tested on at least two distinct diseases?

They should test the medication on at least two distinct diseases, because sometimes a drug might treat one disease effectively and another one by accident. A drug’s quality must match the severity of the disease. For example, if the “heat” of a drug is less than the “coldness” of a disease, it will not work.

What did Islamic thinkers do in medieval times?

In medieval times, Islamic thinkers elaborated the theories of the ancient Greeks and made extensive medical discoveries. There was a wide-ranging interest in health and disease, and Islamic doctors and scholars wrote extensively, developing complex literature on medication, clinical practice, diseases, cures, treatments, and diagnoses.

Why did Islamic scholars order medicine?

Islamic scholars expertly gathered data and ordered it so that people could easily understand and reference information through various texts. They also summarized many Greek and Roman writings, compiling encyclopedias. Rather than being a subject in its own right, medicine was part of medieval Islamic culture.

What was the cradle of Arab medicine?

The bimaristan was, in short, the cradle of Arab medicine and the prototype upon which the modern hospital is based.

Who was the first to emphasize the value of mutual trust and consultation among skilled physicians in the treatment of patients?

Al-Razi was the first to emphasize the value of mutual trust and consultation among skilled physicians in the treatment of patients, a rare practice at that time. Following his term as hospital director in Baghdad, he returned to Rayy where he taught the healing arts in the local hospital, and he continued to write.

What language was spoken in the 10th century?

By the 10th century a single language linked peoples from the Rann of Kutch to the south of France, and Arabic became to the East what Latin and Greek had been to the West—the language of literature, the arts and sciences, and the common tongue of the educated.

Why did the Catholic Church ban surgery?

In the middle of the seventh century, the Catholic church banned surgery by monks, because it constituted a danger to their souls.

Why was mortification of the flesh important?

Because the Christian church viewed care of the soul as far more important than care of the body, medical treatment and even physical cleanliness were little valued, and mortification of the flesh was seen as a sign of saintliness.

What was the center of Europe's new world view?

The center of Europe’s new world view became the church, which exerted profound new influences in medicine. Because Christianity emphasized compassion and care for the sick, monastic orders ran fine hospitals—but they did not function as hospitals do today.

Who laid out the rules for testing the effectiveness of a new drug or medication?

In his voluminous writings, Ibn Sina laid out the following rules for testing the effectiveness of a new drug or medication. These principles still form the basis of modern clinical drug trials.

What was medical knowledge in the Middle Ages?

Medical knowledge in the Middle Ages must have appeared to have stood still. While the Ancient Romans, Greeks and Egyptians had pushed forward medical knowledge, after the demise of these civilisations, the momentum started by these people tended to stagnate and it did not develop at the same pace until the Seventeenth/Eighteenth Centuries.

What was the result of Galen's refusal to take what Hippocrates had stated at face value?

As a result of this refusal to take what Galen and Hippocrates had stated at face value some progress was made in the medical world during this time . However, medicine became steeped in superstition and the Roman Catholic Church effectively dominated what direction the medical world took.

What did the Catholic Church say about illnesses?

Therefore, when the Roman Catholic Church stated that illnesses were punishments from God and that those who were ill were so because they were sinners, few argued otherwise.

What was the name of the university in the 14th century?

The University of Montpelier was one such university.

What was Mondino's book on anatomy?

Mondino’s book on the anatomy, “Anathomia”, still relied on observations made by Galen and other Greek writers of medicine. No-one knew what really caused diseases. For the Roman Catholic Church they were a punishment from God for sinful behaviour. However, some progress was made in certain areas.

What was the name of the medical treatment that was used in the Middle Ages?

Ultimately, this led to the creation of some very excruciating medical treatments. 1. Eye Surgery. Loading... Loading... During the early days of the Middle Ages, surgeons used a painful process calledNeedling” to perform cataract surgery. It involved a thick flat needle, which a doctor would push directly into the edge of a person’s cornea, ...

What was the Middle Ages?

The Middle Ages was a time full of interesting history, rich art, revolutionizing philosophy, epic heroes, and even a bit of magic. However, it was not a very pleasant period to be a medical patient. The common way to relieve pain amongst sick people was to inflict more pain upon them, and then hope to the stars for a bit of luck.

Why were catheters used in medieval times?

Catheters were used in medieval times to relieve painful urinary diseases. Back in those days, there was a lack of antibiotics and a surplus of venereal viruses such as syphilis, so many people suffered from the woes of blocked bladders. The medieval catheter consisted of a metal tube, which was painfully inserted through the urethra, ...

What was the medieval catheter?

The medieval catheter consisted of a metal tube, which was painfully inserted through the urethra, and then into the bladder. When a tube could not enter the bladder of a person, doctors used other equally painful tactics.

What did monks do to humans?

Monks with little to no experience, aside from castrating animals and having access to a few medical books, performed surgery on human beings. The medicine was basic, and the terrible illness that plagued those times was complex. Ultimately, this led to the creation of some very excruciating medical treatments. 1.

What was the practice of letting blood flow freely into a container?

If a patient went in with a mild headache and a sore throat, it was common practice for a physician to open a vein with a lancet, and then let the blood flow freely into a container. Bloodletting was so common, that even barbers of the era began to offer the service, along with stylish trims and shaves.

What diseases did the Middle Ages have?

Some of the most notorious illnesses of the Middle Ages were the plague (the Black Death), leprosy, and Saint Anthony’s fire. From 1346, the plague ravaged Europe, and rich and poor alike succumbed with terrifying speed ( 69.86 ).

What did the medicus do in a monastery?

The medicus in a monastery would have devoted himself to prayer, the laying on of hands, exorcizing of demons, and of course the dispensing of herbal medicine. The hospital of Santa Maria della Scala in Siena was initially administered by the canons of the cathedral ( 23.166; 16.154.5 ).

What was the name of the plague that ravaged Europe?

From 1346, the plague ravaged Europe, and rich and poor alike succumbed with terrifying speed ( 69.86 ). Pneumonic plague attacked the lungs and bubonic plague produced the characteristic buboes; there was no cure for either form. The only hope for those who escaped the dread disease was prayer or pilgrimage.

What was the name of the school of anatomy in the Middle Ages?

By 1340, the university at Montpellier included a school of anatomy. In 1140, Roger of Sicily forbade anyone from practicing medicine without a license, indicating that doctors were clearly under some form of regulation. In the late Middle Ages, apothecary shops opened in important towns.

What did Galen do to help Hippocrates?

To further his understanding of bodily functions, he performed animal and even human dissections and was able to demonstrate that the arteries carried blood rather than air.

What museum is the Department of Medieval Art and the Cloisters in?

Department of Medieval Art and The Cloisters, The Metropolitan Museum of Art. January 2012. In the second century, Origen wrote, “For those who are adorned with religion use physicians as servants of God, knowing that He himself gave medical knowledge to men, just as He himself assigned both herbs and other things to grow on the earth.”.

Who said the pulsing of the veins reveals the patient's ailment just as the

In fact, in the sixth century, Cassiodorus wrote that “for a skilled physician the pulsing of the veins reveals [to his fingers] the patient’s ailment just as the appearance of urine indicates it to his eyes.”.

What was the Islamic presence in Spain?

Islamic presence in Spain appeared at a very early juncture during the evolution of the major Muslim dynasties. The presence of the Umayyad Dynasty, which began in Damascus in the middle eighth century and continued in Spain until the eleventh century, put Muslim Spain (known as al-Andalus or Andalusia) into commercial contact with the North African coast, Palestine, and Syria. This led to the development of flourishing trade centers and a period of artistic and intellectual growth. Under the Umayyads, Jewish merchants enjoyed more tolerance than in Christian states, although persecution increased with the arrival of the Almoravids in the eleventh century and the Almohads in the twelfth, each of whom brought their own cultures and customs to the interpretation of Islam. There were also major religious divisions within Islam that began to emerge after 1000. The Sunni and Shi'ite positions, which go back to seventh-century disputes over the requirements for who might succeed the prophet Muhammad as caliph and still divide Islam today, became strongly linked to ideological and political separations dictating the way Islam would be practiced and perceived. The Sunni, who were in the majority, most often preferred to be directed by teachers, scholars, preachers, and government officials. They subscribed to interpretations of an eternal and uncreated Koran, the word of Allah, which was to be obeyed without question, but expressed concepts of an Allah that could not be completely known to humankind. The Shi'ites, making up roughly a fifth of medieval Muslims, had migrated toward stricter and even more literal interpretations of Islamic law and ideology, as well as relying upon religious leadership that was more charismatic. The mystical branch of Islam called Sufism, which began as more of a monastic movement in the eighth and ninth centuries, became popular among individuals who rejected the formalized trappings of Islamic religious life and were looking for more inward and personal expressions concerning their relationship with Allah.

Which group of merchants enjoyed more tolerance than Christian states?

Under the Umayyads, Jewish merchants enjoyed more tolerance than in Christian states, although persecution increased with the arrival of the Almoravids in the eleventh century and the Almohads in the twelfth, each of whom brought their own cultures and customs to the interpretation of Islam.

Why were there no priests in Islam?

There were no priests with sacramental powers in Islam, as individuals were considered accountable directly to Allah and needed no spiritual intermediaries. Any devout Muslim could lead prayer, so that all were regarded as equal in the eyes of Allah. However, certain dynasties subscribed to the notion of a mahdi (that is, a divinely guided savior or messiah) who might bring justice and righteousness to the earth, restoring the true and proper message of Allah, if one would only follow his lead. The observance of religious law became most important, particularly as a variety of dynasties began to compete with each other for political control of Arabia, Persia, North Africa, Spain, and Asia Minor. As early as the eighth century, Muslim schools sprang up which were devoted to examining the roots of Muslim law. This process was called ijtihad, meaning a strenuous examination. Sunni schools of religious law called madhhabs began to emerge which would establish norms for Muslim practice. Four distinct schools came into being at the major centers of Damascus, Medina, Baghdad, and al-Andalus. The growth of learning centers and formalized education as well as interest in mathematics, astronomy, and philosophy began to create divisions in Islam and give rise to a host of theological debates. Unlike the Christian scholars, the organization of knowledge for medieval Muslims took in separate religious and non-religious categories. However, like Christian scholastics, there were prominent Muslim philosophers, such as Al-Ghazali (b. 1058) in Baghdad, Averroës (1126–1198) in Spain, and Avicenna (980–1037) in Persia, who struggled to reconcile the notions of faith and human reason. The numerous advances of Muslim thinkers had important influence on philosophers in the Christian West. Based upon the works of the Greek philosopher Aristotle, Islamic examination of natural and metaphysical truths attempted to link everything in the universe to Allah.

How many people converted to Islam in 1000?

By the year 1000 it is believed that nearly eighty percent of the population in the Dar-al-Islam (Islamic territory) had converted to faith in Allah as it had been revealed to the Prophet Muhammad in the seventh century and handed down through succeeding generations by way of the holy Koran (Qur'an).

What is the most important religious act?

However, the most important religious act was that of simple belief, reciting the creed or confession of faith ( shahadah ), that "there is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is His prophet.". Almsgiving ( zakat) was also expected of Muslims, charity both to the poor and in support of religious institutions.

What was the law of the ninth century?

Added to this law was the ijma or traditions of historic Islamic communities.

Why was religious law important?

The observance of religious law became most important, particularly as a variety of dynasties began to compete with each other for political control of Arabia, Persia, North Africa, Spain, and Asia Minor. As early as the eighth century, Muslim schools sprang up which were devoted to examining the roots of Muslim law.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9