Common law dictates that individuals possess autonomy and self-determination, which encompass the right to accept or refuse medical treatment. Management of medical treatment can be complicated in situations when the ability of the patient to make reasonable decisions is called into question.
Full Answer
Can a patient have the capacity to make some decisions?
Aug 13, 1999 · Severely depressed patients may underestimate the benefits of treatment or overestimate the risks of treatment, interfering with rational decision making. 46 Some patients with severe depression may favor a high-risk medical intervention, viewing potential risks as a desirable outcome to end their misery. 1 Hopelessness is common in the depressed patient …
Will patients become increasingly involved in making treatment decisions?
A number of factors related to cancer care necessitate a patient-centered approach to communication: (1) cancer care is extremely complex and patients' treatment choices have serious implications for their health outcomes and quality of life; (2) the evidence supporting many decisions in cancer care is limited or incomplete; and (3) trade-offs ...
Do patients'preferences matter in making medical decisions?
Capacity refers to the functional determination of whether an individual patient has the ability to adequately make a specific decision, such as financial decisions, or perform a specific task, such as driving 27. In contrast, competency is the legal determination of whether an impaired mental capacity limits a patient’s ability to make a ...
Does complex medical information overload the patient’s decision-making capacity?
Sep 06, 2003 · “There's not enough time”—The pressure of time is a perpetual challenge; doctors are particularly concerned about the implications of informing patients without allowing extra time for this. 5 However, involving patients more in treatment decisions may have no significant effect on consultation length 3: adequate discussion at an early stage may allow more succinct …
What are some factors that affect clinical decision-making?
Five main themes emerged from the data. From the participants' points of view, 'feeling competent', 'being self-confident', 'organizational structure', 'nursing education', and 'being supported' were considered as important factors in effective clinical decision-making.Apr 6, 2004
What are the limitations of informed consent?
Evidently informed consent cannot be relevant to all medical decisions, because it cannot be provided by patients who are incompetent to consent, cannot be used in choosing public health policies, cannot be secured for all disclosure of third party information, and cannot be obtained from those who are vulnerable or ...
What factors should be used in determining a patient's ability to make decisions?
Patients have medical decision-making capacity if they can demonstrate understanding of the situation, appreciation of the consequences of their decision, and reasoning in their thought process, and if they can communicate their wishes.Jul 1, 2018
What do you do when a patient Cannot make a decision?
When a patient lacks decision-making capacity, the physician has an ethical responsibility to: Identify an appropriate surrogate to make decisions on the patient's behalf: The person the patient designated as surrogate through a durable power of attorney for health care or other mechanism.
What can limit patients exercise of informed consent?
The practice of informed consent is complicated by several well-documented limitations. These constraints include patient comprehension, patient use of disclosed information, patient autonomy, the demands placed on health care providers and how well physicians meet the minimal standards for disclosure.
What are barriers to consent?
Patient-centered barriers to informed consent (such as age, education, and illness) and process-centered barriers (such as content and readability of the consent form, timing of discussion, and amount of time allotted to the process) can affect an individual's ability to provide substantial informed consent.
What are three 3 key issues facing our health care system today?
8 Major Problems With the U.S. Healthcare SystemPreventable Medical Errors.Poor Amenable Mortality Rates.Lack of Transparency.Difficulty Finding a Good Doctor.High Costs of Care.A Lack of Insurance Coverage.The Nursing and Physician Shortage.A different perspective on solving the shortage crisis.More items...
What are the four functional abilities patients must have to demonstrate capacity?
In addition to performing a mental status examination (along with a physical examination and laboratory evaluation, if needed), four specific abilities should be assessed: the ability to understand information about treatment; the ability to appreciate how that information applies to their situation; the ability to ...Jul 15, 2001
What do you do if a patient lacks capacity?
If an adult lacks the capacity to give consent, a decision about whether to go ahead with the treatment will need to be made by the healthcare professionals treating them. To make a decision, the person's best interests must be considered.
What decisions Cannot be made on behalf of a person who lacks capacity?
Some types of decisions (such as marriage or civil partnership, divorce, sexual relationships, adoption and voting) can never be made by another person on behalf of a person who lacks capacity.
When people can't make their own decisions?
Mental Capacity Act Sometimes people have difficulty in making decisions for themselves. The ability to make decisions is called "mental capacity" and there are lots of reasons why someone may lack mental capacity temporarily or all of the time, such as illness, brain injury or mental health.
How can you support a person who is legally unable to make decisions?
Giving the person relevant information to make the decision. Keep the information only to what is needed. Describe any foreseeable risks and benefits in practical terms. If there are options, give the information about the choices in a clear and balanced way.
What are the characteristics of palliative care?
Palliative care has the following characteristics: 1 Care is provided and services are coordinated by an interdisciplinary team; 2 Patients, families, and palliative and non-palliative health care clinicians collaborate and communicate about care needs; 3 Services are available concurrently with or independent of curative or life-prolonging care; and 4 Clinicians respect their patients and families' dignity throughout the course of illness, during the dying process, and after death.
What is the risk of BRCA 1 and 2?
Women with BRCA 1and 2gene mutations are at higher risk for developing breast and ovarian cancer , and may face difficult decisions about breast cancer screening, as well as consideration of prophylactic mastectomy or oophorectomy to reduce the risk of cancer3(Jolie, 2013; Schwartz et al., 2009).
How does cancer affect emotional health?
The emotional repercussions of a cancer diagnosis can prevent patients from engaging in effective communication with their clinicians about their diagnosis and treatment. Patients can become anxious; feel vulnerable, alone, and fearful; and experience feelings of losing control when receiving a cancer diagnosis.
What are the patient related factors?
Patient-related factors. One set of variables is patient related. In the most obvious case, a patient who is unconscious lacks capacity to make even the most basic decisions. A patient who is under the influence of alcohol or hallucinogenic drugs may lack capacity for most decisions.
When talking about informed consent, one should distinguish between research and clinical care.
There is a difference between the role of investigator and the role of clinician, and between physician-patient and investigator-participant relationships [1, 2]. Although the ideas we explore in this essay could be relevant to either research or clinical contexts, we will focus on clinical contexts—specifically, the implications of our ideas for informed consent for clinical care in situations in which informed consent may not be an appropriate approach to decision making.
Why is informed consent not feasible?
Given the primacy of the ethical injunction to avoid patient harm, we therefore argue that in situations in which informed consent is not feasible because a patient’s decision-making capacity is overwhelmed, a clinician should consider shifting from prioritizing informed consent to protecting her patient.
What is informed consent?
Informed consent happens when a patient authorizes a medical procedure or intervention based on understanding of the risks, benefits, and alternatives [4, 5]. This process assures respect for the free decisions of autonomous individuals, a duty that derives from the moral principle of respect for persons. A valid process of informed consent requires four things: voluntariness (the decision is free from coercion or undue influences), disclosure (the clinician’s sharing of information relevant to the patient’s decision), understanding (appreciating the risks, benefits, and nature of the procedure), and capacity (the ability to engage in reasoned deliberation, comparing the risks and benefits of the procedure with personal life goals) [4, 5].
Where is Johan Bester?
Johan Bester, MBChB, MPhil is a member of the professional staff of the Department of Bioethics at the Cleveland Clinic in Cleveland, Ohio, where he conducts clinical ethics consultations, teaches bioethics, and engages in bioethics scholarship. Johan is also a PhD candidate in applied ethics at the Stellenbosch University, South Africa.
Is capacity decision specific?
Therefore, it is only in terms of a particular decision for which informational overload makes informed consent impossible that the clinician should focus on protecting the patient. This conclusion has far-reaching implications for decision making about genetic sequencing tests.
What influences informed consent?
Informed consent depends on capacity. Capacity can be influenced by patient factors, information factors, and communication factors. Upon reflection, it seems possible that certain types of information overwhelm the decisional capacity of patients who have no patient factors impacting their capacity.